5 ms·
Apparently it depends on the climate. In Singapore, you need to maintain the surface of the concrete to keep water out or the rebar corrodes and the concrete s
by refurb 6y ago
Apparently it depends on the climate. In Singapore, you need to maintain the surface of the concrete to keep water out or the rebar corrodes and the concrete spalls.
Buildings only last 50 years or so before being torn down and rebuilt.
https://www.mynicehome.gov.sg/article/dealing-with-spalling-concrete-in-your-flat https://www.mynicehome.gov.sg/article/dealing-with-spalling-...
- marcosdumay 6y agoIt doesn't depend on the climate, but it does depend on the concrete chemistry (that does vary geographically). Anyway, the sequence is that micro cracks form on the concrete and expose the steel, then the exposed steel rusts and pushes more concrete away, exposing more steel. This too can be fixed before it becomes a problem.
- bilbo0s 6y agoI think the material point is that, as engineers, we have to all concede that modern concrete has that fatal flaw. People are being hyperbolic here when they are saying these buildings won't last 60 years. In my opinion, most will definitely last 60 years, even with no maintenance. At the same time, I'm intellectually honest enough to concede that few reinforced concrete structures will last 500 years with no maintenance. And I'm confident that zero reinforced structures will last 1000 without maintenance. People on this thread claiming a collapse in 60 years are probably not civil engineers. People claiming that reinforced structures will outlast the Pyramids at Giza are definitely not civil engineers.
- marcosdumay 6y agoOh, agreed. Concrete itself is not a completely stable chemical compost. Modern civilization is not creating many structures that have a chance of surviving for centuries. What I don't agree is on the classification of that as a "fatal flaw". Looks like we are in serious disagreement on the goal of our constructions.
- bilbo0s 6y agoCorrect. It's not a fatal flaw in terms of building a perfectly serviceable structure. It's a fatal flaw in terms of building a structure that lasts the ages like the pyramids. Like all engineering problems, the solution is greatly dependent on your goals.
- iggldiggl 6y agoCarbonation is another factor – fresh concrete is contains calcium hydroxide and is therefore an alkaline environment, which has the effect of protecting the rebar from corroding. Over time however, carbon dioxide from the atmosphere slowly seeps into the concrete (anything that's only intermittently wet fares the worst here), turning the calcium hydroxide into calcium carbonate. While this has the beneficial side effect of actually increasing the strength of the concrete itself, it also lowers its pH value, which means the rebar is no longer protected against corrosion once the carbonation process reaches the rebar.