6 ms·
The battle over similar issues in Texas has also been fun: • Amazon has a distribution center in Irving, Texas but argued its clever legal structure freed it
by gojomo 15y ago
The battle over similar issues in Texas has also been fun:
• Amazon has a distribution center in Irving, Texas but argued its clever legal structure freed it from having to pay sales taxes.
• The Republican Comptroller Susan Combs insisted on payment of a past tax bill, based on these operations.
• Amazon said it'd thus need to close the facility, and Republican Governor Rick Perry announced his opposition to the Comptroller's decision.
• The Republican-dominated legislature then passed a bill, similar to this California bill, further establishing Amazon's sales tax obligations, for not just the distribution center but the affiliates.
• Perry vetoed it.
• Amazon's hometown newspaper, the Seattle Times, then editorialized that it should stop dodging state sales taxes nationwide.
• The Texas legislature started working on a veto-proof way to obligate Amazon, perhaps by attaching the obligation to a larger budget bill.
• Amazon offered the legislature a bigger new distribution center, with 5000 (and then 6000) new jobs, in return for a full legislative exemption from sales taxes for the next few years.
The part-time legislature, which usually only meets every other year and (with no state income tax) takes sales taxes very seriously, has so far declined Amazon's offers.
Some of the coverage:
http://www.techflash.com/seattle/2011/02/texas-governor-backs-amazon-seattle.html http://www.techflash.com/seattle/2011/02/texas-governor-back...
http://www.statesman.com/news/texas-politics/amazon-sweetens-job-offer-texas-lawmakers-dont-bite-1558831.html http://www.statesman.com/news/texas-politics/amazon-sweetens...
- impendia 15y agoGood for Texas. Elsewhere on HN, I've read Amazon's claim that they would be happy to pay sales taxes, but that dealing with all the local taxing authorities would be a nightmare. If this is true, it makes me quite sympathetic to their position. But if I understood you right, it looks like Amazon outright attempted to bribe the legislature for special treatment which other retailers in the state don't get. I realize this kind of shit happens all the time, but that doesn't make it right. And the Texas legislature refused to play ball. If I lived in Texas I would be standing in line to re-elect these people.
- unshift 15y agowhy? i'd rather keep the money than give it to the state. why vote for people who want to tax you more? i realize it's nice to believe in integrity but i don't think this is an example of it
- sukuriant 15y agoTax money goes to good locations, and things you or people you know use every day. Roads, schools, and the local law enforcement come to mind.
- unshift 15y agoah - you don't live in massachusetts then :-)
- sukuriant 15y agoUsed to live in Florida. Immaculate roads, whenever they were finished, and a school system that desperately needed more money than it was given.
- jmaygarden 15y agoI live in Florida. We are middle of the pack as far as per student funding goes. Since $10,878 per student per year is insufficient, what funding level would you recommend? http://www2.census.gov/govs/school/07f33pub.pdf http://www2.census.gov/govs/school/07f33pub.pdf
- OstiaAntica 15y agoTax money is taken from good locations, and goes to the prison industrial complex, failing schools, and corrupt public employee unions.
- sukuriant 15y agoFailing schools, in part because of their lack of funding.
- techsupporter 15y agoIt appears that the measure died. The enrolled form of SB1 (the Fiscal Matters bill) that was sent to the Governor today doesn't seem to include the sales tax provision.