5 ms·
In this case, though, I don't believe it's just calculation vs. intuition. The reason the 100 or million door problem helped me understand was because it clarif
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
In this case, though, I don't believe it's just calculation vs. intuition. The reason the 100 or million door problem helped me understand was because it clarified an implicit rule of the game: that the door the host chooses to open is not random. If it were random, it would make for a very boring game ("Uhh, there's the prize, you win, I guess that's game over.") Once I understood that the host would only ever open "goat" doors, that's when I better understood the argument.
- FabHK 6y agoIndeed, that is a crucial bit of information that is not made explicit in the original framing of the problem.
- mkl 6y agoI think it's made pretty explicit. In this version: "Then, the host, who is well-aware of what’s going on behind the scenes, opens door #3, revealing one of the goats." The host has to open a door that doesn't show the car.
- someguydave 6y agoYeah - I don't think that statement clarifies. The rule that the host will never reveal the prize should be made explicit.
- listenallyall 6y agoYou're quoting Priceonomic's 2021 description of the problem. This is NOT the 1990 Parade Magazine description of the problem that generated all the responses.
- mkl 6y agoThe 1990 Parade Magazine description is almost identical (and actually more explicit, since "say #3" is a removable parenthetical): "the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat" -- https://web.archive.org/web/20130121183432/http://marilynvossavant.com/game-show-problem/ https://web.archive.org/web/20130121183432/http://marilynvos... The host's knowledge is explicitly mentioned, and the only purpose this could have is that so he can use it to avoid giving the game away.
- FabHK 6y agoThat is literally not explicit (where by "literally" I mean literally, not figuratively, and by "explicit", I mean explicit, not implicit). It is sort of hinted at, but it is not explicitly said that the host will mechanically reveal a door that has a goat. It is quite conceivable that the host picks a door randomly, or in fact that he picks the door with the car with a certain probability (saving the show quite some money).
- ncallaway 6y ago> It is literally explicit in the 1990 rendition. > You pick a door, say #1, and the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat Remove the parenthetical example "say #3", and the parenthetical "who knows what's behind the doors" and that sentence reads: "...and the host opens another door which has a goat". The "has a goat" is not a hypothetical example. It's a (both literal and explicit) declaration of the rules statement. The rules seem very clear that the host will open a door with a goat.
- slavik81 6y agoIt matters whether they choose the door because it has a goat vs. they randomly choose a door that happens to have a goat. It's not explicitly saying the former even when stating the result, because everything is written as a certainty in retrospect. You can say, "the roulette wheel stopped on 00," but it was still a random event when it happened.
- dekhn 6y agonope, it's ambiguous as stated, if you're a literalist.
- listenallyall 6y agoIt's a tv show - a valid purpose is that he needs to stretch by 30 seconds before going to commercial. Another purpose is that the audience thinks seeing a goat is funny. Another purpose is to prove the show uses two different goats and doesn't do a switcheroo behind the scenes. What the Parade article does NOT say is that the first door opened is ALWAYS not the contestant's choice and ALWAYS reveals a goat.
- nzealand 6y agoMarilyn had the same framing of the problem as everyone else. Marilyn made her key assumptions explicit in the original explanation she gave. 92% of people still disagreed with her. And most of them seemed fully aware that she had the guiness world record for the highest IQ in the world. To paraphrase Paul Graham's recent article, If the smartest person in the world proposed an idea that sounded preposterous, I'd be very reluctant to say "You are wrong."
- Winsaucerer 6y agoThat was exactly what happened with me. I hadn't understood in the original proposal that the host's choice is not random. At some point during someone's offer of the '100 door' version, I realised they were operating with this extra piece of information I lacked.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- acomjean 6y agoCan’t it be random if there are two goat doors the host has to choose from? But I see your point about it clarifying the problem.
- flomo 6y agoOne of the sources of confusion with this is Monty Hall did not always behave the way the problem dictates. He sometimes would open the prize door right away, or he would reveal a goat that was not behind a door or etcetera.
- flomo 6y agoOne of the sources of confusion with this was Monty Hall did not always behave the way the problem dictates. He sometimes would open the prize door right away, or he would reveal a goat that was not behind a door or etcetera.