14 ms·
Lung cancer in never-smokers: a hidden disease (2019)
- knolan 6y agoHere in Ireland we have a lot of limestone and new houses must have radon barriers in their foundation. People living in older houses without them are susceptible to lung cancer. Growing up my parents always kept our windows open when possible. My grandmother, a non-smoker, died of lung cancer.
- coldcode 6y agoMy mom died of lung cancer (actually brain cancer which often is the end result) but never smoked; however her father smoked all his life, and my dad smoked for decades before quitting. We never did figure out where the original cancer came from. End stage lung/brain cancer is a terrible way to go, which is why I have zero idea why anyone smokes at all.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoIf you don't die from lung cancer you'll die from some other terrible thing. I don't smoke but I can see why, if it gives someone satisfaction and/or relaxation, they would be willing to risk that kind of death in exchange for a lifetime of mental hacks (though there are arguably safer methods of similar efficacy).
- usgroup 6y agoUnfortunately smoking doesn’t really do that either. I’d say it has close to no benefits from a day to day cognitive perspective anecdotally. I think it’s the same for coffee. Great for socialising though . Smokers have more fun at parties since you end up chatting to other smokers whilst outside in sub zero weather sucking on your death stick. And damn do I miss a cig after dinner
- m00dy 6y agoYour comment made me smile :)
- halikular 6y agoYou have more fun in the actual party inside.
- anders_p 6y agoI was a smoker for 20 of the 45 I've been alive. Around 1 pack a day. It was exactly the social aspect of smoking that I liked the most, now that I look back at it. Smokers have an easier time establishing a bond, when placed in new groups like work or school. They meet up at the designated smoking spot and chat while smoking. It's a great ice breaker. I found that I had an easier time, when having to do group work, than non-smokers since there was already a loose connection with the other smokers. It was always the non-smokers, who were having difficulty finding group mates. I now vape on an e-cigarette instead. Still go with the smokers, so I have not lost the social benefits :) I highly recommend giving e-cigarettes a try, for any of you smokers out there, who are having a difficult time, quitting the habit. I'm aware that it's in no way healthier, but am convinced that it's less damaging. Anecdotal, yes, but it sure feels like a better alternative. Tried nicotine gum, band-aids etc., but I guess there was more to my addiction than just the nicotine. The rituals of inhaling and fondling with something. It's the only thing that's worked for me.
- anders_p 6y agoCorrection. Can't edit, but the last paragraph should've been: "I know that it's in no way HEALTHY*, but..."
- pvarangot 6y agoI got one of those vape things people use for dry weed that gets up to 405F and vape dry rolling tobacco. You can do it inside as it doesn't smell or the smell is pleasant or you can use as an excuse to go hang out with the other smokers too. You also are only burning tobacco and inhale almost no plant matter. I would give it a try. I feel better with that than with e-cigs.
- halikular 6y agoThe nicotine is what CAUSES the stress in the first place, and you have to relive it by smoking or ingesting the nicotine in another way. So essentially what you have done is raised the baseline stress level and you temporarily lower it when you get your nicotine. Then the stress levels will be ascending proportionally to the nicotine concentration in your blood which is constantly metabolized and descending. Nicotine has a half life of about 1-2 hours, so it doesn't last very long.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoHard to follow this. Do you mean the lack of nicotine causes stress during withdrawal? Of course it does, but that doesn't mean a person can't get a net overall decrease in stress by smoking regularly. I'm not suggesting it of course, but I can understand the personal motivation of someone who does.
- halikular 6y agoThe nicotine levels rapidly decrease just minutes after smoking and stress levels are beginning to climb in response until you smoke another cigarette. The cycle repeats and the average stress levels over time than for a non-smoker. If you're addicted you always stress about when you are getting your next dose of nicotine.
- robben1234 6y agoWhat about non-regular smokers? Anecdotally I smoke once a month to once a year (sometimes not cigarettes but vape, hookah, cigars) and feel the stress relief without going into cycles. Even when I was semi-regularly vaping nicotine heavy liquid it wasn't because of _need_ to get the next dose, but the distinct relief.
