3 ms·
Is it really trackable though? AFAIK the argument is "Only Russia has the sophistication to create such a poison that we can't tell what exactly is, therefore i
by mrtksn 6y ago
Is it really trackable though? AFAIK the argument is "Only Russia has the sophistication to create such a poison that we can't tell what exactly is, therefore it must be Russia".
In hindsight, it seems like really good way operating. Russia has plausible deniability as it's not factually proven that it is them but everyone thinks that it is, therefore they earn notoriety points that can make other think twice before doing something that Putin might not like.
Russia also gets mythical literature regarding its capabilities, which means that you can fear them as much as you like. It's intellectually fascinating that KGB and now Russa developed that almost magical substance.
Odourless, colourless substances that are harmless and undetectable create extremely potent poison when come together. This creates an opportunity for drama that would give the chills in any spycraft thriller movie. Just imagine knowing that the target was tagged with one of the substances and will die once comes in contact with the other one. A substance that will do nothing to no one else but the tagged person, it creates such a tension. You can imagine the paranoia if this is an actual possibility for you.
- gustavo-fring 6y agoThis is a general strategy by Putin and his allies in the Kremlin. Google Gerasimov doctrine. It's very literally trolling.
- gustavo-fring 6y agoThe last time this was so much as mentioned in a comment on HN was 2 years ago (last story was 4). Seems like it isn't widely discussed but it has been ongoing for decades (Gerasimov's doctrine is from a Jan 2013 speech but it is Soviet and KGB tactics through and through).
- tazjin 6y agoIt could be because the person who initially posted about it has also said that he made it up from stuff taken out of context: https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/05/im-sorry-for-creating-the-gerasimov-doctrine/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/05/im-sorry-for-creating-t...
- gustavo-fring 6y agoNo, he said he made up the term, based on that speech, but that speech was describing an old strategy that the Russians understood Eastern European/Middle Eastern uprisings to be a result of. It's basically guerilla warfare + a psychological component. Everything Gerasimov was quoted as saying in that link you provided is what has taken place in Ukraine and elsewhere. The academic community has a growing literature on this if you'll check google scholar. There's virtually no doubt it is a real phenomenon even if the term has to be used with nuance (as that article says). He's saying that the behavior that "Gerasimov's doctrine" describes is not an actual doctrine. but it exists.
- ajuc 6y ago> "Only Russia has the sophistication to create such a poison that we can't tell what exactly is, therefore it must be Russia" If somebody dropped a nuke on North Korea in 50s it would be pretty obvious who did it, wouldn't it? There was only a few countries that had nukes and only 1 of them had the incentive. It's very much like that with Novichok.
- mrtksn 6y agoSomeone can argue that only the USA used nukes on the civilians and not once but twice, therefore it must be them again because who else would do such a cruel thing? False flag operation operation, they can argue. As long as you don't have a proof, it's words in the winds really.
- takeda 6y agothat's why it is perfect. It's ambiguous enough that could be misread as false flag operation, but it sends message to other targets that they are not safe.
- fatbird 6y agoIsn't that Ajuc's point? In the 50s only Russia and the US had nukes; North Korea was a client state of Russia and China, and had just recently been in war with the US. If a nuke went off in NK in the 50s, everyone would assume, quite reasonably, that the US had done it.
- ajuc 6y agoYes it was.
- monocasa 6y agoIt's not like that with Novichok. Iran has published just regular scientific journal articles confirming that they've synthesized Novichok, and it's widely believed that most of the west has synthesized it too.