5 ms·
> there is no practical way to “tax and redistribute” sex. But there is a way to improve supply: give dignity to prostitution.
by toyg 6y ago
> there is no practical way to “tax and redistribute” sex.
But there is a way to improve supply: give dignity to prostitution.
- hn8788 6y agoThat doesn't work out as well as it sounds. Unsuprisingly, the amount of women willing to have sex with strangers for money is relatively low. Studies have shown that legalizing prostitution increases the rate of human trafficking to meet the greater demand. https://orgs.law.harvard.edu/lids/2014/06/12/does-legalized-prostitution-increase-human-trafficking/ https://orgs.law.harvard.edu/lids/2014/06/12/does-legalized-...
- toyg 6y agoThat's a function of massive income inequality across countries, though. Fix that, and the incentive for trafficking disappears.
- tengbretson 6y agoLet's start with the assumption that we will have to solve this problem while under the constraints of actual reality.
- toyg 6y agoAre you saying that massive economic inequality is a-OK...? These are all big problems we ain't gonna fix in 5 years or 10.
- cjaybo 6y agoIt's clear that they were pointing out exactly what you're getting at in your second sentence: any solution that that depends on solving global income inequality is practically impossible over any reasonable timeline, and therefore not worth much discussion.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoBut fixing income inequality would presumably reduce the number of women willing to sell sex, so you're back to square 1.
- toyg 6y agoThat also depends on other factors. When being a prostitute means being a criminal, obviously it's not desirable.
- johnnyanmac 6y agoFixing income inequality creates more opportunities to perform activities, which leads to more socialization leading to more potential romantic encounters. Hard to think about a spouse when you're making $8/hr but spending 33% of your life behind a counter. I also wager a portion of the people who feel they "need but can't get sex" may also learn that what they desired wasn't what they actually cared that much about. In this regard, I guess one can argue that prostitution is a crutch to a much larger problem that may never truly be solved.
- spoonjim 6y agoDo you think lower income people have less sex?
- johnnyanmac 6y agoIn the grand scheme of the world definition of lower income, no. I haven't looked too deeply into it, but apparently 3rd world countries have as much or more sex, but have less access to birth control. In the context of "first world lower income", I'd wager there's a loose correlation. i.e the incel movement is one mostly formed from a frustrated lower-middle/middle class (which in the world context, means many americans for the sake of discussion). Another comment in this post heard something similar as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27041400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27041400 I'd be interested in any studies that disprove this notion. I'll admit most of this comment is conjecture.
- waterhouse 6y agoI don't think it's income inequality. It's legality-of-prostitution inequality. That is, the traffickers decided to move their operations from countries where prostitution was illegal to countries where it's legal, because, all else being equal, it's easier to operate in the latter. The link doesn't claim that the total amount of trafficking increased, and the quoted results don't favor the "net increase" hypothesis over the "movement" hypothesis.
- phkahler 6y ago>> But there is a way to improve supply: give dignity to prostitution. Better yet, guys need to learn to be the kind of man women want to fvck. They're not obligated and attraction is non-negotiable. Reality can be harsh. Guys need to treat themselves with dignity and put themselves together.
- ngngngng 6y agoI think this is a good thought. My own religion gave me some direction for how to become to type of man women want, but it did leave something to be desired. And then upon searching for this sort of direction later in life while trying to improve my own relationships I stumbled upon the "red pill" communities. There's a lot of nuance to these communities as well. They tell men that you can become the type of man that women want, and they give you a roadmap to do so (work on your personality, lift weights, take care of yourself, take care of your life) but unfortunately these communities also come with some ideas that range from strange to downright misogynistic. I think there's room for some down to earth, responsible men to try and fill this space. Right now the "teach young men how to be" space is mostly filled with misogyny and terrible pick up artists.
- JohnBooty 6y agoI think there's room for some down to earth, responsible men to try and fill this space. Right now the "teach young men how to be" space is mostly filled with misogyny and terrible pick up artists. Goodness yes. The PUA and red pill communities have absolutely poisoned this space and, at least in America, it's impossible to see how a healthy alternative could even take root. I know that if one sprang up, my first reaction would be to lump it in with the toxic crap and never give it a second look. It's a shame because there is absolutely a need for this.
- johnnyanmac 6y agogoes back to the author's statements: >there’s a vast difference between a person who believes the stated beliefs of a group as opposed to a person who holds membership in a group as a defining part of their identity. Imagining a conversation with someone who generically believes women should be treated well is a much different experience than imagining the same conversation with person who boldly declares themselves a feminist; the same is true for what you’d expect from a talk with an MRA. Always seems to come down to good intentions, bad actors that make such "identities" dangerous. Even if it's an otherwise honest person that just wants some self-help advice.
- robocat 6y agoPhysical sex is not intimacy. Sex work leads to some very strange dynamics, because often the Johns are desperate for intimacy, but they are paying for women that provide zero actual intimacy (because it is usually entirely faked.) I am sure there is some ideal world where prostitution could satisfy emotional needs, but in my admittedly very limited knowledge it doesn't. Prostitution has been legal in my country since 2003, however it is still stigmatised for both men and women (at least for my demographic, and I haven't noticed any difference for other demographics.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mettamage 6y agoThis. I sometimes walk by the red light district. One time I seriously considered having sex with a sex worker. I talked to multiple of them to find a click and I was appalled by all my interaction. I realized that I wanted intimacy leading into sex. What they offered: strictly penetrative sex and nothing else. As I got older, another issue arose: to what extent is intimacy actual intimacy when you are paying for it? Intimacy implies someone caring about you and you caring about him/her. That suddenly means it has an ethical component of idealism attached to it. For me anyways.
- throwaway1282 6y agoI've made the plunge and become a "John" a few times now, always in other countries where sex work is either legal or tolerated/quasi-legal. I must say the experience varied a lot. About half were mechanical and just felt like they were trying to get my money. That feels pretty hollow. But I've also had some really great experiences where I felt like we had a genuine connection. I grant that this is not "real" intimacy in the sense of "they care for you", but it did feel something like chemistry or attraction. And finally I have not tried this but have read enough anecdotes suggesting that you can get intimacy while paying in good sugar daddy-sugar babe relationships. That won't be cheap though.
- 6y ago
- troway357924 6y agoThe movie Her is prophetic. The way to improve supply is with sex robots.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThis will not provide for the psychological need to be valued and wanted by another human being.
- Viliam1234 6y agoSolving half of the problem is still better than solving nothing.