4 ms·
I guess with some designs they could also reduce impact via e.g. the autorotor effect that a helicopter would use if the engine dies. Obviously does not apply t
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
I guess with some designs they could also reduce impact via e.g. the autorotor effect that a helicopter would use if the engine dies. Obviously does not apply to this particular setup.
But most designs have at least some lift, which means there is some optimal glide ratio that minimizes vertical speed. Finally, having separate, isolated systems helps as well. This is also common with multi engine aircraft where an all engines out scenario is very rare. It's a challenge but not necessarily something that can't be addressed. Even some simple airbags could help here.
- nradov 6y agoMany powered lift aircraft designs have very little aerodynamic lift and so the glide ratio is close to zero. And regardless of lift, they generally lack the articulated control surfaces necessary to establish a controlled glide. Autorotation only works if the rotor system has significant rotational inertia and a cyclic (blade pitch) control. Most powered lift designs have multiple small, low-inertia fixed-pitch rotors. If you lose power you're going straight down and probably tumbling out of control. Airbags can help a little in some low-altitude crash scenarios but if the aircraft is falling out of control then there's no way to guarantee that the airbag will be oriented the right way. It's just not practical to cover an entire aircraft in airbags like NASA did on the Pathfinder Mars landing: the technology doesn't scale up.
- ashtonkem 6y ago> If you lose power you're going straight down and probably tumbling out of control. The Osprey has a really nasty habit of doing this. A number of them have crash landed upside down from relatively low altitudes, which is a very bad thing.
- nradov 6y agoYou're referring to a vortex ring state, which can hit helicopters flying low and slow. It has nothing to do with surviving an engine failure in a powered lift aircraft.
- ashtonkem 6y agoVortex ring states in multi-engine VTOL aircraft have the unpleasant tendency to flip the aircraft over, which is markedly worse than being up right at least.
- ashtonkem 6y agoMost non-helicopter VTOL aircraft cannot autorotate. The V-22 cannot, for example; not enough inertia in the blades to pull that off.