- Robotbeat 6y agoMan, lung cancer and stomach cancer are two of the worst ways to go...
- TaupeRanger 6y agoNot much different than other ways of slowly dying TBH. They're all mostly horrible.
- da_big_ghey 6y agoi have knew persons who were dying in peace while sleep. i only am hoping i shall be this fortuneate.
- refurb 6y agoThat happened to my grandfather as well. 3 pack a day smoker and died in his sleep at 70. But I agree otherwise. My wife’s parents both lived into their late 90’s but had lost most of their cognitive ability for the last 5 years - so much they couldn’t live independently. Not sure that’s a great alternative death.
- verelo 6y agoGlad someone brought up radon. No one knows about it. Get a HRV or ERV and ideally slab depressurization, Google the terms if unfamiliar folks! Enjoy the diy projects haha
- dboreham 6y agoSlab depressurization (essentially creating a partial vacuum under a building's concrete slab floor) can work very well. These days usable radon concentration meters are quite affordable. I used one in a building I own to verify the effectiveness of a slab depressurization system. It reduced measured radiation levels to a small fraction of the baseline. Of course you need a building with a slab foundation to use this technique.
- verelo 6y agoYeah it’s an amazingly simple approach. I did it in a house i renovated, the building inspected tried to stop me as he wasn’t familiar with the system and thought it would actually allow radon in. Turns out he had a family member die from lung cancer and they believed they was a possible link. I expect at some point it’ll be part of most modern building codes where there is a basement connecting to a living space.
- secondcoming 6y agoMy parents house was part of a national radon survey in Ireland back in the 90's I think. I had a small little black monitor/'counter' in my bedroom for maybe a year (I'm a bit fuzzy on the details). Anyway, they sent us the results when the experiment ended and we sent the device back. The results were quite bad I seem to recall (I may be mis-remembering according to [0]) Our house was in rural Cork and was build by my parents in the 80's. My father died from lung cancer but he was a heavy smoker; my mother smokes very occasionally and she's fine. However, my aunt, who lived next door, maintained a very healthy lifestyle and also died of lung cancer; her husband is also fine. [0] https://www.epa.ie/radiation/radonmap/ https://www.epa.ie/radiation/radonmap/
- vharuck 6y agoIt's a good idea to test basement radon levels when buying a new house. In my state, it's a check box on the required paperwork, so every buyer can see it's an option. The tests are cheap and quick. Check with your state for any help with finding testers or paying for the tests and mitigation systems. Radon levels vary a lot. In Pennsylvania, the worst areas lie along the Appalachians, but even then neighboring houses can have huge differences in radon. So even if your soon-to-be neighbors didn't have a problem, do the test.
- tr14 6y agoMy great grand mother died from lung cancer and never smoked one cigarette in her life. She was a humble and very sober woman. (no alcohol, no tobacco or drugs, just her medication). The reason, why she died of lung cancer is, that the area, where she grow up, was near coal mine & chemistry plant. LVL 89 tho, nice age anyways. RIP Grandma. On the other hand, my neighbor from the rural area, where my mother was born & raised, lived all the way up to LVL 93. He had one shot of hard liquor every day and smoked exactly 3 cigarettes a day. His calm live and routines granted him a superior lifespan. He died from age, calmly in the bed, with relative good health for his level.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y ago> His calm live and routines granted him a superior lifespan. That's just conjecture on your part. Some people are lucky, others are not, it's not always due to behavior. 3 cigarettes a day is also extremely low - the average is apparently 14[1] right now. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2018/p0118-smoking-rates-declining.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2018/p0118-smoking-rates-...
- zadler 6y agoIt’s low but the risk of smoking one a day isn’t 1/10 of smoking 10 a day, it’s probably much higher. https://www.bmj.com/content/360/bmj.j5855 https://www.bmj.com/content/360/bmj.j5855
- mmcgaha 6y agoWhen I was young, I figgured what would be the big deal smoking a few cigarettes per day. By the time I was 25 I realized that two packs per day was getting out of control. I don't believe there is any harmful information but the whole picture is that most folks cannot smoke a few per day. Eventually cigarettes will own most smokers.
