18 ms·
Amazon Fake Reviews Scam Exposed in Data Breach
- fortran77 6y agoI hope Fakespot gets to integrate this leak in their dataset!
- bagacrap 6y agoor at least use it as training data
- blakesterz 6y agoWow, the scale of this surprised me. Made me wonder, do these services offer both positive and negative reviews? That is, if I want, can I get 5 stars on my stuff, and then also pay for 1 star on my competition? "In total, 13,124,962 of these records (or 7 GB of data) have been exposed in the breach, potentially implicating more than 200,000 people in unethical activities."
- mkmk 6y agoSometimes even the threat of negative reviews is used as a method of extortion against competitive sellers.
- geocrasher 6y agoIt's nice to see hard evidence of this, but anecdotal evidence is plain to see on Amazon.com reviews. For example, a product gets a lot of 5 star reviews stating that the buyer bought it for their child/relative/friend and they are just sure that they will love it... 5 stars! Or "I just got this delivered yesterday and I haven't used it yet but it looks really great!"... 5 stars. These are then immediately followed by a 1 star review along the lines of "This is the biggest piece of junk I've ever bought online. Will be returning to Amazon. DO NOT BUY!" These aren't to be confused with the indiscriminate idiots who can't be bothered to use their brains, who leave mindless reviews such as "This is junk but it was cheap and kinda works... 5 stars!" Right. Most times this trend of 5's followed by 1's is seen even in the first page of reviews. It's a serious problem with the platform. I usually search for reviews written by people who have had the product for a week or two and give the pros/cons along with a less than 5 star rating. That helps me avoid the fakes and the idiots. This makes me wonder why Amazon, in all their analytical genius, isn't cracking down on this when it's so blatantly obvious.
- mschuster91 6y agoIn the pre-Internet world there would be someone at the store who would a) do a checkout of the product prior to listing and b) evaluate customer returns and act upon them, in order to protect the integrity of the store. Delivering crap would lead to consequences (in the worst case de-listing) for the vendor. Amazon doesn't do either - sellers are allowed to put up basically everything that's legal to sell somewhere on the world (including propaganda materials for all kinds of questionable groups including right-wing terrorism), and they don't care at all about complaints from customers about fake products or shoddy quality. They only seem to care when big media representatives short-circuit the system and raise a stink at the PR team.
- shagie 6y ago> These aren't to be confused with the indiscriminate idiots who can't be bothered to use their brains, who leave mindless reviews such as "This is junk but it was cheap and kinda works... 5 stars!" Right. I wouldn't say that they were indiscriminate nor not bothered to use their brains. One of the all too often seen things is a card for "leave a 5 star review and get a $10 amazon gift card" in the package. Yes, its part of an effort to get 5 star reviews since the sorting of the product on amazon is more important than the text in the reviews below the fold. Yes, that's unscrupulous on both the buyer's and the seller's part. But it is not indiscriminate or brainless on the part of the reviewer. It's selfish.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoAnd yet! And yet, like Google, Amazon now prefixes my search results with "Amazon's Choice" or some other marketing crap. Man, I remember when you could trust reviews, search for an item, filter anything below 4 stars and get a decent, reliable list of products to choose from. You felt like you had some of the best damn kitchen knives your budget could afford.
- geocrasher 6y agoTrue, but "Selfish indiscriminate idiots" just doesn't have the same ring to it ;-)
- 6y ago
- jerhewet 6y agoAnyone know if sites like Fakespot will be incorporating this information into their review engines?
- 0-_-0 6y agoMaybe you could train a neural network using confirmed-fake reviews to assign an adjusted rating to products
- naresh_xai 6y agoAnd 2 weeks later, the guy will resell stuff from another account from different paid reviews. Which are also always evolving to capture consumer trust. Works especially well for products in usd 1k range.
- 0-_-0 6y agoWell that's why you trained a neural network and not just used a database!
- SteveGerencser 6y agoAs someone that helps clients with their Amazon stores, this is not a surprise, what is the surprise is that so few people know about. Review scamming has been an issue on Amazon for a very long time and each time that Amazon rolls out a new method of combating it the review sellers simply pivot and keep right on rolling. The hardest part for a lot of smaller sellers is that with enough negative reviews you can have your account locked or even cancelled and there is nothing (not much) you can do about it, just like dealing with a Google or Facebook lockout. There is no recourse for most people.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chenster 6y agoAlizon
- system16 6y agoIt's gotten to the point where a product with thousands of reviews and an average 4.5 - 5 star rating immediately raises a red flag with me. And Amazon appears unmotivated to do anything about it. As a personal example, I had purchased a mouth guard that had over six thousand 5-star reviews. It was listed as high quality, FDA approved, etc. When I received it, it was a piece of plastic junk with inkjet quality instructions in English and Chinese. Along with it came a note promising a $10 Amazon gift card if I left a 5 star review and emailed them proof of it. I took a photo of the note and forwarded it to Amazon expecting some action - instead I received a canned response about "we take these issues seriously". A year later, that seller is still there with dozens of products, all with thousands of 5-star reviews.
