9 ms·
Talk cancelled due to slides critical of Google and Facebook
- agravier 6y agoToo bad that he won't tell what talk that was, it's useful info for other participants.
- pmoriarty 6y agoHere's the same thread on nitter, an alternative to twitter that does not require Javascript to read: https://nitter.eu/randfish/status/1389279726305353730 https://nitter.eu/randfish/status/1389279726305353730 Other nitter instances can be found here: https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances
- caddemon 6y agoI'm a little confused on the reason this talk was cancelled. It seems that nearly the entire talk is critical of Facebook/Google, but the organizer only complains about a handful of slides. It looks like they were fine with claims of FB/G stealing content, purposefully optimizing for addiction, etc. and it was just the "political misinformation" portion that caused offense. Is the organizer defensive of big tech, or do they have some other political agenda that was somehow threatened by his point (or the specific examples given in support)?
- tyingq 6y agoTwitter is a little hard to follow a thread in, so here's a link to the 5 slides they asked him to pull: https://imgur.com/a/k0naEwT https://imgur.com/a/k0naEwT
- bmarquez 6y agoIn the first slide, there's a screenshot of the Facebook app showing a picture of a sign referencing pedophilia. I'd probably be uncomfortable with that and ask to replace those examples with a screenshot from a news website, if I was in the organizer's shoes. Don't see a problem with the other slides though.
- nmfisher 6y agoI have no clue why an organizer would try and edit (censor?) a speaker's presentation. They were invited for a reason, let them talk! The audience is perfectly capable of coming up with their own conclusion about whether the speaker's points are valid. And if you think they're brazenly lying, then just uninvite them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jhanschoo 6y agoBecause, as is the case here, you are inviting person A to speak about topic B, because your audience thinks they may have something interesting to say about topic B, and not because they want to hear about person A's thoughts on topic C.
- pas 6y agoAsk the speakers to submit an abstract beforehand, during call for speakers phase. And pick those which you like. Not after the talk has been confirmed. This editorializing is the equivalent of oppressive regimes inviting a famous band but asking them not to play their "controversial" songs, and the banning them with the obligatory surprised pikachu face when they do. It's not government censorship but it's the chilling effect of G & FB having too much control already. (Or if the problem was that the organizer found those claims unsubstantiated, they should have cancelled the talk, or could have simply put up a big warning before and after the talk saying that this is the speaker's opinion, not necessarily 100% shared by the organizers ...)
- eatbitseveryday 6y agoI do not understand why Twitter is the medium for which to share dense information. The UI is not meant for it. Post a URL to a PDF of the slides, instead?
- cookguyruffles 6y agoEach slide is narrated with an option to like it or start a unique conversation or share that single slide to people who are interested in what you think is interesting. Each slide also gets its own analytics so he can see how well they individually perform (after all, he's in advertising). The medium is more than fine for what he's posting, it's an important message and Twitter is for better or worse how many important messages get around these days.
- vishnugupta 6y agoMy hypothesis is that Twitter trained their users into having short bursts of attentive focus immediately following by amplifying and expressing their impulsive reaction, through retweets/likes/replies. I doubt the vast majority of Twitter users will leave the current context of series of dopamine hits to consume a long form dense content. Content creators don’t have a choice but to modify their content to Twitter’s form factor or risk losing their audience.
- kgin 6y agoIt's true, but every click loses a ton of audience.
- dang 6y agoI understand the annoyance but please let's not repeat this in every twitterthread. People choose how they post for whatever reason. It's the content that matters. There's a site guideline about this: "Please don't complain about website formatting, back-button breakage, and similar annoyances. They're too common to be interesting. Exception: when the author is present. Then friendly feedback might be helpful." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- agogdog 6y agoIs it unethical to disclose who was hosting the talk?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoBy attempting to censor the content... 1) they just made it more popular, 2) it makes them look as it they are admitting it's true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lbacaj 6y agoI know a lot of people make their money on here from these companies. Heck, I interviewed at one of them twice. But my gut says these two are no longer good companies to work for. If you need the money desperately then do what you need to do, but if you can afford to take a role somewhere else you should. Anywhere else is better than these two right now. I also recognize that they didn’t start the way they are now. Back when they started they represented the very best of our industry and they lured in young ambitious people with the promise of changing the world for the better. They did do that for a little while. The engineering capabilities were and still are world class, they are beacons our industry for that. But unfortunately a lot has changed. They are absolutely monopolies now, everything in those slides is true. I know because I worked at a startup that relied on both of those companies for its growth. They abused us in the beginning, threatened us with bans and gave us strikes for arbitrary reasons, and then treated us like gold as we spent a lot more with them. On top of how they treat “partners” they now do far more damage to the fabric of society than they add value to it. Again, I recognize that at some point it wasn’t that way and without them tech wouldn’t be what it is now, but they are no longer that and we should all see it for what it is. I don’t have a solution on how to fix this. I think it’s the business model that’s acidic and broken. I think only disruption can fix this but it’s unclear when and if that will come.
