5 ms·
Just as there are some people who seem to be remarkably resistant to e.g. opiate addiction, I find myself wondering if there are people who are resistant to wha
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
Just as there are some people who seem to be remarkably resistant to e.g. opiate addiction, I find myself wondering if there are people who are resistant to whatever mechanism drives the "addiction" to social media (particularly likes).
My wife does way more conventional social media than me (given that I never use FB or Insta, that's not hard), but as far as I can tell she's fairly impervious to the whole ratings game. For her, it really is just a communication mechanism. I'm not 100% sure about this, but fairly sure.
Maybe we're just hearing about the majority (?) of humans that get helplessly trapped in this stuff, causing us to ignore the minority who can dip and out of it with ease.
- bogota 6y agoIt would be interesting to take a random sample of Facebook/Instagram/Twitter users and remove the ability to see likes for a few months and see what engagement and post frequency looks like. I have a feeling the companies might already know.
- Barrin92 6y agoWell you can I guess for a rough estimate compare your own use of say HN to websites with gamified mechanisms. From my own experience with Reddit HN is considerably less addictive and I attribute it to a large degree to the lack of instant notifications, the plain design and the diminished visibility of up- and downvotes.
- mardifoufs 6y agoUp here in Canada we already can't see likes on Instagram posts and I'm not sure I've seen any difference w. r. t content posted (even from mainly local accs that only deal with a Canadian audience)
- bogota 6y agoCan’t see the number of likes or can’t see that it is liked at all? I have a feeling removing the number helps but I know a few people who like to scroll through all the likes they get.
- emerged 6y agoI went a span of years addicted to a form of social media. After all sorts of silly drama when the dust settled I became completely uninterested. I’d imagine some people have natural immunity and some, like me, had to learn it the hard way. I’m hoping eventually over time there will be the equivalent to herd immunity. But it’s just wishful thinking.
- swiley 6y agoSo what you're saying is I should turn off noprocrast and drown my ego in hackernews karma while I get fired from my job? :p
- kirubakaran 6y agoThere is only one way to find out. Be sure to post your findings here.
- throwaway2037 6y agoThank you for this very honest post. Could you share what made you aware of this personal trend ("addiction") and its negative impacts? It might be helpful to others.
- btkramer9 6y agoI'm hesitant to declare this about myself because of all the biases that can be at play and what not but I generally feel I may be similar. Sure once I make a post I'll check back for responses/likes but it's never on my mind when I create the post. More importantly I never find myself wanting to post anything. In fact its borderline difficult. I hate having to put my thoughts down and try to be conscious of how other's might perceive this. This is becoming increasingly frustrating as I type this right now. I generally feel like I have nothing significant enough to say to put myself through the effort to write it down. I much prefer verbal. Maybe it's not so much a resistance to social media addiction as much as it is despising the process of writing.
- exikyut 6y agoFWIW I incidentally feel very similarly. I can write reasonably effectively (if longwindedly), but if I'm particularly invested in a subject I curiously just don't want to figure out where to start because the whole process feels utterly overwhelming. A few things come to mind that might be related. Firstly, (I think that) parts of my thinking/reasoning process route through and leverage the language center of my brain like a crutch, or a like sequence of stepping stones, that my brain somehow uses in order to stay focused and retain my train of thought. I've found that the whole talk-to-the-air/sounding out thing public speakers do has helped me to better elucidate ideas. In that context, I'll talk about something as though it already exists. Independently of all that, I also find I reason about a few ideas or topics using a sort of indeterminate/open-ended/unconditional focus model that seems to have a bunch of cues associated with it that allow me to carefully isolate the focus process from the traditional "oh meep, solve problem... yay, done!" beginning/middle/end reward cycle, such that I just find myself pondering the ideas on occasion, then naturally drift away when they become boring without associating them with the friction of mental exhaustion in the same way that I tend to do with almost everything (including the discussion topics in the previous paragraph). Critically, I don't tend to reason about the second group of things using language, instead using nameless compound associations I typically perceive as instantaneous point recollections of That One Time I Thought Of A Thing. So it seems I have writing and "funnel entire thought process through language center" on one side, and complex problem solving, ideation, long-term focus retention aaaand unfortunately _memory_ on the other side, of a rift I've been puzzling over for years. (Naturally, if I try to reason about any of those instantaneous recollections, they fragment like waking up from a dream. I've learned to leave them alone, and just try to stumble into them a lot. Not a very effective method.) This whole issue makes writing about those particularly/exceptionlly-interesting ideas next to impossible: because this rift creates the equivalent of a block against sensible random access to all of those memories, I can only write one-dimensionally about a single element of a given idea that I know I have a much deeper understanding of... and the result is that it feels pointless. Hm. I just realized this is way more specific than I thought it would be before I wrote it out. (Caveat emptor.) I'm now very curious if this is even remotely tangentially relevant to what you describe.
- girvo 6y agoTo vastly oversimplify, opioid addiction and withdrawal symptoms are influenced strongly by dopamine receptor downregulation. I wonder if those who are resistant to it (not me!) is related to that. And then I wonder if those who are resistant to social media "addiction" are similar... ...but I'm resistant to social media addiction, and yet was a heroin addict for 6 years as a teen/young adult. So perhaps there's no correlation at all. I wonder if there are any academic papers exploring this?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI wasn't wondering if there was any correlation. I was wondering if there are people insensitive to whatever drives social media "addiction"
- girvo 6y agoAnd I was, and used your comment as a jumping-off point to add context that others might not have.
- adventured 6y ago> I find myself wondering if there are people who are resistant to whatever mechanism drives the "addiction" to social media (particularly likes). Sure, measure people on a narcissism scale, to name one huge aspect, and you'll get a direct correlation to the blackhole of needing validation in the form of likes. People that grade low on narcissism accordingly care a lot less about that validation, they simply care a lot less about what most other people think and don't require their approval. I have almost zero need for approval from other people for example. The exceptions I can count on one hand and are close family / friends. I'm hyper resistant to needing likes on social media, needing that feedback charge. I'm certain it's hard-wired in, you're either born that way or you're not; I didn't have to do anything to be that way, I don't have to resist the urge to seek out likes/approval/upvotes, it's never a consideration in terms of my well-being or needs. The people I know that need that outside validation universally also have low self-esteem, they don't self-sustain so they need to fill that from external sources.
- jancsika 6y agoInitially I tried to see if I could get back to zero "points" on HN without being obvious about it. My absolute failure to find a way to do so revealed the point system as some kind of buggy monotonic clock implementation.
- robertlagrant 6y ago> Maybe we're just hearing about the majority (?) of humans that get helplessly trapped in this stuff, causing us to ignore the minority who can dip and out of it with ease. This is possible. I read the post and in no way related to any of it. I don't think Twitter has a central thesis, and if it does it's about popularity, not quality. And perhaps I've never said anything famous, but I don't have a rush of pride when a tweet gets a lot of likes.
- shigawire 6y agoLurkers are basically what you are describing. Occasional post - never read responses.
- throwaway2037 6y agoThis is a very good post. I live in East Asia, and I notice that women use social media much more than men. (Is this true in other regions of the world?) The men that I know who are "Über" social media users are the most (conventionally) attractive or the funniest. In turn, they (try to) convert the increased social status into (a) personal branding or (b) dating opportunities. Are there any serious (Nature?) studies of social media across genders? It would be interesting to read.