12 ms·
"It’s 2021, and it would be pretty hard to find someone who would come out and say that women deserve to be treated worse than men by default, and similarly dif
by giantg2 6y ago
"It’s 2021, and it would be pretty hard to find someone who would come out and say that women deserve to be treated worse than men by default, and similarly difficult to find someone believes men shouldn’t have rights. In that sense at least we are all feminists and men’s rights activists, but nearly 100% of everyone reading this would have felt some emotional recoil from being called at least one of those two things. Why? Because there’s a vast difference between a person who believes the stated beliefs of a group as opposed to a person who holds membership in a group as a defining part of their identity."
The piece of the puzzle that this misses is the difference in perceived reality between the groups - the definitions those groups use to define equal and the policies they think would provide equality. Sometimes the policies of the two groups in question are actually at odds with each other, and even their own stated intent (equality).
- MattGaiser 6y agoOr the fuzzier "equity" vs "equality" debate.
- throwawayboise 6y agoOr equality of opportunity vs equality in outcomes.
- edgyquant 6y agoI’ve seen this thrown around by Jordan Peterson and his fans but I’ve never met anyone, regardless of how crazy their ideology was, advocate for equality of outcomes outside of basic necessities. I’m convinced it’s a strawman.
- Phrodo_00 6y agoHaven't had a refresher on it since high school, so I might be totally out of the loop, but isn't equality of outcome the point of marxism?
- jhgb 6y agoNo, the point of Marxism is transitioning the society through socialism into communism.
- bjl 6y agoNot even a little bit...
- joshuamorton 6y agoNo, not really in any sense. You might say that marxism is for more equal outcomes than we have under today's system, but that's true of lots of things that aren't marxist (any form of progressive taxation to fund social programs, for example). But even that's sort of an oversimplification and doesn't do either marxism or "equality of outcomes" justice.
- Pfhreak 6y agoNo, it's not. Marx was critical of the capitalist mode of production. Marxism is a lens of looking at economics and sociology. Communism and socialism, which are considered different in modern writing but were the same in Marx's time, are something Marx believes are an inevitable outcome of capitalism. Marxism suggests that when the workers own the companies, then benefits are distributed to the workers who own/operate the company. Profit doesn't get centered in individuals, it gets spread across the workers of a company. Folks like Lenin/Stalin took this idea further and created an authoritarian regime out of the ideas, and create what we commonly think of as 'communism' in the states. Edit: Parent comment asked a question about Marxism, I'm getting downvoted for explaining some high level concepts of Marxism? Do folks want me to dive deeper into the dialectical models Marx discussed? Lol
- rjbwork 6y agoYou're correct, of course. I was also downvoted for an even slightly more simplified version of this post. Not too surprising given the general demographics of HN being quite biased towards startup founders, VC's, and the like.
- 6y ago
- vimy 6y agoProgressives advocate abolishing advanced classes in high school because “they have too many white and Asian students”. Several schools have done so. That is equality of outcome in practice.
- Loughla 6y agoThe only times I've seen "advanced classes" get abolished is when districts KEPT advanced classes in high schools, but got rid of "ability tracking" (read: high, middle, and low-performing tracks) in early grades (k-6 usually). This is because low-income and minority students are more likely to be tracked low performing in lower grades, thereby baking in the inequity in the system. Eliminating those tracking systems, while keeping AP and other TAG programs is actually a very good way to ensure equality in access with no promise of equality in outcome. . . . Those headlines tend to get spun as "Chicago district eliminates advanced classes" or something to that effect, because it gets people riled (spelling?) up. Please, point me to your sources if you are talking about something different. EDIT: The tracking still occurs in early grades, the isolation grouping does not. Students are still tracked and tested for ability, deficiency, and performance. What they are not doing is grouping them exclusively into high, medium, and low, and letting those groups dictate resource access. They are grouping across abilities, allowing high performers to work with medium and low, thereby allowing them to take a leadership role while still providing the other two groups with valuable resources.