- catillac 6y agoFor what it’s worth, and a little off topic, I would never ever purchase a product that went in or closely on my body from Amazon. Jacket? Maybe. Food? Not likely. Mouth guard that sits in my mouth for hours every night? Absolutely not, no, ever. Too many fake products that look like they’re the real things, and if they’re fake who knows where they come from or what they’re made of.
- wombat-man 6y agoyeah, it's fucked up that it's come to this but I'm the same way. I don't even really care about reviews anymore on amazon. I just don't believe the star rating. Reviews with pictures seem better, or like reddit reviews if it's a brand name.
- varispeed 6y agoI don't think most of products they sell are actually legal to be sold. If you had these products in your mom and pops shop, the trading standards or whatever agency would shut down your store, but somehow Amazon is allowed to sell all this dangerous junk without consequences and they are even allowed to avoid paying tax. Something isn't right.
- 6y ago
- ericwooley 6y agoI've been using https://reviewmeta.com/ https://reviewmeta.com/ for a while now. It removes reviews from most products, and shows you what it thinks the most trustworthy, and least trust worthy reviews are. It's pretty inexcusable that Amazon hasn't implemented a similar approach. They certainly have enough resources.
- josefresco 6y agoI've used ReviewMeta as well, however I find the issue is that almost every product has suspicious reviews. If the average rating was 4.8 on Amazon, RM might lower it to 4.3 but they would also do the same for competing products. I guess maybe I'm lucky in that I've never considered a product with blatantly fake reviews, however I also recognize that in order to compete even legitimate companies need to "play the game".
- notacoward 6y agoYes. A great many product categories are so filled with scammers that if you reject the ones with bad scores on Fakespot or ReviewMeta you'll end up with nothing. Which could be an argument for shopping somewhere other than Amazon, except that you might only find one or two stores that have The Thing and then you'll have no information on how good it really is. It might even be the very same thing you looked at on Amazon, or you might fail to find it elsewhere at all. I've ended up buying some real clunkers IRL too, and found some unexpectedly good stuff on Amazon. "Caveat emptor" was a saying long before the internet, after all. No matter where you buy, you're taking a bit of a risk and should try to manage it however you can. I still use ReviewMeta, and often follow where it leads if there's a distinction, but I also think we have a lot of work to do applying what we already know about gaming-resistant filtering in domains like this.
- everybodyknows 6y agoSpot-testing ReviewMeta just now, I see it accepts this, from #2 of the Amazon top 10,000, as valid: https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R17NDQEUZQESUX/ref=cm_cr_dp_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B08QVGB3CN https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R17NDQEUZQESUX/re...
- dynm 6y agoI've always wondered why Amazon didn't take a "collaborative filtering" approach to reviews -- basically take your ratings and then give you recommendations based on others who tend to give similar ratings. It seems like this would mean that the scammers would mostly just give their nonsense reviews to other scammers.
- dylan604 6y ago"Was this review helpful to you?" Maybe there should be a concerted effort of "people" to start clicking "No" to that question on obvious fake reviews. There's already sites tracking bad reviews, so "borrow" their list, create some bots, and start negating fake reviews. ??
- naresh_xai 6y agoCompanies list/re-list products on amazon faster than you can say ‘go’ unfortunately.
- dylan604 6y agoThis is one thing that I think YouTube gets right. Once a video has been posted and comments have been posted, liked, etc, you cannot change that video in any form. This is on the premise of avoid bait-n-switch to put of a video to garner the positive response and then swapping it out with a different video. Amazon should do something similar.
- gowld 6y agoIt's a lot harder. Google makes all the copies of a video. Amazon doesn't make all the copies of a product.
- Nasrudith 6y agoI don't thunk that would work with physical objects very well. Especially when recalls are done via serial number. Apparent identical physical objects are always fundamentally different from each other unlike data.
- varispeed 6y agoI wish by law Amazon (and other stores) were forced to show country of origin of the products. Last week I needed to buy a new kettle and this was a nightmare to find a product that is not made in China (for ethical reasons). It should be as easy as selecting a country you want a product from - instead you have to go through each individual listing, look through photos or answers. Sometimes it is easy to find where product is made by just looking at description (e.g. broken English), but some sellers go out of their way to mask where things are made. As a consumer I should be able to filter products I don't want more easily. Then when you order a product you get these cards that say if you leave a positive review, you'll get a discount or free product. If you leave a negative review, you can brace yourself for being bombarded by Chinese companies threatening you in various ways to delete the review. Amazon needs to sort this out and if they cannot do it, regulator should step in. edit: here we go again, something negative about China and commment is being downvoted. Can Hacker News do something about Chinese bots?
