9 ms·
When people ate people, a strange disease emerged (2016)
- harles 6y ago> But it wasn't a virus — or a bacterium, fungus, or parasite. It was an entirely new infectious agent, one that had no genetic material, could survive being boiled, and wasn't even alive. This is the most interesting part to me.
- gambiting 6y agoWell because it's "just" a protein which by itself isn't alive. It's like how heavy water(water where the hydrogen atom is replaced by a deuterium atom) will eventually kill you if ingested in large quantities, because your body just doesn't recognize it as any different from normal water - it takes the molecules and builds stuff with it, but because it's not quite the same, things start breaking down eventually. This is roughly the same - body takes this protein in, "thinks" it's a different type of protein, the resulting cell is "broken" diseases follow. You'd literally need to break that protein down so that it's completely destroyed, either with extremely high temperatures(not boiling) or with acids. People think of it like bacteria and then are surprised it can't be "killed" - well it can't be killed because it's just a basic building block, it just happens to be defective.
- harles 6y agoMy expectation is that most proteins would be broken down into their amino acids before being absorbed. Maybe it's just the law of large numbers that lets some through? It seems like a pretty spectacular feat to be cooked, digested, and enter the brain intact.
- erdo 6y agoI'd never heard of cannibalism outside of "eating your enemies" this explanation is really touching and quite sad
- haunter 6y agoYou never heard of survival cannibalism? Donner party, Flight 571 etc.
- erdo 6y agoOh that's true, I'd forgotten about that - (cannibalism is not something I generally think about much at all to be honest!)
- LinuxBender 6y agoAnd the original true story that Moby Dick was based on. Quite gruesome. Lesson learned, don't wait until your ship mates have no body fat to eat them, or the protein won't be absorbed.
- dessant 6y agoPeople were selling body parts for cooking during the Russian Revolution. NSFL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_famine_of_1921%E2%80%9322#/media/File:Cannibalism_during_Russian_famine_1921.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_famine_of_1921%E2%80%9... Widespread cannibalism has also been documented in the Soviet Union. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor#Cannibalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor#Cannibalism
- erdo 6y agoThanks for that link, I was aware that Stalin was responsible for a famine resulting in millions of deaths, but had no idea of the details
- erdo 6y agoWeirdly the name of this tribe happens to be an exact match for the name of an android library that I publish - needless to say it didn't come up when I googled potential names :)
- knolan 6y agoSounds very like Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease[0] which can result from the bovine equivalent[1]. There was a major outbreak of ‘mad cow disease’ in the UK and elsewhere and was related to cows being fed feedstuff made from offal. [0]https://www.ninds.nih.gov/Disorders/Patient-Caregiver-Education/Fact-Sheets/Creutzfeldt-Jakob-Disease-Fact-Sheet https://www.ninds.nih.gov/Disorders/Patient-Caregiver-Educat... [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bovine_spongiform_encephalopathy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bovine_spongiform_encephalop...
- 4gotunameagain 6y agoBoth are mentioned in the article, which points out that the suspected outset of kuru was a spontaneous CJD occurrence
- knolan 6y agoYes, you’re right. That’s what I get for skimming the article.
- IncRnd 6y agoThank you. That is actually well-covered in the article. The article states this: "The epidemic likely started when one person in a Fore village developed sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease, a degenerative neurological disorder similar to kuru." And this: "People have developed variant CJD after eating the meat of cattle infected with mad cow disease. Dr. Ermias Belay, a prion disease researcher with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, says that's the only scenario in which there is "definitive evidence" that humans can develop a prion disease after eating the infected meat of another species."
- dkarras 6y agoAh was waiting for my daily prion disease dose in hacker news!
- Farmadupe 6y agoAny chance we've got time for the meta question.. Does anyone have a clue why prion diseases are so popular on HN at the moment? AFAIK it's not something that often turns up in mainstream media? Not even as something they keep in the 'slow news day' draw.. Are we genuinely scared by the idea of getting a prion disease? Is there an actual risk of a prion epidemic? ..or putting my Freud hat on, does everyone on HN share a weird masochistic fetish about 'the next big pandemic'? For my part I don't really get it, but then maybe it's because I'm british and for us prion diseases have been boring (or rather the news isn't interested in prion diseases) since mad cow disease stopped being a thing 20 years ago.
- zem 6y agothe 'at the moment' probably explains it - a lot of online fora have, for want of a better word, fads where there is a lot of discussion of a particular topic for a brief while, then it fades and sooner or later a new topic comes along. I quite like the phenomenon personally.
