9 ms·
The importance of resumes has been overstated for many years now, and I look forward to the day they are phased out entirely. Minor grammar changes are not what
by paxys 6y ago
The importance of resumes has been overstated for many years now, and I look forward to the day they are phased out entirely. Minor grammar changes are not what is making the difference between getting an interview or not. Years' worth of work cannot be distilled down to 2 lines on a piece of paper, and recruiters/hiring managers already know this.
Employers are looking at your education, companies you worked at, years of experience, and maybe a vague idea of what your work area was before this. Just this info is enough to make a decision for whether to call you for an interview, and after that the resume is useless.
- benrbray 6y ago> after that the resume is useless Literally! I can count on one hand the number of interviewers who have asked me about my past work experience. The most important thing seems to be whether I can regurgitate various tree operations on a whiteboard. It's only a matter of time before they cut out the middle man and start hiring candidates by (university_ranking, hackerrank_ranking) in lexical order without as much as an interview.
- baoluofu 6y agoThat seems crazy to me! Whenever I conduct interviews questions about specific situations from their past experience are most of what I ask. "Tell me about a time when..." I find they can very quickly uncover potential red flags. They can also lead to interesting discussions that leave both me and the candidate enthused about progressing to the next stage.
- xx789 6y ago> Employers are looking at your education, companies you worked at, years of experience, and maybe a vague idea of what your work area was before this. Isn't this what a resume is? Just the list of those things that Employers want to look at.
- jsemrau 6y agoDoesn't it also give you an overview of someone's life-choices?
- paxys 6y agoIt isn't what most people think a resume should be, looking at the very article we are discussing as well all the "resume consulting/polishing" services out there. Plus, employers are anyways going to make you fill out all this info separately in their recruiting system.
- baoluofu 6y agoWhen I look at a CV I want to see someone's achievements, ideally quantified. What are they proud of, how have they helped their previous teams/products/companies to succeed, are they passionate about what they do.
- vmception 6y agoFor software engineers, even all the extracurricular software activities is useless! Its like sure maybe have a public github, but the only endgame from actually contributing to a project is just an imagination that you'll stand out for a recruiter to actually say hello. It doesn't give you a leg up on any hiring manager decision, you have to solve the silly algorithm problems, system design and behavior interview just like everyone else! The recruiter was already open to saying hello just because you said you can code for other people.
- lmiller1990 6y agoNot sure I agree with this one. Over the last few years, I've had tons of consulting work purely from my activity in the OSS ecosystem. I also got my last two jobs because of my activity in the OSS ecosystem. "... I saw your GH profile and noticed you have significant contributions to XXX, we'd love to have you join the team". I didn't have to do any algorithm questions for those organizations.
- vmception 6y ago> I didn't have to do any algorithm questions for those organizations. okay. many organizations would not make that exception. and there are many stewards of key open source dependencies that have talked about how they couldn't pass interviews to places that heavily use their software.
- toast0 6y ago> even all the extracurricular software activities is useless! I'm one of the jerks who does a coding interview; but for the people who do interviews on what you've done, having something on your resume that you can talk about is a good thing. Interviewers want to hear that you've got deep experience in something and can explain what you did at a high level and in detail. If you've got that from work experience, great; if not, something you did independently is nice too; otherwise it's got to be coming from classwork, which is ok, but kind of iffy. Ideally, two, maybe three projects you can talk about is good to touch on in the resume.
- tomnipotent 6y ago> Employers are looking at your education People can be petty. I've seen no shortage of candidates get passed on because of spelling mistakes or something equally silly, and it happens a lot more than you'd like to think. Maybe the resume reviewer is having a bad day, or their dad told them "people that do X are dumb" and so anytime they see X they think someone is dumb. I've even worked at places that fast-tracked candidates from USC because the founders were from there. People are biased, and those biases will come across.
- sidpatil 6y agoIt could also be because they're looking for easy ways to filter out candidates if the applicant pool is particularly large. Think of it as dimensionality reduction—many people claim to be detail-oriented, but mistakes on a resume are an easy way for reviewers to verify that claim.
- tomnipotent 6y ago> because they're looking for easy But they're not easy ways. There's absolutely no correlation between resume quality and candidate performance, and they're just idiosyncrasies we develop over time. We trick ourselves into believing these signals are important, when they're not.