- simion314 6y agoYou could have been downvoted by "true americans" that hate any kind of regulation and think that free market solves anything. IMO regulation for more transparency should be no issue with the anti-regulation fans except if they would be affected by transparency.
- ticviking 6y agoTransparency is a kind of regulation though. One that I think we sorely need. Along side anti-basic anti-trust and some small protective tariffs for countries that don't have good labor standards. Much of the cost of stuff made in the first world is the cost of having a first world regulatory framework and workplace protections.
- simion314 6y ago>Transparency is a kind of regulation though. Sure, and the anti-regulation or anti-tax guys still demand that police protect their money and goods - so I can't understand when the anti-regulation fanatic is saying that free market will eventually solve this , transparency is too much of a burden or danger.
- insickness 6y agoLast year, I posted a negative review of an inexpensive (~$10) electronic device on Amazon. A few weeks later, the seller contacted me with an offer of a $20 Amazon gift certificate to take it down. I didn't respond. A few days later, they offered $30, then $40, then $50.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoThat's funny, you can make a business out of "leave bad reviews and don't respond to the first offer to change it" =)
- shoefindortz 6y agoI've also received around ~10 of these same emails offering increasing prices to remove my review. Maybe this is a good investment opportunity? I'm joking, but they did offer me almost twice the price of the product itself, which is interesting. Something also curious is that the seller initially sent emails starting with with "Hi, [my sister's name]". Her name was not associated with my amazon account at all, and definitely not the name shown on the amazon review. I wonder where they are retrieving the names from for this.
- sodality2 6y agoAddress info, maybe? That's creepy, I hope you reported it.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoYour lucky. The last two times I tried to post a review on Amazon, Amazon declined the review under some pretense or another. I've stopped writing reviews on Amazon. Apparently you can't talk trash about a product you were unhappy with....
- zanmat0 6y agoYou should take their offer and repost your review a week later, including some information about their bribery.
- pupppet 6y agoBasically every Amazon product has a 4.5 star average rating now, the reviews are useless.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoUnverified claims are useless* Reviews are largely unverified claims with financial incentives. You bet they're useless.
- crazygringo 6y agoAm I the only one not particularly bothered by fake reviews? Because there's a button for "Helpful" on each review, and the most helpful reviews more or less generally get voted to the top -- and there are almost always some really long, in-depth ones. I don't even pay attention to star ratings anymore. I just read the top 10 reviews and get a pretty good sense of what specifically is good and bad about the product. Even without fake reviews, star proportions were never that useful in the first place because they're not a random sampling of users, and people are way more likely to leave a review to complain than to praise, so it's biased no matter what.
- danparsonson 6y agoSo the star ratings can be gamed but not the 'helpful' button?
- taeric 6y agoWould be amusing if it was the queen's duck. (Probably more accurate to call it a honey pot.) Basically, as long as the stars are there, they capture most of the fraud?
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm sure it could be in theory but it doesn't seem to be in practice. I think the logistics would just be harder -- it's relatively simply to put a leaflet in the product advertising "leave a 5-star review, then e-mail us and get this bonus product/warranty/whatever." Whereas to locate a specific review to mark "Helpful" would need to be via e-mail with a link to a specific review in question, coordinated across several of them, with so much volume that it outweighs the naturally "helpful" ones. I don't know, but I've never seen it happen.
- danparsonson 6y agoIf I were an unscrupulous seller, I'd write a nice review myself, pay a stooge to post it, then pay a bunch of other stooges to mark it helpful repeatedly for the next six months from different IP addresses. I don't think it'd be all that hard but then again I've never tried it.
- kgodey 6y agoI reviewed books regularly on Amazon years ago and made it into their top 10,000 reviewers list. Ever since then, I regularly get emails from Amazon sellers asking me to review their products. Before Amazon introduced the "verified purchase" system, they would offer to send me the product, now they ask me to buy their product and they'll refund me on PayPal. I still get a few emails every week, even though it's been years since I reviewed anything and I'm now reviewer #1,263,485.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoThere's a top 10,000 reviewers list? That sounds like a problem to me. It should be called top 10,000 users to bribe for reviews.
