6 ms·
>The dark side of this is that many of us won't. And, in particular, in many areas, the total number of brass rings is relatively fixed and we can't all get the
by coldtea 6y ago
>The dark side of this is that many of us won't. And, in particular, in many areas, the total number of brass rings is relatively fixed and we can't all get them. A hundred years ago, most people didn't even think of becoming an author.
It's worse: a hundred years ago (say 1921) there were less people (in the US for example), and more succesful authors.
Now it's more people (350 million vs 100 million in 2021) AND less absolute people reading books (perhaps as today they also compete with tv, the web, youtube, netflix, social media, videogames, and so on as everyday entertainment options).
So it's much much harder to make a living as an author today than in 1921.
- cortesoft 6y ago> So it's much much harder to make a living as an author today than in 1921. And much easier to make it as a television screen writer. The mediums have shifted
- coldtea 6y agoWell, it's not the same thing, just because it still involves writing and fiction. That there are new jobs of a different kind is not much consolation when one likes the old jobs.
- fsckboy 6y agoWhen agriculture was invented, it put a bunch of hunter gatherers out of business. They weren't happy about it, they liked being hunters and gatherers. But that surplus workforce found jobs in other areas, creating whole industries where there had been nothing. Can't have Post-mates without workers and restaurants. Can't have restaurants without more workers and food distribution. Can't have food distribution without more workers and food processors... etc. Ivy league english majors get jobs writing TV and movie scripts. Mass electronic distribution means that many many people get to watch the creative output of a small number of people. All the other people who used to write are available to fill new niches in the economy. Yep, the transition is difficult, and they'll complain about it, but society as a whole benefits.
- tuatoru 6y ago> but society as a whole benefits. If only Ivy League English majors get to be writers, then I think society as a whole has lost a lot.
- coldtea 6y ago>When agriculture was invented, it put a bunch of hunter gatherers out of business. They weren't happy about it, they liked being hunters and gatherers. But that surplus workforce found jobs in other areas, creating whole industries where there had been nothing. For many it remains still not that wise a decision. >All the other people who used to write are available to fill new niches in the economy. Yeah, I hear burger-flipping is still in demand. I appreciate the ELI5, but it's not that I don't know history, or I don't understand that some jobs die and others replace them. It is that I consider some jobs dying a problem, whether they are replaced by something else or not, and doubly so in the way that that transition happens (and some people in each generation get the short end of the stick).
- fsckboy 6y ago> it's not that I don't know history, or I don't understand that some jobs die and others replace them. ok, but it's not that some jobs die and others replace them, it's that efficiency gains allow less effort to satiate demand and thereby create a labor/ingenuity supply for new endeavors. the job of writing (or performing music, etc.) did not die, it's that the demand for satisfying arts consumption can be met by a smaller sector of the economy.
- nearbuy 6y ago> a hundred years ago (say 1921) there were less people (in the US for example), and more successful authors. Are you sure there were more successful authors? There weren't that many notable books published in 1921. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1921_in_literature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1921_in_literature
- prewett 6y agoWe won't know for a hundred years how many of the books that will be published in 2021 will be notable enough in 2121 to be on the 2021_in_literature wikipedia page.
- nearbuy 6y agoI didn't mean to imply that we should compare it to the 2021_in_literature Wikipedia page. There are many thousands of successful authors living today. I'm wondering, how many were there in 1921?
- 252452d 6y agoI'd imagine there's a lot that just hasn't made it to Wikipedia: https://springfieldmuseums.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/InteriorBasementFullersBlockJan1905-480x362.jpg https://springfieldmuseums.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/In... http://twitpic.com/9b8h7x http://twitpic.com/9b8h7x
- MereInterest 6y ago1921 is shortly after copyright became effectively infinite, and falls in the gulf of books that were lost because they were snatched away from entering the public domain. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120330/12402418305/why-missing-20th-century-books-is-even-worse-than-it-seems.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120330/12402418305/why-m... Edit: I'm a bit off with my dates, as 1922 was the year after which works effectively didn't ever enter the public domain.
- nearbuy 6y agoInteresting. I really don't see any good argument why copyright should last longer than, say, 20 years. Would any potential authors decide it's not worth it to write books if copyright only lasted 20 years? What benefit to society does ~100 years of copyright provide?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoIt’s older books not Netflix that’s the real competition. Amazon’s unlimited bookshelf holds a lot more than just Lord of the Rings. That said, residuals are also much easier to capture now days than back when book stores had extremely limited shelf space so it’s not all bad. There is a real trade off of fewer sales in year one but more sales in year 2-20. On the numbers side people have a lot more disposable income, capturing a larger share of revenue per person can completely flip the equation. Patreon, etc don’t have to individually provide enough to live off of as long as all revenue streams add up to a living wage. I suspect if the objective threshold is say 50k USD inflation adjusted, today is relatively speaking a much better time to be an author than most people here are assuming. Of course that’s ignoring all the vanity books being published. Simply having an ISBN number doesn’t really mean anything in today’s world.