- TheGigaChad 6y agoPeople are desperate to keep "working" from home.
- FinanceAnon 6y agoAs long as we are not eating our co-workers, I think we should be safe to get back into offices
- h0l0cube 6y ago... or eating the flesh of any animal Edit: ... or eating plants: https://www.virology.ws/2015/06/25/prions-in-plants/ https://www.virology.ws/2015/06/25/prions-in-plants/
- radarsat1 6y agoI'm curious, if it's a "misfolding protein" (my knowledge of biology is not sufficient to know what "misfolding" means here, I understand that proteins fold, but "misfolding" is a mystery to me), then what is the reproducing mechanism? My understanding is that viruses reproduce themselves by hijacking the DNA (or RNA?) in cells. DNA being a cell reproduction mechanism that copies protein structures. But what is it about a particular protein that can make itself reproduce and infect the body?
- genocidicbunny 6y agoMy (admittedly, very layman) understanding is that prions are proteins that are misfolded in such a way that when in proximity or contact with their 'correctly folded' version can induce them to change shape to the misfolded version. Prions are below the level of things like viruses or bacteria -- they are a result of the underlying chemistry of making proteins. Proteins and their folding is arranging atoms into energetically favorable states. A prion is then a different arrangement of the atoms that is somewhat more energetically favorable, one that can induce other proteins to transition to this different state. It is this last property that makes them infectious.
- adammunich 6y agoIt catalyzes others like ice-9
- teachingassist 6y agoProteins are produced as a string (either literally as a chain molecule, or in the computer science sense of a string of characters/amino acids). Once a protein is formed in the body, it naturally folds into its useful, functional shape with the purpose it was designed for. A 'misfolding protein' is then a folding into a stable shape which is not desired. A 'prion' is a misfolding protein that encourages other proteins of the same type to misfold in the same way - maybe by acting as an incorrect template for folding. When this is folded in a way that is difficult for the body to break down, and somehow enabling its sibling proteins to do the same, you start to have problems. So, a prion is a protein structure able to reproduce itself, in some way. Prions are not 'viruses', where viruses have their own DNA (or RNA) for making their own proteins. There's an argument about whether viruses are 'alive', since they depend on others' cells to make their proteins. Prions are even less considered 'alive' - they are just inert single protein molecules folded in a particular way. But, they have the ability to reproduce, in some sense.
- medstrom 6y agoDoes cannibalism have an inherent propensity to create/spread prions or is it just incidental?
- saagarjha 6y agoEating infected meat is a way to get infected by prions, which otherwise don't really spread.
- teachingassist 6y agoIt's thought yes: Continuing my explanation from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27094602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27094602 "A 'prion' is a misfolding protein that encourages other proteins of the same type to misfold in the same way - maybe by acting as an incorrect template for folding." So, if you introduce a human prion - here by eating a human and perhaps brain in particular - it will potentially start this process by acting as a first template. (Other animal prions are typically less likely to start this process, since animal proteins will likely be too different)
- p1mrx 6y agoWild speculation: Maybe a lot of humans have prions, and the ones who survive until birth are just lucky enough to be genetically immune to their own. Cannibalism copies the protein to someone without that immunity. And maybe the proteins of different species are usually too incompatible to be dangerous.
- philipswood 6y ago(Ignoring prions for now) Eating your own kind should definitely expose you to pathogens, infections and parasites that are directly compatible with you. I think in nature it would tend to be a bad strategy due to this, even though in cases it would make a lot of sense otherwise. IIRC the SF novel 'The Legacy of Heorot' had an alien life cycle/population dynamic based on this idea of using cannibalism coupled with a staged life-cycle to allow the creature to exploit a wider ecological niche. The juveniles were herbivores and the adult forms then ate the juveniles, forming a joined niche.
- smackeyacky 6y ago
- DonHopkins 6y agoIf God didn't mean for people to eat each other, then they wouldn't be made out of meat! ;) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjAHw2DEBgw&ab_channel=VariousArtists-Topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjAHw2DEBgw&ab_channel=Vario...
- roenxi 6y agoRevulsion is a "seriously, this is a bad idea" signal from evolution. Do a quick inventory and see just how many psychological barriers there are to cannibalism. Considering how important calories have been for most of history and what a 'traditional' diet looks ... it must be really be a mistake to eat people.
- eatonphil 6y agoI'm fine with focusing on the ethical/moral reasons against cannibalism. I was revolted by fish, squid, and tofu as a kid until I forced myself to get used to them as an adult. I still find the thought of eating insects revolting but there are many valid ways to do so.