- lostmsu 6y agoI am sorry, but at what time Google or Facebook were not ad machines?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Clewza313 6y agoThey've always been ad machines, but once upon a time Google was the good guy of the ad world. Even regular sites used to be full of punch the monkey ads, popups and pop-unders. Google with its dainty little text-only ads neatly on the side of search results was a real breath of fresh air, and we all cheered when Chrome came along and started blocking many of the most annoying ad tactics.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYou do wonder - what does the code of conduct have to say about this?
- briffid 6y agoI hope the code of conduct advances free exchange of views and opinions. I even don't understand how an audience can be uncomfortable hearing an opinion, listening to arguments? They don't have to act or agree. Otherwise if they only hear comfortable and reassuring things: how could they grow, change and advance their knowledge?
- throwaway3699 6y agoThe whole point of code of conducts is to create psychological safety, but you're right that people need to hear uncomfortable things to grow. This is precisely why CoC are a bad idea - it stifles exchange of knowledge.
- pembrook 6y ago...and the Streisand effect strikes again. Everything Rand was going to present is true. If you're building your marketing efforts around the benevolent algorithmic dictators of Google and Facebook...you're not really building a business. You're sharecropping and building a house of cards. One algorithm change from the overlords and your business dries up overnight. The fact that organizers are self-censoring their talks to avoid offending Google and Facebook is evidence alone that these companies have way too much power. My favorite part is where he points out the massive mistake of everybody who drove their customers to a Facebook page and told them to "like" it. Facebook then disinter-mediated these customer relationships and cut business page reach to near zero (0.09% as he shows in one of the slides). These businesses ended up growing Facebook's business more than their own.
- colinmhayes 6y agoWell wherever he's presenting at doesn't care that the presentation is critical of google/facebook, they care about google/facebook might react. As long as he doesn't reveal their identity they don't care about the streisand effect.
- pas 6y agoIf this was a confirmed talk maybe it was already announced. Eventually that can be tracked down. Sure, does not have the same effect.
- kmeisthax 6y agoI agree with 99% of what this guy is saying but I'd like to know why he thinks GDPR was a huge win for Google and Facebook. As far as I'm aware, GDPR legally restricts when sites can collect and store your information. Is the argument that we need to let everyone spy on you so they can compete on who can sell your information to advertisers? Like, no, that's really wrong. We need to be legally boxing in the advertising industry as much as possible. If that means Google and Facebook have the accidental advantage of being the only companies with enough of a relationship to their customers to continue selling ad profiles, then so be it.
- hoseja 6y agoRegulatory capture. Google and Facebook can afford the administrative load to fully comply with the letter of the law, without being hindered, while smaller entities are meaningfully affected.
- raverbashing 6y agoYeah at the same time there's an easy way of complying with the GDPR: don't gather data you don't need. But instead people prefer to use a non-compliant and obtrusive "we care about your privacy" popup while complaining about the fines. (also remember GDPR is not only about FB or Google)
- bastawhiz 6y agoThey really can just throw money at the problem to solve it, which otherwise hamstrings their competition. If you can plop a billion dollars down to move data to the right country, have lawyers to check your lawyers checking your lawyers, and can afford penalties when you trip up, you're already at an advantage over most of your competition—probably without having to sacrifice much in the process.
- pas 6y agoGoogle now has a really big and obnoxious popup modal. That's a clear disadvantage for them. Is it enough to dethrone them? Well not right now, but it's at least a sign of an opportunity. If DDG can do similar results without the popup then hopefully people will migrate there. (Of course G Search is brutally entrenched in a myriad ways, connected services, Android, Chrome, all the other browser defaults, etc.)