- parineum 6y ago> This is because low-income and minority students are more likely to be tracked low performing in lower grades Are they actually lower performing or is this an effect of bias? It wouldn't surprise me at all to learn that children with less resources do worse. I thought the purpose of performance tracking was to give the ability to help those who were struggling. Instead, you're saying that it's more helpful to just not know who's struggling and that somehow creates more equality.
- Loughla 6y agoEdited for clarity. >Are they actually lower performing or is this an effect of bias? This is why these programs in early grades are eliminated - they absolutely were based on bias and external factors. Yes, children with less resources do worse. That was the problem. Students with less access would be tracked low, thereby ensuring they had access to even fewer resources (which were diverted to high performers and TAG classes). >Instead, you're saying that it's more helpful to just not know who's struggling and that somehow creates more equality. I didn't explain it well. They still track student ability for interventions, they don't group solely by ability. When they did the latter of those two, the have's had even more and the have-nots had even less.
- Loughla 6y agoI don't know why you're being down-voted, you're right. I haven't met anyone, even in the insanely left and progressive university circles that I run in, who advocate for equality in outcome. It's equality in opportunity that's important. It's about letting 'your freedom as an individual to choose your own destiny' actually be 'free' from the start and not constrained by social mores, ingrained biases or discrimination, and/or other external factors. The freedom in outcomes argument is 100% a strawman used by far right pop culture icons to drum up views and clicks.
- textgel 6y agoIt's a core belief of progressivism; those who claim it isn't know it is but are interested in protecting a movement that gives them a means of attacking those they dislike.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt absolutely isn't. Progressives, when they see inequality of outcomes at the group level, correctly identify an inequality of opportunity. There's no progressive in the world that thinks that everyone should have the same outcomes. That's different from wanting similar outcomes between groups of millions of people, because those almost invariably come from inequality of opportunity. I don't know of any left tendency that believes in equality of outcomes. Even communists don't believe in equality of outcome.
- textgel 6y agoYou believe in quotas, you believe in equality of outcome. In fact I could be inclined to agree with you in some ways; its more accurate to state that progressives don't believe in equality of outcome in much the same way as they don't really hold any disdain for racism/sexism or any of the other causes that claim to champion but they like the power that comes from doing so. For example no progressive has any issues with an imbalance in genders in nursing; this of course contrasts brilliantly against theirs views on it in the tech industry.
- commandlinefan 6y ago> advocate for equality of outcomes Well, usually when I see somebody arguing "equity vs. equality", they're advocating strict racial quotas: absolute equality of outcome, at the level of race.
- toomuchredbull 6y agoThere's this thing called communism, not sure if you have heard of it but it's becoming quite popular again amongst the younger generation.
- Manuel_D 6y agoI worked at a company that set a diversity target of 33% women in tech roles. In the same all-hands that announced this target leadership said using our definition of a "tech role" 20% of the workforce was women. To achieve this, we gave women two chances to pass the pre-onsite coding interview instead of one. Sure, this isn't as forceful as a hard 50/50 quota but it is pushing the needle away from equality and towards equity. Equity taking precedence over equality is also the basis of affirmative action used by private universities. And progressive taxation. In fact, I'm a supporter of equity over equality in plenty of instances beyond basic necessities. I think certain avenues to pursuing this are better than others, and that there are some instances where pursing equity over equality is misguided. But yes, I do believe there are instances where pursuing equity - at least in part - is better than exclusively pursuing equality.
- intergalplan 6y ago> And progressive taxation. Point of order: I'm taxed the same on my one-millionth dollar of income (assuming the same source) as Jeff Bezos is. ... I just don't have a one-millionth dollar of income to tax, but if someone wants to shift things toward equality rather than equity I'll happily accept donations toward that end. To make things more equal for Bezos and to strike a blow against equity, naturally.
- Manuel_D 6y ago> To make things more equal for Bezos and to strike a blow against equity, naturally. This is exactly my point: a flat tax rate would be more equal, but less equitable. And I do support a tax code that is more equitable, rather than more equal in this regard.
