3 ms·
> money that expires unless you spend it on goods Why would anyone want that?
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
> money that expires unless you spend it on goods
Why would anyone want that?
- kqr 6y agoI presume that sort of money would be cheaper than the other kind. It's never a question of whether anyone wants lower-quality money, it's only a question of price.
- hahaxdxd123 6y agoYou wouldn't want it. The Bidenbucks you get in a crisis would be the expiring money. It would force you to go spend it on food to keep your local restaurants alive, or replace your phone to keep the factories running, etc. Instead we all got $1200 and pumped it into Doge, some EV SPAC, or similar speculative "investments".
- MrPatan 6y agoWhy wouldn't the expiring bidenbucks be spent on Doge?
- iamacyborg 6y agoPresumably, the money expiring would put a downward price pressure on something like Doge as no one could afford the newly inflated price
- imtringued 6y agoThe seller gets bidenbucks. What is he going to do with them? Buy Doge?
- dskloet 6y agoIf they remain bidenbucks when spent, why would any merchant accept them for anything?
- dmantis 6y agoBut this is my money then, isn't it? My property - my rules. If I have enough money without this check due to personal savings and economy, it would be pretty much unequal and unfair situation if I won't get anything from this helicopter money (making it expire) and some guy who got himself several debts for parties and travelling will get help. Let's say that people actually spend money given to them, but invest their remaining saving into investments, if that make someone feel better. If I have my own 1200USD and get "expiable" 1200USD for free - it doesn't matter which one I spend, technically.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoWhy wouldn't people immediately trade this expiring "money" for any other currency, precious metal? Even memecoins are better than holding currency that's guaranteed to disappear. This is government-enforced consumerism. Nobody wants to be forced to buy random stuff they don't need just to keep some struggling businesses alive. Saving or investing this money is a much better decision.
- hahaxdxd123 6y agoBecause you can't? Every purchase would be coded like they already are with credit cards. You can spend it only on the right category. Good luck trying to launder it when every transaction is logged and easily queryable. "Government-enforced consumerism" sounds an awful lot better to me than picking winners and losers like in 2008 or massive stimulus that did nothing but boost asset prices like 2020.
- dskloet 6y ago> Because you can't? You could make informal trades where you pay for something someone else would have already bought and give them a small discount. Or just buy something and resell it immediately.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Because you can't? > Good luck trying to launder it when every transaction is logged and easily queryable. I buy something for someone, they pay me back in normal money or XMR.
- hahaxdxd123 6y agoCool! The money was still spent on a good or service like it was intended.
- drexlspivey 6y agoExample, when the economy slows down the government sends you a 1000$ stimulus check that you must use in 30 days
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matheusmoreira 6y agoI understand but why would anyone actually want that policy? If I have money, I should be able to do what I want with it, not what the government wants me to do. It looks like they want to make it impossible to save money in order to increase consumption "for the good of the economy". I wonder how people are supposed to increase their net worth like this.
- bbatha 6y agoStimulus isn’t supposed to increase net worth it was to provide people cash for the essentials and to artificially increase demand in the economy. Sitting in a bank account doesn’t help anyone until they retire decades from when they get the stimulus.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoI see. So in this case only the stimulus would expire.