4 ms·
This is a really common misconception that buyers have. Just stop and think for a second - put yourself in the dealer's shoes - why do you think the dealer wou
by chrisseaton 6y ago
This is a really common misconception that buyers have.
Just stop and think for a second - put yourself in the dealer's shoes - why do you think the dealer would want cash? No reason. They don't want your cash. A cash buyer is a pain. They want to sell you a loan.
The last time I bought a car I offered cash, and they countered with a four-figure discount (on total cost of ownership) if I took part of it as a loan. I now have that part of the price invested, creating money, while I gradually pay the loan.
And my credit score went up as I had a new, responsible loan!
Cash buyers are fools, unless you're really at the point of valuing not having a loan for moral reasons (maybe a German?) at four-figures.
- SilasX 6y agoYes, and the smart move there is to take the offer and pay it early, which is still stupid on the dealer's part.
- throwawayboise 6y agoAssuming you can. Some deals are set up so that you have to pay most of the interest even if you pay the loan off early, or other prepayment penalties.
- SilasX 6y agoYes, prepayment penalties are a thing. But every time this comes up, we see reports of too-good-to-be -true deals that don't have them. See, for example, this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14484615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14484615 I also had a friend do exactly what I described, and there was another thread where they only had to make two payments and then could pay off the rest without penalty (and even that was an unspoken gentlemen's agreement with the dealer) -- will find if I get a chance. The point is, it's simply not warranted to assume as a bedrock of truth that no dealer every makes a confused deal in this respect, as chrisseaton was insisting.
- throwawayboise 6y agoAnd if you had walked out the door they would have run after you to take the cash deal AND given you the discount. You think they prefer to deal with the time and uncertainty of putting you through a loan application, when they could pocket the same sale in cash? Nobody is coming out with less money on a loan purchase vs. cash, except the buyer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI think you're mistaken about how dealerships and car sales are structured, at least in places like the UK and the US. Maybe it's different where you are? They get a proportion of the sale price, and they get paid a referral fee for you opening a loan, and then on top of that they can offer extras that you probably don't need like fabric protection products. > Nobody is coming out with less money on a loan purchase vs. cash, except the buyer. The dealer is paid to get you to get a loan. If they don't get the loan, they get less money. My understanding is that their referral fee is somewhat weak about how much the loan actually has to be, so they just care that you take it. It's worth it to them to discount the price by less than their loan referral fee, in order to get the loan referral fee. > And if you had walked out the door they would have run after you to take the cash deal AND given you the discount. No they'd just have sold to someone willing to pay their price. There's a car supply shortage... that's the whole point of the article... did you miss that? If you want to buy a new car at the moment and you go in haggling them on a mid to high end spec car they'll just tell you to fuck off and you won't get the car you want.
- throwawayboise 6y ago> they get paid a referral fee for you opening a loan Which is added in to the finance charges or amount borrowed. Ever wonder why the salesmen always want to negotiate a "payment" amount instead of a purchase price? > No they'd just have sold to someone willing to pay their price. And I'd have just gone to another dealer willing to work with me on my terms. > There's a car supply shortage True, and that causes higher prices overall. But negotiation strategies for getting the best deal haven't changed.
- formerly_proven 6y ago> Cash buyers are fools, unless you're really at the point of valuing not having a loan for moral reasons (maybe a German?) at four-figures. German Ideal nowadays is to buy a house for a couple hundred grand on a loan that you finish paying off when retiring.
- ineedasername 6y agoYes, if you're going to cash buy, you can frequently get a better deal off the sticker price by agreeing to finance and then simply paying the loan off. How you structure things really depends on priorities though. Normally I buy the car (through financing) but right now I prioritized low monthly payments during financial uncertainty, so I leased. If things are different in three years, we'll either buy a new car or buyout the lease-- I made sure the lease buyout price was something we would be comfortable with: the TCO came out to only a little more than if we financed a purchase w/ higher immediate monthly payments, and I judged that a slightly higher TCO is worth the current ability to keep monthly expenses to a minimum.
- wingspar 6y agoI always separate trade-in and financing from the price. Deal on the price first then the trade, then the financing. Trade ins are good for negotiation too. Wanted the factory extended warranty. Dealers in other states will discount the extended warranty but can’t sell in my state. Dealer wouldn’t discount the warranty to the price of the out-of-state so I had them keep it that price and up the trade in value to match it. They can show they didn’t discount the warranty. I get the discount. They did that if I would get finance thru them, matching my prearranged banks rate. Deal made. Went in the next Monday to the local bank and refinanced the car loan. Also made them give me so thing for signing the arbitration agreement. Everything is negotiable. I did have to walk away but they called me back on the drive home.
- chrisseaton 6y agoExactly - agree a sale price. Then discuss payment. And at that point cash has no benefit to the dealer, but a loan does. So the loan can get you a discount but the cash cannot.