5 ms·
Audacity Telemetry and Why Free Software Means Better Privacy
- meibo 6y agoSo much FUD and derailment in that GitHub pull request, wow. Hundreds of comments talking about names for forks and alternative software. The original PR description absolutely was not explicit enough, and they probably shouldn't have went with a third party data processor in the first place, but the way they are trying to handle it is sensible in my opinion (opt-in, ask only once, disable the code path otherwise).
- hashhar 6y agoThe issue I see it that Linux distributions generally build software from source on their own CI. This means that their telemetry data won't reflect Linux users habits and hence be useless at best or detrimental in the worst case to the decisions made using said incomplete telemetry.
- merb 6y ago> If you are compiling Audacity from source, we will provide a CMake option to enable the telemetry code. This option will be turned off by default.
- hashhar 6y agoDistributions will disable telemetry by default. e.g. Debian etc. Only individuals running from-source OS or package managers will be able to enable telemetry.
- capableweb 6y agoMy guess is that Linux users (or users who use package managers in general) are happy to provide bug reports or even patches when they find bugs. Less can be said about users downloading the binaries directly from Audacity's website (Windows and macOS users), which I'm guessing is a fair bit of share. Those users will still get the choice to enable telemetry or not, and I guess those are the most important to get the telemetry from, as they are not as happy to provide bug reports nor patches.
- hashhar 6y agoThat a very valid point. But the sad truth is that if the people in charge of deciding product direction are the people looking at telemetry instead of bug reports/patches from users then in the end the Linux user's interests will not be high up (or even visible) to the product direction decider. I've seen this happen before at some previous workplaces where the telemetry and analytics was the only factor controlling decisions - and this lead to the vocal (but not visible in telemetry) userbase getting the short end of the stick on many occasions.
- ergot_vacation 6y agoNothing is sensible about forcing telemetry functionality into a project like Audacity. It's a blatantly hostile act toward the user base, and likely the first step toward attempting to monetize them.
- Bancakes 6y agoI don't even want the code path in the binary at all. At worst, have it be a downloadable addon.
- IshKebab 6y agoWhy? That's such an extreme view.
- Bancakes 6y agoThey could be fixing bugs and adding features. It's FOSS, just look at the git issues. Telemetry is the ultimate "We don't want to listen to opinions in forums.". Why telemetry, I'll tell you my troubles directly.
- IshKebab 6y agoThis is so they can fix bugs. Did you read the bit about how they are adding telemetry so they can debug rare crashes?
- valdiorn 6y agonot just FUD, the entitlement that shows through is staggering. This is from one of the comments: "" You have failed from the very outset to identify that as a widely used and well loved FOSS, you will be, and must be, at all times subject to public scrutiny of decisions prior to ANY kind of code changes being submitted. "" I know audacity was acquired recently, but these people were, until about 3 days prior to that pull request, most likely unpaid volunteers working on a hobby project for fun. It's that sort of attitude (the "you will and must be subject to public scrutiny") which is why my open source projects are only open source, I dump my code on github for people to learn from them, but I have absolutely no interest in engaging in this sort of discussion to grow my projects. And there is no lack of entitled comments on my Github issues pages.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Proprietary apps almost universally default to opt out for tracking (if they give an option at all). This is because companies understand the power of defaults. If their users had to consent before being tracked, many if not most of them would say no. Since so many of these apps are funded by capturing and selling user data, that's too big a risk to take." "Tech" companies want users to believe tracking is not optional. They want users to believe no tracking means no more more internet, no more web, no more apps. Totally untrue. It just means no more "tech" companies selling users out as ad targets.
- sofixa 6y ago> It just means no more "tech" companies selling users out as ad targets. which just means that those tech companies will probably ( to keep up the same type of revenues, i doubt indiscriminate ads could be as profitable) have to make their products paid, which will automatically exclude the vast majority of the planet's inhabitants.
- est31 6y agoI think opt-in telemetry is useful. Many users don't have the technical ability, or simply don't care enough, to report issues. Also maybe they use one feature really often while using another one less often. Maybe the UI should thus show the often used feature. The question is though whether to send data to Google and Yandex out of all analytics providers. I think this is a culture clash issue. IIRC Google analytics is quite the standard when it comes to telemetry, so some product owner who previously worked on proprietary software might have used the Google product throughout their entire career, might be very familiar with it, etc. For them it's a no-brainer to choose it again. The FLOSS community of course has an alleric reaction especially to Google tracking. Had they self-hosted the analytics, the reaction would have been way less negative I think. FTR I side with the FOSS community here.
- sofixa 6y agoIt's because people confuse Google's tracking of people to serve them better ads in order to get more money from advertisers and their product, Google Analytics, aimed at advertisers to see statistics about people visiting their sites, and the effectiveness of the Google Ad Network. Google Analytics, without the ad-related features enabled ( they aren't by default), is anonymous and only collects and stores generic data like http request, times, location, language, browser, OS, etc. Neither Google nor the Analytics user "track" or "spy" on the website user. With the extra ad features enabled, it's more complicated because it allows creating user groups and retargering via DoubleClick cookies, so it's a lot less acceptable from a privacy standpoint, since Google identify the site user ( with a pseudonymous identifier) for retargeting with ads later on another site. The advertiser still knows very little about the site user, and Google are just the intermediary. Google Analytics without the ad stuff is just a good, easy to use site analytics solution. It's easily blocked, but so are all the others in a similar vein. It bothers me a bit that I can't just block the ad part without the rest, because people who run websites need to know what happens with them (access.log is very cumbersome to parse, and lacks a lot of very useful information like screen size, time spent on page to know if it's just a misclick or a legitimate visit, etc.) https://developers.google.com/analytics/resources/concepts/gaConceptsTrackingOverview https://developers.google.com/analytics/resources/concepts/g...
- arsome 6y agoMozilla gets away with opt-out, I don't see why Audacity can't get away with opt-in.
- Bancakes 6y agoNo they don't, the Free Software Foundation's IceCat cleans that up.
- jacobmischka 6y agoYes they do, because I have never even heard of that.
- approxim8ion 6y agoIceCat is ridiculously out of date at this point. It is built out of the Firefox ESR base. The current ESR is 78.10.1, IceCat is on 60.7.0.
- Bancakes 6y agoThe binaries, yes. But it's just a collection of patches applied to upstream FF when you build from source. I'm compiling 78.10.1 as we speak.
- torstenvl 6y agoDo you want to live in a world where the best thing that can be said about the software you use is that it isn't worse than what other software was able to get away with? Demand better.
- arsome 6y agoEh, I don't see opt-in as a bad compromise here either, it'd be one thing if they were trying to sell the data in some way, but there's beneficial information they're gaining from that data from a maintenance and UI design perspective.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]