5 ms·
I've recently heard a few parents talking about getting their kids these shots. So I decided to take a look at the CDC numbers again. There's a graph where yo
by mixmastamyk 6y ago
I've recently heard a few parents talking about getting their kids these shots. So I decided to take a look at the CDC numbers again. There's a graph where you can select death counts per age group:
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm#SexAndAge https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm#Se...
Given that death rates for the elderly are in the thousands per week, while those for kids jump around two to four or so, is this a good idea? Typically you want the benefits of a vaccine to outweigh the risks. I certainly could be missing something, but it doesn't look like this is the case for healthy kids.
- uniformlyrandom 6y agoCOVID has many other long-term side-effects besides death (fatigue, muscle and joint pain, respiratory problems, etc). These side-effects are present in younger people as well. For me, mere possibility of these side-effects outweigh the risks, which are negligible for MRNA vaccines.
- splittingTimes 6y agoVaccines help to reduce risk of hospitalisation and death, But are there studies that show that vaccination prevents long covid, too?
- Gh0stRAT 6y agoBesides nearly eliminating the risk of hospitalization and death, the vaccines also greatly reduce the odds of contracting COVID-19 in the first place which logically would lead to a reduction in long covid. (contracting covid is a prerequisite for experiencing long-covid)
- lthornberry 6y agoLong covid is also more likely to result from more severe initial cases.
- splittingTimes 6y agoI thought many people with mild symptoms got long covid, too.
- vlovich123 6y agoNot quite yet. The work has just started [1]. There's anecdotal evidence [2] that some people report improvements in long COVID symptoms after taking the vaccine (I have 0 background in chemistry/biology so I'll defer to domain experts to determine whether there's even a plausible mechanism of action for that). I thought there were preliminary studies showing the vaccine is effective at prevention of infection, not just in reduction of severity of symptoms. Assuming that, a good prior to hold IMO (until we have such research) would be that it also prevents long COVID. However, since I can't find where I heard this, may be smart to withhold judgement one way or the other. That being said, what the sibling commentor pointed out seems plausible also to me to put into the prior (i.e. if long COVID is correlated with serious illness, then plausibly the vaccine would also prevent long COVID by reducing the serious response in the first place) [1] https://news.yale.edu/2021/05/10/study-determine-how-covid-19-vaccine-affects-people-long-covid https://news.yale.edu/2021/05/10/study-determine-how-covid-1... [2] https://www.yalemedicine.org/news/vaccines-long-covid https://www.yalemedicine.org/news/vaccines-long-covid
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ozzie_osman 6y agoI assume one main benefit is that vaccinated kids are less likely to spread it to more vulnerable populations. Also some kids have preexisting conditions that put them at risk.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoSoon the vast majority of vulnerable populations left in the US will be deniers. Should kids have the responsibility to protect those folks at their own small risk? Open question as the numbers are still coming in.
- pseudalopex 6y agoPeople who can't get vaccinated don't deserve protection less because people who won't get vaccinated outnumber them. And the vaccines aren't 100% effective.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoAgain, is it worth the risk to potentially millions of kids for a small % of folks that could quarantine? Not obvious.
- pseudalopex 6y agoAre you suggesting people who can't get vaccinated should quarantine forever? And how would vaccinated people know they're vulnerable?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThey will have to if near 100% vaccinations rates are your standard. This isn’t our problem ultimately, we don’t bleach the whole world because the boy in the bubble exists. Risks must be factored. Also, the number of folks who are vaccinated and have needed intensive hospitalization has been found to be approximately zero.
- btowngar 6y agoHelps with herd immunity. For example, Rubella is a vaccine commonly given to kids, but it is isn't really a severe disease even if kids catch it. If a pregnant woman contracts Rubella in her first trimester however, it can lead to severe complications for the unborn child. Just vaccinating women of child bearing age against Rubella works a little, but vaccinating kids as well means that that transmission vector is removed, and really improves the overall outcome.
- hartator 6y ago> Helps with herd immunity. It's highly probable that it helps but I thought we don't have the data proving it yet?
