7 ms·
Some important background on this. At issue here is sales tax. By state law, the tax is owed by the citizens to the state no matter where they make the purcha
by btilly 15y ago
Some important background on this.
At issue here is sales tax. By state law, the tax is owed by the citizens to the state no matter where they make the purchase. To make enforcement easier, the tax is supposed to be collected by businesses. In theory the tax is owed regardless, but as a practical matter when businesses do not collect the tax, customers don't volunteer the information and the state loses revenue.
This annoys states to no end. However courts have long ruled that a company that is not in a state cannot be forced to be regulated by that state, even if it does businesses with residents from that state. They can't do that because that is interstate commerce, which the Constitution says is regulated by Congress, not the states. But if the company has a presence in that state, then it can be forced to obey state regulations, even if the actual commercial act crosses state boundaries.
This is all old hat, and was settled back in the 1800s with catalog companies.
The new twist here, that several states (now including California) have pursued, is declaring that the existence of an affiliate program with state residents is a business presence in that state. Because it is a presence, they can make Amazon collect taxes.
Amazon's position is that affiliates are not Amazon employees, and are not a presence of Amazon in that state. And therefore those laws are unconstitutional. However Amazon has chosen to not contest these laws in court. Instead Amazon has chosen to cut off all affiliates in any state that tries this tactic. It thereby guarantees that it no longer has a presence in that state, and it doesn't go about trying to collect taxes from people in that state.
The net result is that Amazon loses some business, the state continues to not get taxes, and some residents lose a source of income.
- ddlatham 15y agoHow many affiliates are they willing to terminate? All of them (besides the 5 states it already collects for http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=468512#which http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=4...) ?
- flyt 15y agoyes, all of them.
- dablya 15y agoThey probably don't make enough from affiliate traffic to make up for the lost sales if they have to collect the tax.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoSales tax tends to be 5-10%, affiliate kickbacks tend to be less than that, which means that the increased revenue from affiliate links is in the same ballpark. It would be bad enough if these laws forced amazon to pay sales tax on purchases where the affiliate lived in the same state as the purchaser. Instead these laws force amazon to pay sales tax on all sales where the purchaser lives in a state where there is a significant number of affiliates. The former would not make business sense (raising prices for a much less significant benefit to affiliates) the latter makes even less sense economically. This isn't Amazon trying to skirt paying sales tax, it's merely amazon making a level headed business decision in the face of irrational and grasping legislation.
- Shenglong 15y agoBeautifully said. However, now Amazon needs to give California a reason to terminate this law while saving face.
- jbooth 15y agoAmazon (or more accurately, the purchaser) should be paying all sales taxes in the state where the purchaser lives, period. Seems cut and dried to me. If the corner store has to run sales tax, Amazon should too. I don't see why a "[adjective] business decision in the face of [adjective] and [adjective] legislation" is in any way different from "skirt paying sales tax".
- modoc 15y agoBecause as you say, it's actually the purchaser who needs to pay the sales tax, legally. Not Amazon.
- jerf 15y agoYou say it's "cut and dried" at the same time that you are clearly reaching beyond what the laws say. It is not cut and dried as to what one state may make a resident of a completely different state do. Amazon probably is correct, and forcing Amazon to collect sales tax for your state probably is an overreach. It should be pointed out, since so many people forget this in this discussion, that as a resident of a state you are frequently required to pay the sales tax to the state directly in the form of a "use tax". This isn't about consumers owing sales tax, technically the states have already made that happen. It isn't about Amazon "not paying" this tax, because it is the consumer's responsibility at that point. It is about one state forcing an entity not in its jurisdiction to do something for the convenience (and little more) of that state. Amazon's got a pretty strong case here; any principle that makes this compulsion legal is likely to have numerous and manifold "unanticipated results" beyond merely getting Amazon to collect tax.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI love it when everyone works together to make a lose/lose/lose situation happen.
