8 ms·
As the article points out, weak antitrust enforcement has allowed companies to become monopolies, or near-monopolies. It's not just "tech". Look at banking. The
by Animats 6y ago
As the article points out, weak antitrust enforcement has allowed companies to become monopolies, or near-monopolies. It's not just "tech". Look at banking. The US is down to four big banks. Until 1995, US banks couldn't operate in more than one state.
Right after deregulation, there are new entrants. Twenty years later, there are a very few giant companies. See telecom, airlines, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- adrianb 6y agoAnd the ones you mentioned have major regulatory hurdles to expand internationally. In industries where a single player can dominate multiple markets we are down to 2-3 major competitors, worldwide. See airplane or train manufacturers, beer companies, computer chips... This has all been financed by more than a decade of low interest rates which fuelled the M&A.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoLow interest rates have helped, but I feel like it's primarily the relaxation of regulations that fueled things. We had really low interest rates for a decade or two after WWII, but I don't think we saw the same rate of business consolidation.
- Accujack 6y ago"Relaxation" of regulations has been sliding downhill since about the 50s, but it reached a fever pitch during the Reagan presidency. The "new conservatives" and religious fundamentalists found they had a president they could control who was slowly forgetting everything he knew, and they used that to the fullest advantage. Much of where we are today is due to the processes that began then, from (lack of) fairness in news reporting to the permissive corporate laws that allowed private equity and corporate raiding to relaxation of banking and securities laws that allowed 2008 to happen. There have been some ups and downs between the 80s and today, and a few Democratic years, but in general the slide has continued because once money gets into politics, it won't leave quietly... it has to be forced out.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think it is entirely the opposite. It is all about regulatory capture. You put in place firm regulations that only the largest multinationals can comply with, and in most cases have written themselves to set the bar high and exclude competition
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoThat's a good point. It's probably some optimal combination of the two. Firm regulations to make it harder for small companies to succeed and rolling back regulations that protect the consumer so companies can improve profit margins.
- fwsgonzo 6y agoIt's my biggest gripe with current society. It's everywhere, and it's not going away. Nobody is tackling it, or talking about it seriously. At some point I thought that companies would become more powerful than states, but I've changed my mind on that. Nations do retaliate hard if they feel threatened. Maybe I've just turned naive again. But when it comes to monopolies I just don't see them ever going away now. Too much globalization combined with lobbying power and corporate veils. People talk about companies and never about the people who make the decisions, and I feel like people have trouble with accepting that in the end nobody actually wants to be in a society where companies can do whatever they want and end up being a negative contributor to society.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> But when it comes to monopolies I just don't see them ever going away now. Too much globalization combined with lobbying power and corporate veils. We’ve been here before though, in the era of Standard Oil. They can be broken up, but it won’t just happen on its own. The government needs to take action.
- briantakita 6y ago> The government needs to take action. The government is taking action. The government is in on this consolidation via investments, contracts, preferential legal & tax treatment, etc. Think about this from the government's perspective. The government would rather govern a small number of large entities instead of a large number of small entities, thus the government is incentivized to favor monopolies/oliogopolies. The government itself is a monopoly of power in many domains. Sure, the government may intervene with a company getting too big, but the intervention is so the government can gain a foothold with that company. e.g. any telecommunications platform will need to have back doors for the law enforcement agencies or said telecommunications platform will not be allowed to operate.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Think about this from the government's perspective. The government would rather govern a small number of large entities instead of a large number of small entities, thus the government is incentivized to favor monopolies/oliogopolies. According to what incentives? The government’s responsibility is to the country at large.
- jean_tta 6y agoSee "The Great Reversal: How America Gave Up on Free Markets", by Thomas Philippon [0] [0] https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674237544 https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674237544
- briantakita 6y agoMany people erroneously equate Capitalism with Free Markets.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoNo, many people incorrectly equate a monopolistic, pay-to-play, regulation-captured plutocracy with capitalism. Fundamentally, capitalism is about handling economic planning in an efficient way by free-market autoregulation and policy makers who nurture competition to ensure that process continues to happen efficiently.