- kgodey 6y agoYup, here it is: https://www.amazon.com/review/top-reviewers https://www.amazon.com/review/top-reviewers. Edited to add: I think it takes into account how many people vote your reviews as helpful. I got a lot of helpful votes because I received books weeks or months before they were released (I had a book review blog) and would post reviews on the release date so they would be one of the first reviews up.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoTo me that proves Amazon entices and enables this fake review bs. They give fraudsters everything they need without explicitly saying it.
- weasel_words 6y agoI wouldn't think this even possible?!? 24k+ reviews! https://www.amazon.com/gp/profile/amzn1.account.AENQAO4BXMO72ZH6AXVD4JVRWX6A/ref=cm_cr_tr_tbl_hof_name https://www.amazon.com/gp/profile/amzn1.account.AENQAO4BXMO7...
- everybodyknows 6y agoSkimming a hundred or so reviews from first few of the 10,000, every review is five stars, posted at rates of ten or more per week. So to the fakery professionals, it’s an industry leaderboard. To you and me, who have need to spot fake reviews, it’s a singularly valuable sample of what to be on guard against. So thanks, Amazon, for clueing us in to just how rotten your system really is!
- ThePhysicist 6y agoOften it's quite easy to spot these fake reviews. I mean a 10 $ USB-C cable with more Amazon reviews than e.g. the PS5? Sure. The popular "name brands" must really like this as these scammers ruin the collaborative review system for everyone, so people will put more trust in brand names again. Another funny thing are all the new brands that pop up on Amazon (at least in Germany). They're often picked to sound vaguely familiar (e.g. Orfeld) and trust-inspiring, and their product pages portrait them as century-old companies. Often the products they sell are sourced from whitelabel manufacturers, so you have 20-40 brands offering the same product (for wildly different prices), maybe with some small variation in packaging and color. Interestingly, some new companies like Anker have managed to build up a good "brand reputation" in 5-10 years, probably also due to the fact that they're no longer at the bottom of the trust chain.
- jader201 6y ago> I mean a 10 $ USB-C cable with more Amazon reviews than e.g. the PS5? That seems like a bad example. People are having a really hard time getting PS5s, and probably 50%+ are scalpers that don’t care about writing reviews. And cables are produced and bought at a much higher rate than video game consoles, anyway.
- 1_person 6y agoThe funny thing to me, if you think about it, is that nothing really changed, it's just become more transparent. It's for decades, if not arguably always been a bunch of bullshit marketing for meaningless labels slapped on imported knock offs of questionable quality that you just hope they sample enough of for QA to keep the factory from slipping turds and razor blades into some of the boxes.
- mitchdoogle 6y agoCables are an interesting example because they are so inexpensive and easy to produce, I can't imagine any one being much better than the others. Especially when they're all within 10-20% in price. I used to agonize over finding "the best" but then I started to realize how much time I was wasting. Just find the cheapest option with the length you want and call it a day. Same goes for most things on Amazon.
- Thaxll 6y agoWhy Amazon allow people that did not purchase the product to review it? Does not make any sense.
- coldcode 6y agoIf you read the article, they made deals to have people buy the product, give it 5 stars, and then reimbursed the buyer who got to keep the product.
- shockeychap 6y agoNone of this is surprising. I’m very sad to say this, but the internet of today, for all of its sophistication, sucks compared to what it was, and all the promise that it held, 20 years ago.
- uniqueid 6y agoI wholeheartedly agree. If you want to depress yourself further, think about how much potential for good we squander on the web in terms of medical information. If we had designed the internet differently (eg: with considerations for privacy, authenticity, verifiability) we could pool resources and have millions of people report on medications, treatments, nutrition, etc. If a regular person uses the web we actually have today to do their own health research, they're playing dice with their life.
- zucked 6y agoIt's a race to the bottom. Always has been, probably always will be.
- neuronic 6y agoThe same review scam issues exist anywhere where reviews are a thing. imdb, yelp, google... Anecdote: just before the pandemic me and my SO searched for a Sushi place one day. Found one on Google, 4.7 star average on 500ish reviews. Should be good, right? Nope. It was literally the worst restaurant experience of my life. Nobody was inside. Weird location. The menu screamed "run by cheap assholes trying to scam you". It's always a huge red flag when well over 100 menu items exist and all are from different Asian cuisines (BUT authentic Chinese restaurants will still be amazing despite 700+ items). Hungry, we still sat down and ate and dear god was it bad. I will spare you details. Some weird Indian dude pretended to service us, food was worse than gas station sushi. So what happened? We made the mistake to just look at the summed score and not the reviews. It were obvious paid Indian reviews and bots. So obvious that I was angry at myself for the stupidity not to check more closely and angry at Google to allow such bullshit on their platform.
- RootReducer 6y agoWhy does it matter that the server was Indian?
