3 ms·
For the former, if someone is actually willing to listen to evidence, you can cite them numbers of average years of life lost per covid death (~15).
by whimsicalism 6y ago
For the former, if someone is actually willing to listen to evidence, you can cite them numbers of average years of life lost per covid death (~15).
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>you can cite them numbers of average years of life lost per covid death That's practically inviting them to cite back the average life lost from the 1918 flu. If you're trying to counter someone who's downplaying Covid that is probably not something you should invite them to do.
- AnotherGoodName 6y agoThat's fine though. If they point out that COVID is merely in the same order of magnitude but not objectively worse than Spanish Flu then the point that COVID should not be downplayed has been won.
- Revery42 6y agoI believe there are a significant amount of these people that won't actually argue that just because the Spanish flu was worse in this way that the Covid pandemic isn't a problem.
- whimsicalism 6y agoAs the other poster said, if that's the argument you're resorting to, I would say you've already lost. I've found it is helpful to count by equivalent number of deaths to something that the person has actually experienced, as it is way too easy to brush away deaths that occurred in 1918. For instance, it's as if you took the number of years of life lost in 9/11 and multiplied it by 120.
- xkjkls 6y agoIs the point here to argue that the Spanish Flu was worse? Yes, it was. But I think someone crying, "This is the worst pandemic in 100 years", sounds like they are pretty on the money.
- mettamage 6y ago^ This is my argument as well. I also translate every probability to sequential coin tosses.
- Revery42 6y agoAnd for the latter, you can cite excess mortality rates. Good example of the asymmetry of bullshit here.
- hervature 6y agoI believe the counterargument is to that what is worse, 1/15 of the population losing 15 years or the entire population losing 1 year keeping in mind that 1 year in your prime is probably worth more than 1 year in your old age. These numbers are not COVID specific, just going off your ~15. For COVID numbers, even with 1M deaths, that would be 1/330 (US population) losing on average ~15 years vs. everyone losing almost 2 years now. It's emotionally tough to pick a policy when you are condemning one group to statistical death, but you still have to try and be objective. My personal opinion is that we'll be writing books about the "the lost generation" in 10 years about children currently in school.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> or the entire population losing 1 year Except we didn't lose a year. A lot of us actually kind of liked the last year. Many got to work from home and discovered it was a lot less stressful than commuting into an office every day, for example. I have a feeling that some of us are going to recall the last year with a bit of nostalgia in the future.
- nostromo 6y agoAll available data is showing that this past year has been detrimental to poor students. Imagine trying to learn on an old phone, using a cellular internet connection in a bedroom you share with your sister. So, while I'm glad you enjoyed your year at home -- the focus here was on the impact on students.
- nonameiguess 6y agoThat isn't true. The parent comment said the "entire population" lost a year of their lives. K-12 students are about 17% of the US population, not all of it.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoIt hasn't been detrimental for all students. Some have thrived. https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=some-students-have-taken-to-remote-learning-theyre-thriving-in-fact-COVID-coronavirus https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=some-students-have-taken-to...
- anoncake 6y agoThen multiply it with the death rate.
- nradov 6y agoThe studies that I've seen on years of life lost per COVID-19 death all appeared to suffer from co-morbidity bias, particularly around obesity and related metabolic disorders. We know those conditions seriously increase the risk of COVID-19 death. https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/obesity-and-covid-19.html https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/obesity-and-covid-19.html And they also reduce life expectancy on their own even without COVID-19. Being obese cuts life expectancy by about 7 years. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12513041/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12513041/ So the actual average YLL is probably a little less than 15. I don't blame the researchers for this bias. The detailed data to correct for it generally isn't available so they're doing their best with what they have.