- CyanBird 6y agoThat's a postdoc rationalization based on your western perspectives There are more than a few cultures which disprove your general angle, on South East Asia there are still a couple cannibal groups, which base their cannibalism on eating perceived witches and did it on a semiritualistic fashion to ensure that the witches spirits could not come back and haunt them/put a spell on them There are many, many, many references of through the discovery of SEA islets of colonizers finding Cannibal tribes and groups whom would instead eat them to (is through) acquiring "their power" which is a strong motif that's replicated on West and Central African animistic groups and tribes Do remember reading of more than a couple times several years ago of reading East European cannibal tribes through the 700s, and this was beyond the post Roman vilification of "barbarians" Anyhow my core is that, this is quite, quite common throughout human history, same with human sacrifice Apologies for lack of references I am on my phone, I'll add them later
- asimjalis 6y agoThis is something the article does not make clear. Why can’t prions be transmitted through eating non-human animals like cows?
- mariodiana 6y ago> [I]t was just a twisted protein, capable of performing the microscopic equivalent of a Jedi mind trick, compelling normal proteins on the surface of nerve cells in the brain to contort just like them. The so-called "prions," or "proteinaceous infectious particles," would eventually misfold enough proteins to kill pockets of nerve cells in the brain […] Disclaimer: Somebody stop me if I'm spreading misinformation, because I am way out of my wheelhouse. Honestly, I would like to be disabused of this suspicion if it's entirely fanciful. So, if someone knows something about what I'm about to discuss, please weigh in. The subject is genetically modified organisms. My understanding is that at least some (if not all) GMO's are produced by bombarding an organism's genetic material with radiation and then separating out modified organisms that seem to be useful. This process, however, does result in misfolded proteins. Often, scientists judge that these misfolded proteins are of no harm, and so some GMO's (if not all) make it to market with misfolded proteins. That's my understanding. I'm wondering two things. First, is my above account (over-simplified in any case) basically right or way off base? Second, if it's basically right, aren't we playing a very dangerous game with things we don't understand well enough?
- larssorenson 6y agoGMO's are not produced by targeted radiation in the way you have described, at least not as common practice (i.e. the GMO food you buy isn't created this way). GMO crops are generated in two ways: targeted gene modification (with deliberate modifications being made in contrast to the randomness of the radiation method you described) and crossbreeding (which has a more randomized effect but does not involve radiation). If you look at the [Wikipedia article on genetic engineering techniques](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_engineering_techniques https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_engineering_techniqu...) radiation doesn't appear once.
- gregw134 6y agoCreating new crop varieties using radiation is a thing, here are some wiki articles discussing it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutation_breeding#New_mutagen_techniques https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutation_breeding#New_mutagen_... I also remember seeing a news article about using radiation to breed new rice variants that have more nutrients, but I can't find it anymore.
- xallarap 6y agoIt's not from ppl eating ppl, it's from ppl eating ppls brains, specifically.
- alien_player 6y agoFirst thing that came to mind: "It's something prion related."
- uwagar 6y agowow, one wonders what the spike protein made by the covid-19 vaccines could do...the narrative appears presenting just a protein for the immune system to tackle instead of the whole virus is without risk.
- MertsA 6y ago>wow, one wonders what the spike protein made by the covid-19 vaccines could do Here's what it does. https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.121.318902 https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.121.31890... >presenting just a protein for the immune system to tackle instead of the whole virus is without risk. The level of S protein produced from a vaccine is substantially less than someone infected with SARS-CoV-2. Covid-19 is not a prion disease, the protein doesn't cause any kind of catalytic misfolding of other proteins. No one said new vaccines are without risk, that's why even a one-in-a-million reaction causing blood clots was enough to halt the administration of the J&J vaccine until it could be studied further. These vaccines have been studied for over a year on a massive chunk of the world population, any kind of adverse reaction that hasn't already been caught would have to be so rare that no matter what demographic we're talking about you're at substantially greater risk of harm from Covid-19 than from any as of yet unknown side effect of any of the mainstream vaccines.
- uwagar 6y agojust like the kuru, the effects may develop long term. 1 year study is not enough to catch that.
- ChrisArchitect 6y agoold previous discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14079026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14079026
- stunt 6y agoI once heard a story of how a report by historian turned into cannibalism report after bad translation. Apparently he quoted the phrase "they eat each other alive for food", while the true story was that farmers kill each other fighting for land and water.
- nix23 6y agoWhen cows ate cows, a strange disease emerged too.