- acrobatsunfish 6y agoIt must be tiring to jump at shadows of racism all the time. He mentioned it because that's what he was. You can't get any more generic of a description then someone's gender and race.
- jonfw 6y ago'server' is significantly more generic than 'weird indian dude'
- mitchdoogle 6y agoIt's usually not necessary to mention someone's race. Nothing objective is added here because we know the server is Indian. The author is expecting the information to carry specific negative connotations with the reader, and just to make sure he adds that the server was "weird". He doubles down on making sure you understand that Indian = dishonest by mentioning fake reviews, that were surely created by Indians. Maybe they were, but that is not materially important to the situation. Fake reviews can just as easily be created by Americans, or Japanese, or literally anyone on Earth. I understand that people like you tire of hearing your thoughts and ideas challenged. It's part of the reason the world is becoming more polarized. People would rather stick their fingers in their ears and say everything is okay, rather than face the problems that exist in society. I hope you remove the fingers some day.
- toss1 6y agoThis is good to see hard evidence of a scam that has for many years been obvious to anyone who bothered to look -- Amazon reviews in any non-obscure category have been fake for years, and there are multiple startups/services working to mitigate it, e.g., Fakespot [1], which are definitely helpful. Now we get to see if Amazon is actually just really bad at filtering a bad problem, or really just DGAF as long as the fraud drives sales and commissions. What we should see is wholesale delisting, banning, and prosecution of vendors, and banning and selected prosecution of fakers. What will we actually see? I'd think Amazon would care when people abandon them because it is just too hard to find anything real, but the level of fraud on there indicates that Amazon prioritizes other metrics. When a few figure it out, it doesn't hit the traffic & sales numbers much. When many figure it out, it is likely too late. Did Bezos exit while the exiting was still good? [1] https://www.fakespot.com/ https://www.fakespot.com/
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI have to say that in retrospect, it seems fairly pathetic that back in 94-95 we (Jeff, Shel and myself) did not even think about how the review system would eventually get gamed with this level of "sophistication". I think if you had told us then that this sort of thing would eventually happen, we would not have believed you. This goes to show, perhaps, that imagining the significance of something when you're first building it is almost impossible. The notion that worldwide manufacturers and distributors would consider it so important to have "strong" amazon reviews that they would engage in this kind of behavior just would not have crossed our minds back when amazon itself had no significance. So if you're building something right now, maybe stop and ask yourself "ok, so how does this all look if we end up taking over the world 25 years from now, and this thing is a gatekeeper between a lot of people and a lot of revenue?"
- ej12n 6y ago>So if you're building something right now, maybe stop and ask yourself "ok, so how does this all look if we end up taking over the world 25 years from now, and this thing is a gatekeeper between a lot of people and a lot of revenue?" This is a fair concern, but I'd say that if you're building something right now, I think is better to worry more about getting your startup in a position to take over the world first and then deal with those concerns. Worrying about these big problems when you're small I would say is a bit of premature optimization.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIf we had known in 94 that customer reviews would eventually get gamed in this way, should we ever have added the feature? Was 15 or 20 (?) years of a "working" review system enough to make it worthwhile, and now it needs revisiting, or should we just have said "no" right at the start?
- Nasrudith 6y agoNo review system would be even worse as you cannot even tell if people are getting crap. There is already ceasesless whining about false positives being an abuse of power and in the same breath complaining about not doing enough. The "do nothing ever without the foresight of a precog or else you are EVIL!" school of ethics never made any sense. It is just an excuse to be outraged and pin all of the world's problems on the tall poppy.
- Ansil849 6y ago> The server contained a treasure trove of direct messages between Amazon vendors and customers willing to provide fake reviews in exchange for free products. In total, 13,124,962 of these records (or 7 GB of data) have been exposed in the breach, potentially implicating more than 200,000 people in unethical activities. This information should be made public. I'd love a browser plug-in which displays a warning when viewing a product from a vendor in this database, that the vendor has been known to pay for reviews, and likewise if viewing a review by someone in this database, a warning that the reviewer is a shill.
- bogwog 6y agoHonestly, the reviews are a big reason why I use Amazon. Even if I know most of them (or all of them) are fake, I feel safer buying from Amazon when a product has hundreds of reviews, compared to an online store like Walmart which may have zero reviews for the same product. It's stupid, but there's a part of my brain that likes seeing those numbers I guess. I wonder if there are any middle man review services out there that can offer product reviews to online stores, along with proper moderation. If I see a product on Walmart.com I want to buy, but there are no reviews, I'll usually search for it on Amazon just to see reviews. But once I'm on Amazon, they usually have the better price and free 2-day shipping with Prime.