- fallingknife 6y agoThe title is misleading. The whole presentation is critical of Google and FB. The conference was fine with the slides that criticized them for the way they do business with their partners. They asked for the removal of the slides that go into wider politics, like trying to blame FB/Google for political extremism and income inequality. Totally reasonable decision IMO.
- jart 6y agoNah dude. Most of his criticisms, most Googlers would probably agree with him. It was probably because he called Google "unreliable". That's one of the few words that will actually hurt the monster. It's also not true. It's sort of like shouting "The Golden Gate Bridge is falling down!" on the radio.
- pas 6y agoHow is it not true? They will terminate your account (like Amazon drops sellers), without any warning, and that's it. There are stories about this right here on HN almost each day. (Yes this naturally only affects a small number of their accounts, but it's not negligible, and it's the exact opposite of a well managed and understood risk which would be needed for reliability.)
- lrvick 6y agoDid we forget the countless services Facebook and Google have dramatically altered or killed over the years that can never be forked or restarted elsewhere because they are proprietary? The only services we should assume are reliable are the ones that directly generate profits. I expect neither company will shut down their ad selling systems but everything else I would not consider reliable.
- fallingknife 6y agoThey asked him to remove specific slides. The ones that called Google unreliable were approved.
- killjoywashere 6y agoIn other news, railroads use your cargo as leverage to get you addicted to product delivery. They in fact use it in a variety of ways for and against you and other railroads and the government. This pattern is true of pretty much every industry that carries freight, whether coal, llama socks, or information. It's true in capitalist, socialist, communist, and fascist societies.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoI'm having trouble understanding this. Organizer of what? What sort of thing is there that they look over the slides beforehand? I've given talks to industry, and at industry conferences, and nobody has ever looked over my slides for content. Is my experience atypical? Maybe it is.
- yarcob 6y agoI think the number one thing people should understand is that it's really important to own the relationship with your audience. Tech companies like Google and Facebook want you to pay for reaching your audience. This sounds like a good deal when it allows you to reach more people. Ads are great! Expand your business! With Google and Facebook you just pay a little and get more customers! It sounds like a win/win situation! Except that tech companies found it would be even more profitable to make you pay for reaching your existing audience! Finding new customers is a really hard problem, so they'll just sell access to your existing customers! So they trick businesses into sharing their customer data with them, by offering analytics or other free services. Once the tech company knows who your customers are, they can charge you to reach them! You can pay to reach the people in your Facebook groups or buy retargeting ads to reach people who visited your online shop. You don't get new customers, you just pay to reach people who you thought you already had a relationship with -- except that relationship is controlled by someone else. And if you don't pay, well they'll just show your competitors ads! If you built up a reputation with hard work by providing a great service, you can now start a bidding war with your competitors to reach your own customers! Long live big brother!
- berkes 6y ago> And if you don't pay, well they'll just show your competitors ads! That implies they do sell 'access to new customers'. Not that it makes their businessmodel any better, but this counters your own arguments, it seems.
- yarcob 6y agoOf course they also sell access to new customers. I'm not saying they don't. But they also sell access to your existing customers, both to you and your competitors. That's what companies don't understand, and I'm sure marketers would be a bit more careful with the data they share with tech companies if they understood that.
- aembleton 6y agoCan't you email your customers?
- jarek83 6y agoIt's a beautiful sign that these companies are becoming very powerful entities. We got used to existence of superpowers or dictatorships in the shape of a very strong or narrow-minded country governments. Now large companies prove to have similar influence to a likewise governments. We are used to watch out for monopolies, but those companies created something even more evil without being scrutinised - some kind of omnipoly, where they have power over many aspects of life by owning small-ish companies from different domains. They created a bubble where only their truth is true, and only their business is only allowed business. What they just did with these slides? They had power to censor them. Who else has power to censor stuff? Superpowers and dictators. Similarities are starting show. Are we already past that point where we could control these companies with law, policies and rules? They are so big and powerful, because we missed what they were doing. They were slowly and patiently building their power. Now they can tell governments what to do. Now there are governments in the world that seemingly have less resources than them to make them accountable. Did they bought us all already? How much is left outside of their control or at least their knowledge? I hope this is and will always be a scary fantasy. Otherwise we're going to experience some new and miserable developments in the near future.
- mr_woozy 6y agoWhat was first clue Google went bad? When they couldn't even maintain a motto of "Don't be Evil" That should have been everyone's red flag right there.