- monopoledance 6y agoYou probably have to differentiate risk. I assume for some risks associated with smoking there is a linear correlation with exposure, where it's on/off for others, or e.g. following a logarithmic function. Nicotine, CO and radioactive toxicity have a long half-life, where primary radical damage or reactive carcinogen burden is dose dependent stochastics. Also people forget, you are much, much more likely to die from cardio-vascular damage or COPD as a consequence of smoking, than lung cancer.
- freddealmeida 6y agomy dad died from lung cancer. He smoked his whole life. His MRI's looked pretty good. So this is interesting. Makes sense. Poison, radiation.
- bokchoi 6y agoMy father also died last year from lung cancer and never smoked in his life.
- gadf 6y agoSorry for you to hear that :(
- dccoolgai 6y agoDon't forget asbestos, which despite all the hubbub never got banned. It's used in all kinds of stuff and just one or two microfibers of it in your lungs and your fate of a slow painful death is sealed.
- the-dude 6y ago> just one or two microfibers of it in your lungs and your fate of a slow painful death is sealed. Hell of a claim. Sources?
- dccoolgai 6y ago>The one asbestos disease that is different is mesothelioma. Very small amounts of asbestos can give you mesothelioma. Asbestos workers' families have gotten mesothelioma from the dust the workers brought home on their clothes. https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/asbestos/homeowner/heffects.html https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/asbes...
- the-dude 6y agoThe magic word there is of course can. Although both asbestos and mesothelioma are very nasty, I fail to see evidence for your claim that your faith is sealed.
- shawnz 6y agohttps://thorax.bmj.com/content/58/9/809#xref-ref-7-1 https://thorax.bmj.com/content/58/9/809#xref-ref-7-1 > Necroscopic studies have led to the determination of asbestos fibre load and the demonstration of a dose related effect, thus making improbable the argument that mesothelioma only requires one fibre of asbestos for initiation of the malignancy. Furthermore, asbestos exposure in urban settings is very common: https://www.atsjournals.org/doi/10.1164/arrd.1980.122.5.669 https://www.atsjournals.org/doi/10.1164/arrd.1980.122.5.669 > We isolated uncoated asbestos fibers from the lungs of 21 urban dwellers who had fewer than 100 asbestos bodies/gram of lung, a level shown previously to be associated with environmental rather than occupational exposure to asbestos
- bengale 6y agoMy friends grandfather died from a lung cancer he got from years of soldering before they introduced the lead free stuff.
- bijant 6y agolead is terribly toxic stuff, but the lung cancer would most likely be caused by the flux, which you will still find in lead free solder. Which is why You should always ensure good ventilation when soldering.
- gadf 6y agoCould microplastics, aerosolized in seawater be playing a role in this? I saw something that most of the non-smoking related lung cancers are in coastal regions
- ghjnut 6y agoThis is me. I'm 34 years old and was diagnosed with stage 3B non-small cell lunge cancer in February- a 3cm adenocarcinoma in my right lung as well as metastases in some lymph nodes. When they tested me they found my cancer to have an ALK+ biomarker which is frequently found in young, non-smokers. Luck of the draw I guess.
- EForEndeavour 6y agoSorry to hear. I don't know much about cancer, but that sounds scary to say the least. What was your pathway to diagnosis? Was it picked up in a routine checkup, or did you feel symptoms that convinced you to see a doctor?
- ghjnut 6y agoI had a dry cough for about 3 months that only seemed to crop up in the evenings. I didn't think much about it as I have quite a few allergies and chalked it up to that. I decided to visit the doctor when I started getting some chest tightness when I was going to sleep and I was also getting what I can only describe as hot flashes just as I was falling asleep. It felt like just as I was about to fall asleep I'd get an adrenaline shot and I'd spring back up wide awake. My PCP did a clean EKG which showed nothing, then it showed up on X-Rays. I immediately got PET scans which showed 2 masses. I then had a bronchoscopy to ensure it was malignant where they noticed additional lymph nodes. I then had a mediastinoscopy showing spread in 3 clusters of chest lymph nodes. I went through 6 weeks of chemo and radiation that resulted in a 25% reduction in the primary tumor and no change in the metastases in a hilar lymph node. I'm now scheduled for a bi-lobectomty to remove my superior and middle lobe on the right side, as well as however many lymph nodes they can get a hold of (check out "da vinci thoracic surgery" to see the robot beast the surgeon will be using). I have almost no symptoms outside of a slight cough and still run 1-2 miles per day. I've generally been a grin-and-bear-it guy when it comes to my health. Please suck up your pride and stay on top of your health.