- ben509 6y agoOne test is to search for something that's obviously a scam: '2TB flash drive' You know these are scams because SSD chips with a high enough density to get 2TB in a keychain form factor are going to be cost thousands. When they're advertising $40 or $50, it's likely a 64GB drive with a controller that fakes the available storage. Run some of those listings through FakeSpot and ReviewMeta to see how they do at identifying scams.
- holoduke 6y agoAnd you support the extortion of sellers who are suffering quite a bit. If everyone would use Amazon, the world soon would be enslaved by one single retailer offering the lowest wages on planet earth with zero to no respect for human rights.
- jareklupinski 6y agoThese days I DDG/google the product name I'm interested in and look for no-name forums on page 2/3 where people post at least a picture or two and an honest review. I'm 50/50 on affiliate links, but tend to trust them more if it links directly to the manufacturer's webstore.
- jiveturkey 6y agoI don't understand why folks (here) are so up in arms about this? It's well known. It's pretty easy to spot fake amazon reviews with very little effort, and buy accordingly. Also, no matter how tempted I only buy directly from amazon and never from their 3rd party sellers; just for easy returns. So on the off chance I get burned, the product goes right back. It's not that big a deal. It's not like I was going to independently find the best product on my own, without the help of amazon, without some trial and error. Maybe I'm too much of a sociopath. Allowing fake reviews is great. It vastly increases amazon's footprint, making sure that the things I buy are and remain easily returnable. Scammers gonna scam. Let them. It's also easy to spot incompetent users that leave 1 star reviews due to their misunderstanding of the product. Or 5 star reviews of blu ray before it's even released. That kind of thing. You know, you have to actually read the reviews ok? It's not too much to ask, honestly. You cannot police this kind of thing to any reasonable degree and maintain cost/performance ratio where it "needs" to be. Maybe it's a little too loose now, but any improvement is going to be modest plus it will breed better scammers. I really rue the death of flash. It was sooo easy to filter flash and ignore the drek. Now where are we? I don't consider these fake reviews to be a problem; indeed they are a benefit. Keep them easy to spot, please.
- hsnewman 6y agoI recently got spam that said that if I purchase a product for 1/2 the price (reduced via a link in the email), AND then I put a review of the product, they will give me a refund for the 1/2 price I paid. I reported this to Amazon, and Amazon replied that the email was not doing anything wrong. I didn't do this, since the commitment to pay back the 1/2 I paid was not guaranteed.
- xfz 6y agoYeah, Amazon reviews are pretty broken. Not sure if this helps much, but I try to avoid buying from marketplace sellers. This is partly to avoid my personal data being shared with yet another company (it's been misused by marketplace sellers in the past) but also in the theory (hope!) that Amazon themselves will on average buy better products. After all, they have their reputation to maintain and have to deal with all the refunds if they sell shoddy goods. Increasingly though, I'd rather just shop from a retailer that specialises in a particular type of product and has invested in their reputation.
- throwaway744678 6y agoI'm with you here. I only buy from Amazon itself, or, if looking for a specific item (eg. a known brand, or a product with 'offical' reviews found elsewhere), the manufacturer's. It probably reduces the risk of fake/knockoff/garbage products. I also feel (not sure about that, though) that the customer support would be better should there be any issue with the delivery or the product.
- yalogin 6y agoI have always wondered why "verified purchase" is a thing. That should be the default and only way to review. May be when they were little it was needed, but now they already know who is adding the review, they can easily check if the user bought that item in the last X months and only allow in that case. The rest of them can't add reviews, simple.
- ericabiz 6y agoAll of these would be "verified purchase" reviews. The scammy seller refunds you through PayPal after you post the review.
- testplzignore 6y agoI'm surprised the article does not mention tax evasion and money laundering. Those are surely bigger hammers than whatever would come from the FTC or GDPR.
- gorbachev 6y agoI ignore all positive reviews these days as a rule. Instead I check a few of the negative ones and see if there's a pattern that indicates some sort of systemic issue with the product.
- ziptron 6y ago"Fraudulent reviewers with thousands of fake reviews to their name can pay penalties of more than $10,000, and could even receive a jail sentence. " Is there actually a law in the US (or others) that suggests leaving fake reviews could subject you to a $10,000 fine and/or jail time? Asking for a friend.
- milofeynman 6y agoAs others have said before, going to Amazon and reading 1-2 star reviews is the best way to judge I have found.