- tengbretson 6y ago> Helps with herd immunity That is true and it's a good thing in it's own right, but it's orthogonal to the responsibility a doctor has to their patient first and foremost.
- xref 6y agoyour faulty line of logic, that you can’t both serve an individual and a group, just condemned most vaccines. Why bother giving kids a chicken pox vaccine when the infection is usually mild for them. Or from the GP, why give them rubella vaccine when it mainly hurts pregnant women.
- loudtieblahblah 6y agoI think the big argument here is: Is doling out medical advice to an individual to protect the group ethical? Or should the medical advice for the individual be directed at the potential outcomes for the individual. This conversation of individual vs communal rights is much simpler when we tell smokers they should keep it to designated areas or their private property. It's a bit of a different animal when we're essentially encouraging and coercing people into taking potentially unnecessary medication for OTHER people's benefit. It's not an easy question, if you're being intellectually honest. People who are hardliners on one side or the other on this debate, i feel aren't honest about the problems this poses. They're so wrapped up in their side of the individualism/tribialism or collective-safety/freedom dynamic, that they're not giving the other side a fair look. This is a problem that plague the human species. Our greatest strengths are also our greatest weaknesses. Both our nature as collective/tribal animals, but with a deep since of contradictory individualism leads us to success and survival and wellness, but both of those aspects of us lead to great tyranny. it's the communism vs capitalism debate - both sides have tons of blood on their hands. Tons of oppression too. It's the debate played out between Kirk and Spock about the needs of the one vs the many. And it's an honest, real debate that i don't feel will ever be solved because of the myriad of ways it plays out in a complex society.
- staticassertion 6y agoI get being cautious, but it isn't like there's a strong concrete reason not to do it. Plus we still have the potential for mutations, and kids can still spread covid even if they aren't dying from it.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoKids are overwhelmingly asymptomatic. The post above mentions some risks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27111071 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27111071
- sbelskie 6y agoThere are bad outcomes other than death.
- void_mint 6y agoIsn't the risk for kids more transmission related? Kids (usually) won't die from COVID, but they'll transmit to people who can, was my understanding.
- aroch 6y agoThe point of vaccinating kids is: 1. They still get sick, even if asymptomatic, and can bring it home to the house where older people live 2. I don't know if there are published case report / data yet, but anecdotally the new strains are much more likely to cause complications and require hospitalizations for younger children. 3. Even asymptomatic infectious seem to cause "long covid" (Something like a third of long covid cases were asymptomatic). Potentially life-long alterations to lung or heart function doesn't sound like fun
- dham 6y agoBut aren't older people vaccinated?
- aroch 6y agoNot necessarily, you could have an immuno-compromised parent/grandparent
- dham 6y agoBut according to CDC, both people have to be vaccinated to talk to each other inside. This means that if one person is vaccinated you can't see you're immuno-compromised grandparent anyway.
- aroch 6y agoYes, but if your child is school age -- schools which are now increasingly going to in person instruction -- and you are immunocompromised, what are you going to do? Same question if you live in a multi-generational household, but now there are grandkids going to school and kids going to work. I see elsewhere you're claiming that long Covid isn't a thing. It is, full stop. Unless you're suggesting that living with lung and heart damage caused by Covid isn't a complication of Covid?
- dham 6y agoLung and heart damage can be the result of any virus. Just look at any article pre 2020. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090717150302.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090717150302.h... https://erj.ersjournals.com/content/45/5/1463 https://erj.ersjournals.com/content/45/5/1463 https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2000/03/000329090639.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2000/03/000329090639.h... https://www.cdc.gov/flu/highrisk/heartdisease.htm#:~:text=Studies%20have%20shown%20that%20flu,experiencing%20their%20first%20heart%20attack https://www.cdc.gov/flu/highrisk/heartdisease.htm#:~:text=St.... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8142/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8142/ https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0945053X18301458 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0945053X1...
- maxerickson 6y agoThe Pfizer vaccine is looking pretty safe at this point, so there is a benefit to the vaccine, taking risk from very low down towards 0.