- jean_tta 6y agoYour definition seems closer to ordoliberalism [0]. If competition and free markets are a necessary components of capitalism, then you would conclude - for instance - that the US stopped being a capitalistic country in the late XIXth century with so many prominent trusts. Or perhaps it never was capitalistic before WWII, since policy makers did not nurture competition but rather attempted to shield local industries from foreign competitions. [0] Wikipedia definition: Ordoliberalism is the German variant of economic liberalism that emphasizes the need for the state to ensure that the free market produces results close to its theoretical potential
- Enginerrrd 6y agoI was all set to say I disagree with the comparison to ordoliberalism pretty strongly with the following statement: There is a key difference about how often I think, from the perspective of a government official or regulatory body, the best policy would be to do nothing. Then I found myself in significant agreement with the following paragraph from the Wikipedia article: >Ordoliberal theory holds that the state must create a proper legal environment for the economy and maintain a healthy level of competition through measures that adhere to market principles. This is the foundation of its legitimacy.[9] The concern is that, if the state does not take active measures to foster competition, firms with monopoly (or oligopoly) power will emerge, which will not only subvert the advantages offered by the market economy, but also possibly undermine good government, since strong economic power can be transformed into political power. However, I still hold some skepticism about this concept, since it often seems like, at least in the US, that government interventions are what serve to dissuade competition. Either way, thank you for your input. I find it very interesting, especially because I've often admired the Germans' modern economic management which seems largely based on ordoliberalism.
- rustybelt 6y agoThis has had a big impact on the economies of regional mid-sized metros as jobs consolidated in coastal megacities. Arguably, this resulted in a lower quality of life in both classes of cities. Good Atlantic article on the subject: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/04/how-americas-coastal-cities-left-the-heartland-behind/478296/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/04/how-ame...
- BlueTemplar 6y agoAnd it's not like this hasn't been predicted by the cyberpunk genre... in the 1980's ?
- snarf21 6y agoExactly correct. The FTC and SEC have failed us completely in the 21st century. Things have gone bad ever since the focus of all companies has been shareholders above all else.
- coachtrotz 6y ago"Until 1995, US banks couldn't operate in more than one state" Can you clarify what you mean? The National Bank Act was originally written in 1863.
- Animats 6y agoSee this 1994 article from the St. Louis Fed, "Going Interstate: A New Dawn For U.S. Banking"[1] And then in 1999, even more deregulation.[2] [1] https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/regional-economist/july-1994/going-interstate-a-new-dawn-for-us-banking https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/regional-economist/j... [2] https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/1999/11/bank-n01.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/1999/11/bank-n01.html
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> See telecom, airlines, etc. Don't forget media companies. Everybody forgets media companies because media companies that have no qualms writing articles condemning mergers by Bank of America have a different incentive when it comes time to look in the mirror.
- codegeek 6y agoyes it is def. not tech only. telecom, banking, airlines are great examples as well. One recent example. My phone company Sprint got acquired by T-Mobile. Btw, Sprint used to be Spring PCS many years ago which I think was a merger b/w Sprint and PCS. Consolidation/mergers are endless.
- will4274 6y ago> Until 1995, US banks couldn't operate in more than one state. I can't think of a worse example of regulation. People obviously want to be able to access their money when they travel 30 minutes away. Your example undermines your point.
- mulmen 6y agoHuh? My money stays in my bank. If I want to spend it in another state that's what Visa and MasterCard enable, or I can carry cash, or directly transfer to another bank account in another bank across state lines. My bank can do business with any number of companies offering the ability to spend money nationally such as Visa, MasterCard, PayPal, Venmo, Zelle, Coinbase, etc. Separating these concerns is good for consumers because it encourages competition and innovation and banks themselves are incentivized to offer access to new capabilities instead of preserving the status quo because they profit from owning the means of spending money.
- will4274 6y agoYes, and everybody attends college in state. Look, I understand most hacker news readers do banking online, but the notion that banks are limited to a single state requires either that people rarely go out of state or never need to go to a physical branch. Neither is true in 2021. The former (not traveling) is more common than the later (not needing to go to a physical branch). You seem to be proposing purely online banking. I take it you don't own a home or a car or a business? Most loans still require an in person meeting.
- freeone3000 6y agoI was approved for a $550,000 mortgage over the phone, during COVID times. They verified my identity documents electronically, verified that the place I was buying existed using the digital property registry, had their appraiser go out, charged me for the appraisal, and placed the money in escrow with my notary. If they can do this during a pandemic, why can't they do it all the time?
- 6y ago
- throw123123123 6y agoI would not call banking unregulated.
- walshemj 6y agoWell the US has a very non standard view on banks compared to other developed countries. Look how the US lags in Chip & Pin. Having a lot of local monopolies is worse than larger regulated ones in my opinion.
- dools 6y agoAnd food most worryingly!! There are only like 4 meat companies in the US right?
- nly 6y agoMaybe being a bank is just more complicated today than it used to be