- unloco 6y agoI don't find the fake reviews that important when I make a purchase. I know they are there. I know 95% of my Amazon search results are absolute trash. You get what you pay for. If you don't do your research, and think a $50 speaker from HWAROMA is going to be as good as a $250 Celestion because of reviews, that's kinda on you. Believe it or not, some people will want that deal because that $50 speaker might get them through a show in hard times. You do have to do research on everything you buy. User reviews are still a part of that research, just not nearly as much. If you google info on what you want, you KNOW at least the top 25 results are all paid for in one way or another, probably more than that now. Don't expect a corporation to watch your back. Amazon has made clear they give NO F's about the average human using their services, as long as they keep using it.
- welder 6y agoIt's common to receive a counterfeit brand-name product from Amazon, because anyone can fulfill a product by sending it to an Amazon warehouse. Lot's of counterfeits make it in. Netflix even has a docuseries about it[1]. Research doesn't help there, since you're getting a counterfeit instead of the quality product you researched. Yelp is even worse than Amazon, with reviews tied into their business model[2]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMPdsKvhCOo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMPdsKvhCOo (Netflix's Broken about Amazon counterfeits) [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tG-ULQrlx9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tG-ULQrlx9s (Yelp Billion Dollar Bully Trailer)
- achenatx 6y agoI use 5* ratings to get an idea of which products to look at, but I mainly look at 1-3* reviews to see if I want to buy it. I personally had a ton of amazon basics batteries leak in the packaging after 2 years of storage. I posted that review and amazon rejected it saying it didnt meet their community guidelines. That made me distrust the review process and now I generally wont buy amazon branded products. However if there are bad reviews that tell the same consistent story and that go into enough detail, then they are likely not competitor plants.
- nucleardog 6y ago> I use 5* ratings to get an idea of which products to look at, but I mainly look at 1-3* reviews to see if I want to buy it. Yep, exactly this. Who cares what people that were happy with it think, generally. Hearing a few use cases is helpful to decide if it's fit for what you're trying to do, but it's generally very useful information. If I buy this I don't care all the ways it will make trees greener and shiny things shinier, I want to know if I give them $100 what is the _worst_ experience I will get. Look at the negative reviews and see what kinds of issues people were having. Usually after skimming 5 or 10 you can get a pretty good feel for what kind of experience you are going to have. > "These headphones that say 'for iPhone' and clearly show a lightning connector don't work with my Android! They should really say they don't work with Android! Garbage!" > "I tried to use this blender to start my own 'will it blend' YouTube channel and when I put rocks in the blade got all chewed up and the company won't replace it! COMPANY DOESN'T STAND BEHIND THEIR PRODUCTS! AVOID!" > "These $0.50 pens aren't half as good as my co-worker's $80 pen. Why bother." > "Said it would get here Friday but it got here Monday, and UPS threw it over my fence and broke it!" > "Ordered this desk chair and parts were missing!" When the negative reviews are largely stuff like that (bought wrong thing, misuse of product, not understanding that cheap things are cheap for a reason, carrier issues), you know you can basically ignore them. The last one (product issues) kinda depends on whether there's a million of these, but generally if it's one or two and they don't say that they've tried to contact the company to resolve it I'm not too bothered. When you start seeing reviews that explain (1) an actual issue with the product; (2) attempts to contact the company and/or get a refund; and (3) a poor response from the company... that's when I get worried. A few like: > "Product arrived, of the ten included, only 4 worked. I contacted the seller and two weeks later they still haven't responded." > "Product is very cheaply made. The first one worked for a week then the foo broke. The seller sent me a replacement, but then that one broke 2 days later." And I start to look for something else.
- skeeter2020 6y agoHow do (relatively) smaller marketplaces avoid these problems? ex: steam allows reviews from people who got the product for free, and all the reviews tend to be far more trustworthy IMO, both in detail and aggregate. Is this because the economics of the market's products is different (plus easy to refund)?
- artful-hacker 6y agoAt least for me the best part of Steam reviews is that I can easily check reviews done by my friends / online gamer groups. By restricting the web of trust so a smaller batch of entities, I know I am avoiding most of the fraudsters.
- palae 6y agoA few years ago, I closed my Amazon account partly because I felt like the company was a net negative for society. And I haven't missed it, even in the past year. I guess it's kind of similar to social media in that respect, you feel less like a clicking/buying machine and it's pretty nice.
- ashleshbiradar 6y agoI once bought a product from Amazon India, the manufacturer had literally printed on the product, that if I give a 5 star review and send a screenshot on Whatsapp they'd give me X cashback. I outed them on amazon reviews, and amazon decided to not publish my review.
- lesinski 6y agoHere’s why Wirecutter can make an entire business out of credibly reviewing products
- deostroll 6y agoIt's not an Amazon-only issue. Many services, even Google playstore, is replete with this kind of _infestation_. There are many perspectives here. (1) One can hope to combat this with technology and processes. But the number of people consuming the service versus the actual number of people and systems employed to safe guard customer trust is quite high. (2) Understand the kingdom of humanity. There are always good/bad actors. The line that divides good/bad is also quite fickle. But we need more "good". We need to discuss this more.