- EForEndeavour 6y agoThank you for sharing this extremely detailed experience. I could definitely see your comment helping to save some stranger's life when they google something like "adrenaline shot before sleep chest tightness." Best of luck with your impending encounter with the da Vinci bot and life after cancer.
- agumonkey 6y agobefore I can find a nicer source, here are some geographical maps of lung cancer https://duckduckgo.com/?t=lm&q=map+of+lung+cancer&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?t=lm&q=map+of+lung+cancer&iax=images... helps getting an idea of environmental impact
- fortran77 6y agoAnd I suspect these unfortunate individuals are treated with suspicion / lack of respect from the medical and insurance industries.
- decafninja 6y agoMy uncle died of lung cancer in Korea; neither him nor anyone in his family smoked. If culprits were to blame, it's probably his coworkers - Korean men are notorious smokers even today and it was worse when he was of prime working age. (quick Google stats indicate 40% of men smoking vs. 16% in the US as of 2016, and it's obvious many, many men smoke if you just live their and peoplewatch.) His death is one reason I really hate smoking. In Manhattan it's especially annoying when you have to go past an honor guard of smokers wreathed in a carcinogenic miasma cloud of smoke when you enter or leave office buildings, or if you're walking in a tightly packed crowd and someone ahead of you decides to light one up and cropdust everyone behind with a blessing of cancerous smoke.
- collyw 6y agoYou don't think that diesel fumes are a more likely culprit? I saw this study mentioned which showed negligible risk for passive smoking unless you are actually living with a smoker. https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2013/12/12/study-finds-no-link-between-secondhand-smoke-and-cancer/?sh=282b7f8f65d4 https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2013/12/12/study-f...
- decafninja 6y agoKorean corporate culture is extremely workaholic - even today but especially during his working years (1970s to early 2000s) - he probably spent more time with his coworkers than his family. Also people likely smoked indoors in the office when he was working. Indoor no smoking bans didn't come until later in his career, and even today I think enforcement is much more lax compared to the US.
- ornornor 6y ago> he probably spent more time with his coworkers than his family. This is so sad. Unless he didn’t like his family.
- Clubber 6y agoFrom the article he linked. The study found no statistically significant relationship between lung cancer and exposure to passive smoke, however. Only among women who had lived with a smoker for 30 years or more was there a relationship that the researchers described as "borderline statistical significance." Over at the Velvet Glove, Iron Fist blog, however, journalist Christopher Snowden notes "there's no such thing as borderline statistical significance. It's either significant or it's not," and the reported hazard ratio was not.
- calibas 6y agoVarious scientists and organizations have been yelling for years that air pollution is one of the leading causes heart disease and cancer. It's not "hidden", it's being ignored... https://www.iarc.who.int/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/AirPollutionandCancer161.pdf https://www.iarc.who.int/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/AirPollu...
- throwawaysea 6y agoDoes the possibility of other causes (like air pollution) also mean that some portion of lung cancer incidents are misattributed to smoking, overstating its dangers by some amount?
- hammock 6y agoSmoking increases your risk of cancer from air pollution, so it's not so simple
- hammock 6y agoRadon is the second leading cause of lung cancer
- hammock 6y agoAir pollution was a huge issue when I was growing up as a kid, the #1 environmental cause. At some point people stopped talking about it and focused mostly on global warming.
- agumonkey 6y agoDo you, or anyone around here, use air cleaning devices in your homes ?
- calibas 6y agoI have an air quality monitoring device and I live in a place with clean air, so I just open a window. A PM2.5 of 2.318 (ug/m3) inside my room at the moment.
