3 ms·
Is Porn Becoming a Monopoly?
- coldtea 6y agoIt's getting close to a monopsoli
- cratermoon 6y agoDid you mean "monopsony"?
- YuriNiyazov 6y agoHow can you have an article like this without a single mention of OnlyFans?
- nexuist 6y agoProbably because it disproves the headline, given that all of these people getting kicked off of SFW sites have a popular sanctuary where they can continue making money doing the things they want. A true monopoly has no sanctuaries.
- cratermoon 6y agoHow long before cloud and hosting providers kick sites like OnlyFans off for fear of legal liability? Especially if things like SESTA become law, they'll lose whatever common-carrier protections they may have.
- nexuist 6y agoOF uses a Canadian payment processor because American card providers don't allow a site like OF in their terms of service, so there's that. However I don't think any cloud provider has taken any moral stance on the content they host other than the bare minimum legal requirements. AWS dropped Parler because it promoted an actual riot/insurrection in real life. AWS continues to host pretty much anything else so long as you keep paying them. Hell, even if you stop paying them, they'll let you freeload for months before they actually decide to close your account. Getting kicked off is a pretty low risk ATM.
- cratermoon 6y ago> However I don't think any cloud provider has taken any moral stance on the content they host other than the bare minimum legal requirements So what happens if a law like FOSTA-SESTA comes along and threatens legal penalties for cloud providers like AWS who knowingly host porn? Wouldn't that change "the bare minimum legal requirements"? And then later, the US, Canada, EU, and other countries sign a treaty to regularize "sex trafficking" laws and Canadian payment processors drop OF and similar? Yes, of course some of them will go further offshore, into the fringes of the internet, to find hosting, but it will still hurt them, just like the way torrent sites have been hurt by similar moves? https://torrentfreak.com/googles-new-downranking-hits-pirate-sites-hard-141023/ https://torrentfreak.com/googles-new-downranking-hits-pirate...
- nexuist 6y agoIt's a what-if just like everything else. Congress could ban computers tomorrow too and we'd all be out of a job. So far they haven't and there isn't a real risk of them doing so. Even SESTA doesn't ban hosting outright, it just complicates payment for content. A treaty like you're talking about doesn't appear to be on the table, at least not soon, and probably won't be given that other countries are much more sex-positive than the US is (prostitution is legal in many places in Europe, for example).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toomuchredbull 6y agoAlso cryptocurrencies/telegram/signal/ya hell instagram/twitter/tiktok... seems like thousands of tiktokers also have an onlyfans..
- cwkoss 6y agoNope
- Pako 6y agoSerious question: > This is an issue bigger than Patreon (In the climate of FOSTA/SESTA) It probably goes beyond even the payment processors. it’s a world wide, online AND in person crack down on freedom of expression, on women, on marginalised people, on sex and sex work, on non conventional forms of labour that counter the status quo: the domination of corporations and the patriarchy. On dissent. (Taken from the blog post mentioned because it provides a bit more context than the quote on the linked site; emphasis not mine) How is this a crackdown on either women or freedom of expression? Isn't every sex worker equally affected? Not like Patreon still shows penises on their platform. Neither is any company forced to allow arbitrary personal expression on their platform if I understood it correctly. Freedom of expression only protects you from the government, like freedom of speech, no? If anyone intends to respond to this comment please consider that I'm genuinely asking this. I really want to understand.
- unanswered 6y ago> Freedom of expression only protects you from the government, like freedom of speech, no? No. In the US, the first amendment to the US Constitution only applies to the government. "Freedom of speech" is a concept with general applicability. People opposed to freedom of speech often intentionally conflate the two but they really are separate things. There may be a genuine argument about what any particular actor should do w/r/t speech - should they adopt a permissive, "freedom of speech" attitude, should they restrict speech, etc. But "freedom of speech only applies to the government" is not a genuine argument, because it's not an argument at all, it's a conclusory statement (and false).