- nimih 6y agoPresumably, the cost-benefit analysis here is being done on a population-wide basis--leaving a large portion of the population unvaccinated lets them act as a reservoir for the virus, hindering progress towards herd immunity (recall that not every [willing] adult can get vaccinated, nor is the vaccine 100% effective, especially against some of the mutations we're already seeing, so achieving herd immunity is a meaningful public health goal), as well as increasing the mutation rate of the virus.
- mesh 6y agoThe only concern isnt just death, but also longer term issue such as long covid (which may be a bigger concern for this group).
- dham 6y agoLong Covid is likely a psychological phenomenon. Mainly due to 24/7 news cycle and social medial
- mixmastamyk 6y agoI don’t agree with that, it lingered for me for at least six months. Don’t own a tv and block most soc media.
- dham 6y agoThen you have post viral syndrome which is common with viruses. If you've ever had a common cold or flu you would know. I had a simple cold and had fatigue for months. It just lingered and lingered
- Volundr 6y agoThat's a remarkably quick and easy diagnosis. And over the internet too. Most doctors examine their patients before making a concrete diagnosis.
- dham 6y agoActually some things are easy to diagnose remotely. Which is why remote doctor visits are becoming more common. If you feel like crap and only your throat hurts you most likely have strep. Since bacterias attack only one area. If you feel like crap and your nose is running, head hurts and have a sore throat, you have a virus. Yet doctors still prescribe antibiotics for viruses. No wonder we have a problem.
- mixmastamyk 6y ago
- dools 6y ago2-4 children dying per week of a communicable disease is a pretty big deal.
- pokstad 6y agoPlease provide a citation for these stats. We had more kids dying of the flu before, so this reasoning is not really accurate: https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/covid-19/true-or-false-desantis-says-covid-lower-risk-school-aged-kids-flu https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/covid-19/true-or-false-de...
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThe stats come from the cdc link at the top.
- adrr 6y agoKids can spread it. Strength of vaccination program is having high vaccination rates to prevent spread and risk of mutations. There’s a bunch on immunocompromised people that can’t get vaccinated or the vaccine has little effect on them like people who had an organ transplant.
- joe_the_user 6y agoThese discussions seem to revolve around "one hundred and one flavors of shortsightedness". The aim of vaccinating everyone is so these kids can grow up in a world without Covid - so they don't die 5-10 too early when do get old. (You've heard kids get older, right?). And as people mention, kids not giving it to their parents, etc.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoParents, elders, and compromised folks are vaccinated already in these parts. Forcing kids to pick up the slack to protect those who refused is not fair or a good use of resources, imho. Certainly technology will be better in ten years as well.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoIt would also be more like 30 years before they enter a significant risk age, not 10.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoYes, I didn’t want to predict that far, but could be even higher, right?
- dham 6y agoI mean we have Chicken Pox, Measles, and Rubella vaccine. Soooooooo. Either way I won't give this to my kids. No need to take any risk. I'll wait 10 years. I love how the CDC had scope creep. I turned into slow the spread to save every human ever in existence even if they're 80 years old.
- xwolfi 6y agoLaugh now, in India they also said no need and survive the fittest, and now it's everyone losing their parents. Ill give it to my kid, I dont see a downside. She won't die of a vaccine.
- dham 6y agoOf course she won't die of the vaccine. She'll just have a lifetime of autoimmune diseases. Which might be worse
- dapids 6y agoYou commented 7 days ago noting you vaccinated all your kids and now your shaming someone's decision for vaccinating theirs? Rich. As for the rest of your comments on this article.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dham 6y agoYou're right. Emotion is high. I did say my kids are vaccinated, but I meant with non emergency approved vaccines.
- lthornberry 6y agoThe risk of death from covid is low for this age group, but almost certainly much higher than the risk of death from the vaccine. The risk-benefit analysis seems to weigh pretty obviously in favor of vaccination.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThree out of almost a hundred million is not significantly lower than the risks outlined here, truth is we don't have enough info on the risks to decide: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27111071 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27111071