- Rohpakle 6y agoI never read the positive reviews anymore. I mostly scan the negatives to see if there's any consistent issues. If they are only "shipping got damaged" or something clearly that the manufacturer warned against and the buyer still bought it..."this was too small or big" kind of thing (measure before you order, people)...I'm good to go.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI think it is easy to be cynical and easier still to say, "Just fix it, nerd," but trying to detect collusion between two parties when you do not control their communications is quite difficult, especially when their associations will be only fleeting. For example, you could disallow changes in star ratings, but that would also prevent people from rating something only to change their minds when it broke three months later and you've lost useful information that way. You could make sure all communication goes through Amazon, but that only counts for email. The seller has your physical address and therefore can offer you gift cards to change your mind, via a postal offer. You could hide the names of reviewers, but then you risk losing the trust metagame where there are reviewers people trust. You could allow only the verified purchaser of a product to comment, and only once, and that makes "review bombing" of competitors expensive but not impossible. I imagine you would need a good outline of all types of different "fakes" (I am sure multiple sorts exist) and scams, then find the nastiest game theorists available and discuss what could and could not be done. The more I think about this, the more Amazon Marketplace morphs into Amazon Escrow.
- dcdc123 6y agoI bought something on Amazon for $20, the seller then sent me a post card offering a $25 Amazon gift card for providing proof of a 5-star review.
- jwally 6y agoDumb question: if you un-tethered reviews to user profiles (or removed user profiles all together), wouldn't this problem go away, or fall drastically? If amazon could give me the scores from verified-purchasers, show me anonymized comments from verified-purchasers; I think I'd be ok.
- CWuestefeld 6y agoThis has become a serious problem on IMDB as well. It's common, almost the norm for small releases, to have a flurry of reviews right at release giving ratings of 8 or 10 out of 10. They'll have glowing comments about how the director made such effective use of a shoestring budget, and so on. And then a little later this gets followed by a string of 1- or 2- out of 10 reviews, saying it's one of the worst movies ever and the high reviews are obviously shills. For larger movies, or over a large enough timespan, the noise eventually gets drowned. But it's made IMDB reviews useless for deciding whether to watch new movies.
- ergot_vacation 6y agoReminds me of the nightmare that descended on Steam when they opened up Greenlight to nearly everyone. Great in theory, but in short order the service was drowning in low effort garbage, asset flips and downright scams. Eventually they had to up the barrier of entry a little again just to get some sanity back. Or just look at the wasteland that is the Play Store on Android. Any marketplace that's globally accessible needs to have curation and a high barrier of entry, or it will be spammed to death by these people. Of course, Amazon has no motivation to fix this, being a monopoly. They get paid either way.
- 1cvmask 6y agoThe main issue is that all ratings systems are essentially mathematical garbage, with voting incentives heavily skewed by actors who want to sell or disparage a competitor. The masses are the collateral damage. But even in an honest "fair" voting schema how does my neighbor harbor the same sort of values and beliefs in a product as I do. Just like opinions, ratings are inherently subjective and relative to one's own value systems. Some prefer cheap, quick and dirty solutions whilst others prefer durable and long-term solutions.
- cooldevguy 6y agoI love Amazon as much as the next guy but I do think they are doing something....just the other day I got one of those "free 5G" phones from T-Mobile and thought about getting a case for it...well I got a $5 case on Amazon and when the item arrived it had the nice little card about "leave a 5 star review; we mail you a $5 Amazon Gift Card"...well cheap ass me tried to provide my review (I had already installed the case) but the site did not allow me to submit a review for the first 2 days after I received it...so I guess this is some sort of deterrent right? It did the trick for me, I'm happy with the case but I haven't bothered to try to submit a review again
- marmot777 6y agoUgh. Yet I’m totally influenced by Amazon reviews. I’ll choose one item over another based on the number of stars and how good the reviews are. What can be done to stop it? Maybe ONLY confirmed purchasers can review at all could help?
- Rudisimo 6y ago> These Amazon vendors send to reviewers a list of items/products for which they would like a 5-star review. The people providing the ‘fake reviews’ will then buy the products, leaving a 5-star review on Amazon a few days after receiving their merchandise. > Once the Amazon vendor confirms all reviews have been completed, the reviewer will receive a refund through PayPal, keeping the items they bought for free as a form of payment. They are all confirmed...
- smsm42 6y agoThey mention there online tools that allow to spot fake reviews. Anybody knows which ones they mean? E.g. as a browser extension?