- T-hawk 15y agoYup. Politicians and governments are, by and large, oblivious to the fact that laws induce behavioral changes. Like extending unemployment benefits to 99 weeks, then somehow being surprised when the rate increases of people staying on unemployment rather than finding jobs. Or creating a tax credit for low-income families who have children, then being surprised when the low-income birth rate increases. In the politician's world, if a $100 million business exists and a tax rate of 7% is imposed, that is obviously $7 million in revenue, because no company would ever think to try to work around the tax structure or would lose business to competitors not subject to that tax.
- cheez 15y ago> Yup. Politicians and governments are, by and large, oblivious to the fact that laws induce behavioral changes. Come on. Politicians are some of the smartest people in the society. Do you really think they are oblivious or do you think they're just looking out for #1?
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> Politicians are some of the smartest people in the society. [citation needed] Not that I necessarily disagree, mind you; nor do I want to drag the whole social vs. whatever we call it now intelligence.
- cheez 15y agoI'd say it takes a certain degree of smarts to be able to manipulate people as well as politicians do!
- maxharris 15y agoBut are they really looking out for themselves by doing so? A captain that helps sink the ship he's on (and keeps him from drowning) is not "looking out for #1" long-term.
- jbooth 15y agoI don't think it's at all unreasonable for states to want to enforce the tax that's already on the books and supposed to be already reported/collected, as you state. The problem is the hangup with the commerce clause. Catalog companies didn't threaten to make a significant % of all sales into postal sales, the internet does. I'd hope that we could find a way to straighten things out where the state can still assess the sales tax the way it's written legally without bringing all of these other issues about affiliates into it. I don't really see where states can go on this, the current strategy seems to be "try and force congressional or SC action", good luck with that. Maybe they just fold on sales tax altogether and shift that burden to income tax.
- hvs 15y agoThey could sign on to the Streamlined Sales Tax Project that Amazon is in favor of (as well as 44 states and D.C.) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streamlined_Sales_Tax_Project http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streamlined_Sales_Tax_Project
- btilly 15y agoCatalog companies didn't threaten to make a significant % of all sales into postal sales, the internet does. I am not so sure of that. Particularly in rural states, companies like Sears-Roebuck were the prime source of all sorts of amenities of basic life, from phonographs to sewing machines. Sure, it took longer, but the prices were a lot better than general stores. And the selection was amazing. You could buy anything up to and including a new house! (Some assembly required.)
- brudgers 15y agoSears-Roebuck even sold houses. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sears_Catalog_Home http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sears_Catalog_Home]
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoI can totally understand why Amazon doesn't want to have to collect municipal sales tax. Every city in my state has a different potential tax rate, with a percentage determined by the state, by the county, by whether the city participates in mass transit, etc. Same zip codes have different taxes. Trying to manage that across the country is an ugly proposition! At least the EU has chosen a single VAT (even if it is outrageous! :).
- walexander 15y agoI guess there is a significant risk of the result being found in the States' favor so that they don't directly challenge the law. IANAL, but it seems like the Supreme Court would very likely rule in their favor though. Quill v N Dakota is a very similar ruling and when looking through the notes I found this: "As we noted in Heublein, Inc. v. South Carolina Tax Comm'n, 409 U.S. 275, 280 (1972), in enacting § 381, "Congress attempted to allay the apprehension of businessmen that `mere solicitation' would subject them to state taxation. . . . Section 381 was designed to define clearly a lower limit for the exercise of [the State's power to tax]. Clarity that would remove uncertainty was Congress' primary goal.""
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tomp 15y agoSo... if I understand correctly, if I am a resident of California and I buy books from Amazon, I pay no sales tax (isn't that the same as VAT)? Does this mean that Amazon books in Washington are more expensive (because I Amazon must collect the taxes, because the state can force it to, because it has a physical presence there)?
- ojbyrne 15y agoYes that's what it means.
- tedunangst 15y agoIf you live in CA and buy books from Amazon, Amazon does not collect sales tax. You are still required by law to pay it. The onus is now on you to calculate the amount and include it when you file your income taxes.