- CRConrad 6y agoYeah, taxing every dollar the same would be more equal... For dollars, but not for people.
- etripe 6y agoHave you never seen people decrying unequal representation in, say, tech? I've seen plenty of people make that claim and expect the distribution of groups to match the distribution in the general population. That's equality of outcome, not opportunity. It's also only really possible in two scenarios: A. Everyone regardless of demographic has the same opportunities, talent and interest in tech B. You force people into positions they don't want and force people out that do want them The same goes for education, nursing, construction, sewage, fire fighting...
- betwixthewires 6y agoThe trick is in how broadly you define "basic necessities." Go talk to a plains Indian in the 1700s and ask them if a permanent structure all to themselves with running water and a refrigerator is a basic necessity. Now think about access to doctors and drugs. That's the real crux of what we talk about when we talk about equality of outcomes. What qualifies as a necessity? And that's when you start getting arguments that start with things like "well in a modern society..." You'll probably be hard pressed to find someone that says that someone deserves to starve to death because they're unwilling to pull themselves up by their bootstraps. You'd probably also be equally hard pressed to find someone who thinks that waigu beef is a basic necessity. You say "strawman" and they say "moving the goalposts" and none of that is productive, this is a legitimate discussion that is going to be had, needs to be had and is not over or settled, shutting it down by calling the opposing viewpoint fallacious on false premises will not change that, it will only be counterproductive.
- Phrodo_00 6y agoGenuine question: Isn't this equivalent to equity vs equality?
- giantg2 6y agoExactly. There's a good fence and box example in here. https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/equality-vs-equity-difference https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/equality-vs-eq...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Genuine question: Isn't this equivalent to equity vs equality? Not generally, no; “equity” generally refers to fairness of treatment (as distinct from non-differentiation in equality); while concepts of fairness vary, equivalence of outcomes not the moat common understanding pursued under the banner of “equity”. Which is not to say that the two are never (especially in particular narrow domains) the same, but they aren’t in general the same.
- slg 6y agoIn my experience, people who are against "equity" call it "equality of outcome" because it sounds more Orwellian/communistic/whatever your dystopian descriptor of choice is. Very few people actually advocate for "equality of outcome". Equity is closer to "equality of opportunity" than "equality of outcome". "Equality" is neither of those things because it doesn't correct for differences in opportunity and therefore obviously doesn't yield an equal outcome.
- oftenwrong 6y ago>In my experience, people who are against "equity" call it "equality of outcome" because it sounds more Orwellian/communistic/whatever your dystopian descriptor of choice is. I call it Harrison Bergeron: https://archive.org/stream/HarrisonBergeron/Harrison%20Bergeron_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/HarrisonBergeron/Harrison%20Berge...
- yamellasmallela 6y agoPeople who use "equity" really do mean equality of outcome, and that is a huge problem. Equality of outcome is undeniably evil.
- giantg2 6y agoIn case others are looking for more on this... https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/equality-vs-equity-difference https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/equality-vs-eq...
- eloff 6y agoHonestly because neither feminists nor men's rights activists want equality, despite whatever they purport to be about. Just like there's a political spectrum with the crazies at the edges of both left and right, there is also a spectrum on gender issues, race, or any other social issue. The crazies are to be found at the edges of that, again on both sides.
- krastanov 6y agoAre you equating reasonableness of the *average* person that self-identifies as feminist and the *average* men's-rights-advocate?
- textgel 6y agoConsidering the year on year decrease in women who identify with the movement, its fairly clear anyone who would describe said movement as "reasonable" would no doubt hold the traits inherent in the movement that so many find despicable.
- krastanov 6y agoYou are making some pretty wild misrepresentations of reality: https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/07/07/a-century-after-women-gained-the-right-to-vote-majority-of-americans-see-work-to-do-on-gender-equality/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/07/07/a-centu... The closest thing I can find to your interpretation is that women of color are less probable to adopt the term "feminist" because they are less probable to feel the movement has done enough for them. I do not know who has convinced you of an alternative definition of the word, but feminism means "believing in equal treatment / equal opportunity / etc".