- 6y ago
- refurb 6y agoThe article is interesting for what it doesn’t call out. There are people that get lung cancer without a cause - just an unlucky lottery of errors introduced through natural processes. If I recall correctly, 1/3 to 1/2 of all cancers don’t have a cause. Just bad luck.
- ComputerGuru 6y agoDon’t have a cause or don’t have a known cause? There’s a big difference between random mutation and unknown precipitator.
- pessimizer 6y agoIt's not the cancer caused by moral failure, it's the good kind which is caused by God's plan. https://www.dailymotion.com/video/xc3x84 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/xc3x84
- refurb 6y agoWell considering we already know of inheritable cancers that have no cause other than bad genes, it’s clear a large portion of cancers have no environmental causeZ
- ComputerGuru 6y agoYes, but then are others like our recentish discovery that drinking hot liquids often can cause mouth/throat cancer.
- hh3k0 6y ago> There are people that get lung cancer without a cause I'd be quite surprised if breathing in microplastics does not contribute to the risk of lung cancer -- and essentially every human being is exposed.
- refurb 6y agoWe use plastics in medical implants so it’s unlikely.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoI fervently hope mass adoption of EVs will lead to a marked decrease in cancer, and not just lung. Who knows what oil, antifreeze, additives, and all the chemicals used in processing no longer being emitted on tailpipes, dumped as part of refining byproducts, and the like are no longer placed into the environment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrtnmcc 6y agoI good reminder to test your home for Radon. Check your local Radon maps, there are hot spots throughout the world that vary locally. Even if maps show low values it is worth testing.
- subpixel 6y agoOld wood burning stoves are also quite unhealthy, and perhaps even dangerous. My wife won't let me use ours, which is only 20 years old. The EPA issued new regulations such that all new stoves manufactured after 2020 emit far less smoke and particulate both indoors and out. The American Lung Association actually runs programs that will pay you to replace your old wood stove, which probably says something about their potential impact on health.
- Izikiel43 6y agoWhat about barbecues?
- subpixel 6y agoAll sorts of fires contribute to air pollution and barbecues are not an exception. The compounding factor with woodstoves is that they are indoors and they are often the primary source of heat for months on end, meaning they they emit smoke and particulates into the air you breathe all day and all night.
- kozikow 6y agoMy mother was recently diagnosed with stage 4 lung cancer. Never smoked, no alcohol. For 3 months doctors were diagnosing her coughing as probably covid related, even when tests came negative. Probably a lot more people got late cancer diagnosis due to Covid. And lung cancer deaths are at 150K vs 577K for Covid. As article says, genetic mutations are much more common among non-smokers. Exon 19 deletion egfr mutation was detected, so she started on Osimertinib that works very well. Sadly Osimertinib will work for a year or two, and then cancer mutates and gains resistance.
- izend 6y agoWhat about Radon exposure? Big problem in Canada in certain cities: "Over 16% of lung cancer deaths are attributed to radon exposure in Canada. It is estimated that more than 21,000 Canadians will die from lung cancer this year, and more than 3,000 of those deaths are because of exposure to radon indoors."
- kozikow 6y agoNo radon risk in north-eastern Poland according to some Googling. Only risk factors was pneumonia many years ago and maybe a wood fireplace. Wood fireplace seemed properly insulated, chimney was regurarly inspected and no smoke escaped, but who knows.
- ufo 6y agoJust to add a clarification for the rest of HN, since this is a common source of confusion... Every cancer has gene mutations. Typically these mutations are only present in the cancer cells and are not there from birth. They don't indicate a hereditary predisposition to getting cancer. Really sorry to hear what your family is going through. This kind of stuff is never easy to deal with.
- kozikow 6y agoFor some reason, non-smoking lung cancer means 2-3x higher chance of finding a mutation that could be used for targeted therapy - e.g. EGFR, ALK, ROS1 and others. It doesn't mean that this mutation was present at birth, but at some point some cells mutated and became cancer cells.
- diob 6y agoI grew up in a household where they chain smoked inside. Pretty much just waiting to get cancer at some point.