3 ms·
>You’re probably better off just having. A fire safe box under your bed. Not really. You're trading one threat (negligence on the part of the bank) for another
by gruez 6y ago
>You’re probably better off just having. A fire safe box under your bed.
Not really. You're trading one threat (negligence on the part of the bank) for another (your home getting robbed/burgled).
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> You're trading one threat (negligence on the part of the bank) for another (your home getting robbed/burgled). Only one of these are you in any control over. Banks are also bigger targets. Bank robber Willie Sutton was famously asked why he robbed banks. "Because that's where the money is," he said. That's the problem with putting all the valuables together in one place. Meanwhile you can't so easily get your stuff caught up in some robbery or "investigation" of somebody you have nothing to do with.
- nimos 6y agoIf you own your own home it would be pretty trivial to hide something that wouldn't get noticed in most burglaries. The average burglary is 10 minutes. They aren't digging into insulation in your attic or going through multiple boxes of kids clothes in your basement. I imagine most safes get burgled because their owner can't keep their mouth shut.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoAs someone else mentioned, the civil asset forfeiture has surpassed burglary. With that continuing to increase, it might actually be statistically safer to keep it under your bed than at the bank's safety deposit. I guess it depends on a deeper analysis, but with just that info it starts to become comparable.
- gowld 6y agoThis is absolutely false. "forfeiture" has surpassed burglary; and most of that is criminal forfeiture, after a conviction, returning stolen property or paying a fine. The biggest single chunk is what Bernie Madoff stole. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-took-more-stuff-from-people-than-burglars-did-last-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-...
- Clubber 6y agoBurglary requires breaking and entering. I don't think Madoff did any B&E. the act of breaking and entering a dwelling at night to commit a felony (such as theft) https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/burglary https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/burglary
- bpodgursky 6y agoThis is 100% true. Ignore the downvotes.
- gruez 6y ago>With that continuing to increase, it might actually be statistically safer to keep it under your bed than at the bank's safety deposit. Whether that's true would depend on the false positive rate of civil forfeitures. Even if it's some absurdly high number (eg. 50%), you'd still need 2x as much civil forfeitures than burglaries for the risk to be equal (presumably nobody "deserves" a burglary). Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered, if you can provide documentation that the items aren't ill gotten gains. I'm not sure what the recovery rate for burglary is, but I'd imagine that P(assets recovered from civil forfeiture|you are innocent) is much greater than P(assets recovered from burglary).
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Even if it's some hilariously high number (eg. 50%) It's plausibly even higher than that. The incentive for civil asset forfeitures is for law enforcement to seize in exactly this sort of "a medium amount of money from a large number of people" type of situation. Because it makes this useless: > Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered "I got back my $9000 and all I had to do was pay $25,000 to a lawyer." And when people do the math on that and decide not to pursue it, law enforcement gets to keep the money. Hence the incentive for them to do it.
- Analemma_ 6y ago> Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered, In theory. It will cost you a shitton of lawyer fees that might exceed the amount you lost, and you can also expect to be constantly harassed by the cops during and after the process, plus forget about ever getting help from them again if you need it.
- syshum 6y agoI would say civil forfeiture is nearly 90+ % false... If it was a legit use of government power they would go for the better, more ethical criminal forfeiture where by they prove a person committed a crime and then take the assets related to the crime Civil Asset forfeitures are an end run around the 4th and 5th amendments, and should be viewed as unethical by every reasonable person
- brobdingnagians 6y ago
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoCivil Asset forfeiture also includes things like when Bernie Madoffs assets were seized and sent back to the investors which was $1.7 billion listed in an article on another person's comment. So it's not 100% comprised of "honest" citizens just getting screwed.
- bpodgursky 6y agoThe terms are confused a lot, but "Assert Forfeiture" includes seizing assets from Madoff. "Civil Asset Forfeiture" is the Really Bad kind people complain about. Only "Assert Forfeiture" overall is a larger volume than theft, because yes it includes recuperation from white-collar crime. The money from civil kind is much smaller (not that it excuses it).
- fossuser 6y agoEntirely depends on which is more likely, which probably depends a lot on where you live. No such thing as perfect security etc. but the trade off could make sense.
- frankfrankfrank 6y agoI agree that under your bed in a lockbox is a rather poor choice, especially since not only are those boxes are usually not difficult to open without a key and they offer next to no real fire protection for any useful amount of time that would make difference. Maybe the reply was just imprecise, but the sentiment seems to still be valid in that hiding your vault in your home/on your property somehow is surely more secure in many cases and circumstances, especially in this time where it should be clear to essentially everyone that fundamental rights once accepted as universal and violations of them harshly punished, are now being essentially totally ignored and even nullified through various legal and legislative gaslighting; civil asset forfeiture being of course only the most commonly known perversion of the most basic and fundamental concepts of civilization and basic logic.