- rbritton 15y agoIn most tax jurisdictions they call this a "Use Tax". In theory here in Washington you're supposed to file that with the state annually/quarterly/monthly/whatever interval they set for you, but in practice no individual actually does. Businesses that remit sales tax to the state do have a field on the form to include their own use tax as well.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- aaronbrethorst 15y agoThe books are the same price. Amazon simply tacks on WA sales tax. Here's an example from a purchase I made last month: Amazon.com items (Sold by Amazon.com, LLC) : 1 Apple iPod touch 8 GB (4th... $204.99 1 $204.99 -------------------------------------------------------------------- Item Subtotal: $204.99 Shipping and handling: $3.99 Sales Tax Collected: $19.85 Total: $228.83 Paid by Visa: $228.83 -------------------------------------------------------------------- Not surprisingly, items that are sold by third parties on Amazon, but still fulfilled by Amazon are not subject to sales tax, as long as the third party is not located here in Washington state.
- leot 15y agoNice text of the actual law with revisions marked-up: http://leginfo.ca.gov/pub/11-12/bill/asm/ab_0001-0050/abx1_28_bill_20110615_amended_sen_v97.html http://leginfo.ca.gov/pub/11-12/bill/asm/ab_0001-0050/abx1_2... [edited to note that revisions are highlighted]
- FilterJoe 15y agoJust carefully read through parts of this and noticed the following exception for small retailers (<$10,000 annually), which may or may not be applicable to Amazon Affiliates (could be interpreted either way, because "retailer" includes "an entity affiliated with a retailer within the meaning of Section 1504 of the Internal Revenue Code."): "This bill would include in the definition of a retailer engaged in business in this state any retailer entering into agreements under which a person or persons in this state, for a commission or other consideration, directly or indirectly refer potential purchasers, whether by an Internet-based link or an Internet Web site, or otherwise, to the retailer, provided the total cumulative sales price from all sales by the retailer to purchasers in this state that are referred pursuant to these agreements is in excess of $10,000 within the preceding 12 months, and provided further that the retailer has cumulative sales of tangible personal property to purchasers in this state of over $500,000, within the preceding 12 months, except as specified. This bill would also provide that a retailer entering into specified agreements to purchase advertising is not a retailer engaged in business in this state and would define a retailer to include an entity affiliated with a retailer under federal income tax law, as specified. This bill would further provide that these provisions would not apply if the retailer can demonstrate that the referrals wold not satisfy specified United States constitutional requirements,as provided." EDIT: slight formatting changes
- joezydeco 15y agoSo what about actual Amazon employees, like Lab126 in Cupertino? Are they hiding Amazon affiliation through fancy corporate footwork and shell companies?
- btilly 15y agoYes. They are shell corporations that happen to be owned by Amazon. I don't know how they are affected by this bill. But it will be interesting to see what happens with it.
- _delirium 15y agoTexas is trying to go after Amazon shell companies; I'm not sure if California has tried that route. In Texas, there are two companies involved: Amazon.com.kydc, Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of Amazon.com, Inc. The sole business of the former is to operate physical facilities, some of which are in Texas, and which provide warehousing and shipment of books for the latter. Texas argues that this constitutes Amazon having a physical presence in Texas, but Amazon disagrees.
- mkramlich 15y agoSo Amazon has physical buildings in Texas, and Amazon disagrees with that state's position that they have a physical presence in Texas. Only a lawyer could argue for such a twisted interpretation of reality with a straight face.
- emmett 15y agoAmazon owns a company that has physical buildings in Texas, and disagrees as to whether that constitutes a tax nexus or not. Pretty easy to argue with a straight face! Tax law is a matter of technicality, not "does it seem about right".
- joezydeco 15y agoIt's a warehouse full of books. People in Texas order books on Amazon's website, and they ship from the warehouse in Texas to people in Texas. So it's a store, but not a store. Boggle.
- nathos 15y agounfortunately, Amazon didn't have the balls to fight New York sales tax. Too many large, high-profile affiliates in NYC, I guess.