- imiric 6y ago> There's absolutely no correlation between resume quality and candidate performance I don't think that's entirely true. The resume is a product of a potential hire, and it gives off the first impression of their organizational and writing skills. While it shouldn't be the _only_ deciding factor, that first impression is an important signal for a hiring manager who has to filter potentially hundreds of candidates.
- tomnipotent 6y ago> The resume is a product of a potential hire That's like saying a first date is in indication of a couples future. It's a bit silly. Sure, if it's absolutely chock-full of errors that could be a sign, but one or two are the kind of things you're supposed to ignore. > that first impression is an important signal for a hiring manager Only because people have been trained to judge others based on petty things, so people have responded in kind. Not because it's actually a valuable effort, but to give people one less reason to throw it in the "No" pile.
- abraae 6y agoResumes have been on the verge of death for decades now, yet they are still with us. Yes, once you get in the door and get an interview the resume is worthless. Except it's not. The interviewer may need to run you past someone else. Will he/she reach for their carefully curated interview notes and pass those on? No, because they haven't written them up, or they can't be emailed, or the recruitment system is rubbish or [some reason]. But the resume is still there, a nice Word doc or pdf that can be easily emailed around. Source: too many years building recruitment systems.
- ekianjo 6y agoResumes are still needed to get you to interviews so they are never going to disappear... Plus you seem to forget that HR uses resumes to filter candidates even before the hiring manager ever sees anything.
- Aeolun 6y ago> Employers are looking at your education, companies you worked at, years of experience, and maybe a vague idea of what your work area was before this. Speak for yourself. The biggest signal I have when deciding whether to call you for an interview is your resume. I have never considered education so far. There’s 2 states: I know the school, and I don’t know the school. I’ve never known any school so far. Anyway, your resume decides how enthusiastic I’m going to be when starting your interview. Which is going to make things easier when that time comes.
- grecy 6y ago> I have never considered education so far. Surely though a B. Eng. Software with first class honors is better than a random science degree.. ?
- Aeolun 6y agoMaybe? As far as I’ve found there is zero correlation between education and competency, at least in the candidates I’ve interviewed. This is mostly in the Asia/Pacific region though, it might be different elsewhere.
- busterarm 6y agoI'm in a senior position with no degree and the absolute best engineers I have ever worked with almost all have music degrees. Edit: it's also worth noting as an ex-hedgie that in technical roles most of the firms specifically filter for people with musical ability for this reason.
- whatshisface 6y agoThe best people in any field are the ones that passed the harshest filter, and pole vaulting from music to programming is about as demanding as it gets.
- busterarm 6y agoNot as much as you'd think. Most of them had a specialty in computer music which leans heavily on building your own tools/instruments. But I agree with you.
- jesterson 6y agoAs others already pointing out, seems like you're making huge generalisation here, which appears to be incorrect. Being on employers side, I give little-to-no attention to education. Seen MBAs with no critical thinking or skills whatsoever and dropouts with very diligent and knowledgeable approaches. For me, resume is not just a boring list of what you did, but also the way it is written - lucidity, points emphasised, etc. It all speaks loudly of personality. And yea, if there are grammar mistakes it most likely will go to bin. Not because I particularly value grammar (which I do not) but because resume is usually supposed to be diligently written/reread by the candidate. If he/she didn't bother to do that properly - the damn thing that potentially land him/her job - this negligence says for itself, further projects, had there been any, will not be cared properly. That's my opinion which is in no way representative or absolute in it's truth. I'd like just to pinpoint that there may be few opinions on the matter.
- thomasahle 6y ago> For me, resume is not just a boring list of what you did, but also the way it is written - lucidity, points emphasised, etc. It all speaks loudly of personality. Do you require the candidates to have written the resume themselves? Otherwise it's risky to read so much personality into it. Resumes are usually required to be truthful, sometimes this is even verified, but I've never seen a requirement that I can't just have an agent write it for me; like how students write essays.
- zimpenfish 6y ago> Do you require the candidates to have written the resume themselves? Otherwise it's risky to read so much personality into it. Especially problematic when recruiters are known for rejigging resumes into their own format, etc., before passing it onto the client.
- jesterson 6y agoThey don't usually jiggle with text, just match it with corporate forms. Substance will still be there.
- kodah 6y ago> Employers are looking at your education I don't look at education at all, unless you're an intern or within your second job out of college. It's an unnecessary gate to talent, imo.