- textgel 6y agoLiterally the first google result of "women identifying as feminst" https://www.ipsos.com/en-us/american-women-and-feminism https://www.ipsos.com/en-us/american-women-and-feminism And plenty more for the willing student; however an ideology that considers "men are on average taller and stronger than women" to be a controversial statement might understandably place some difficulty on those in need of finding these things. And funnily enough the definition of a group has nothing to do with how it behaves; or are you suddenly going to proudly identify as a mens rights activist? I suppose its just as well that naming North Korea a democratic peoples republic magically fixed the place overnight as well.
- tryonenow 6y agoThe problem with the definition of equality within the modern feminist movement is that it does not make allowance for the social power that females intrinsically have over men. In particular it completely ignores that, as in the vast majority of sexually dimorphic species, women are (at social scales) effectively the gatekeepers of the bedroom, and this gives females massive influence over male behavior. The dominant socially acceptable view of equality therefore is markedly unequal, and quite self serving as the "ideal" balance of power within the feminist framework becomes rather lopsided.
- GavinMcG 6y ago> the gatekeepers of the bedroom There is no way this can be true. Sex takes two consenting people; there is no "gate" to be unequally "kept" because both parties have autonomy. Trying to shift to "social scales" to escape the central role of autonomy is a nifty trick. But casting individual bedroom decisions as a matter of social equality is to presume a degree of entitlement in the bedroom. After all, we're entitled to be treated equally, right? By governments? Yes. By our managers at work? Yes. By those who we desire? No, not at all.
- giantg2 6y ago"Trying to shift to "social scales" to escape the central role of autonomy is a nifty trick." I don't understand this comment. Isn't feminism addressing an issue at social scale, often in areas that include autonomy? Even looking at marriage, you are expected to treat each other fairly.
- GavinMcG 6y agoThere are absolutely places where the social scale is relevant: places where one is entitled to equal treatment. Incels mistakenly think that the bedroom is one of these places, and that they are entitled to an equal amount of sexual attention as some other man. Thus the "gatekeepers" language when there is no gate. The social-scale concerns are totally appropriate when it comes to how we construct masculinity and what male attractiveness requires, and feminists are by and large interested in that conversation.
- dartharva 6y ago> but nearly 100% of everyone reading this would have felt some emotional recoil from being called at least one of those two things What's the rationale behind this statement? It seems like it's implying "nearly 100%" people are one or the other kind of extremists when it comes to Gender politics. Wouldn't it rather be the other way round, people knowingly identifying themselves as both Feminists and MRAs (redundant, as "Feminist" by itself means someone who strives for equality among genders), since most are normally moderate in their opinions?
- betwixthewires 6y agoThe rationale behind that statement is explained in the subsequent statements in the article. Something about how there's a difference between agreeing with some group or cause's ststet principles and identifying as an in group member as a part of ones identity. The article explains it better than I am.
- monksy 6y ago> difficult to find someone believes men shouldn’t have rights. There are quite a lot of people who would try to argue that mean don't deserve rights. "men need a curfew" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD8cwX6g3do https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD8cwX6g3do MRAs being counter protested: https://www.vice.com/en/article/8gd9y4/who-do-mens-rights-activists-think-they-are https://www.vice.com/en/article/8gd9y4/who-do-mens-rights-ac... (and this article that handwavy justifies a counter-protest) Speech being protested and threatened: https://thevarsity.ca/2012/11/17/arrest-assaults-overshadow-mens-issues-lecture/ https://thevarsity.ca/2012/11/17/arrest-assaults-overshadow-...
- swiley 6y agoThere's something in humans and I'm not sure if it's an anglo culture thing or a biological thing but men who haven't reached a certain stage in life are more or less considered sub-human. Many don't reach it and still more don't develop far past it. I feel like I'm just there and there's a night and day difference in how people treat you but it's most extreme with your female peers. It's also nice to have some friends from before, I feel like they're the people I would go to if my life fell apart.