4 ms·
The insight about starting from the public odds is so important. It's like running from a polar bear: you don't have to outrun the bear, only your buddy. Not co
by kqr 6y ago
The insight about starting from the public odds is so important. It's like running from a polar bear: you don't have to outrun the bear, only your buddy. Not counting the track take, any deviation from the public odds in the correct direction makes you money.
(And the public is often reliably biased -- this is why they say sports betting is more about betting on gamblers than on games.)
A smaller deviation makes you less money that one time, of course, but it also saves you lots of money if you're wrong, ensuring you live to bet another day.
Also in real life: people in aggregate aren't dumb (just a bit biased), so using the public opinion as your prior and then adjusting it Bayesically with private information gets you a more reliable edge than guessing wildly.
- le-mark 6y agoThe dynamics of odds movements are interesting in their own right imo. Some sports, with many days between matches (nfl, college football) lines can move drastically between when odds are published to match start. Others sports that play daily or by-daily often don’t see the swings. And then what facotors influence the line movement? People with predictive models that see great value in opening lines can move the line a lot. Things like injuries, starting lineup, breaking news before the match can certainly move the line. Casual bettors and fans betting on their team (the public) move the line but usually day of the match. The key insight is the books are trying to balance winners/losers to maximize their profit, that’s why the line moves. It’s also why historically spread betting is nearly 50% odds.
- joosters 6y agoThe key insight is the books are trying to balance winners/losers to maximize their profit, that’s why the line moves. In two-way markets (e.g. a tennis match) maybe. With more outcomes, it's a rare market that ends up with the bookmakers locking in a profit regardless of the outcome. For horse racing, the favourite in the race is most often a loser in the book for the betting firm. Even for football (soccer) betting, i.e. team A/draw/team B, generally a bookie is very happy for a draw, because people just can't get very enthusiastic about betting on a tied result. Raising the odds on offer for a draw won't attract many extra regular punters, it only risks luring professionals who are more sensitive to the odds - and they aren't the customers you really want!
- ProjectArcturis 6y agoIn horse racing, at least in the US, betting is done via a pari-mutuel system where the house pools all the money, takes a 20% cut, and then pays the remainder split between winning tickets proportional to the bet size.
- kqr 6y ago> Things like injuries, starting lineup, breaking news before the match can certainly move the line. But! At least until recently, people overreact to events like these. If you see the line moving strongly at once, it's more often an overreaction than an appropriate adjustment.
- bluecalm 6y agoAlong those lines it used to be a very good strategy to bet against popular clubs/players. As fans like to bet on their favorite teams/players there was too much money on that side so the bookies moved the line to balance. I don't follow sports betting anymore and my guess is that there is enough smart money out there these days to close that market inefficiency but it's an interesting mechanism.
- user5994461 6y ago>>> (And the public is often reliably biased -- this is why they say sports betting is more about betting on gamblers than on games.) One mistake here. It's the house that sets the odd, not the public. When the house sets the favorite to 1:3 odd and the second favorite is 1:4, they better be damn right about that proportion. At the end of the run, the money on the losing side will need to cover the winning side, and if it doesn't the company must pay the difference out of pocket. The direct effect is that there is an enormous spread, the article mentioned about 17%, for the exchange to cover high uncertainty and make some profit.
- kqr 6y agoIn parimutuel betting, which is what the article talks about, the public sets the odds.
- user5994461 6y agoI doubt it's parimutuel per the strict definition. It's subject to extreme variations due to liquidity and doesn't work well in practice, especially for quant trading and at the volumes involved here. (If it were, the article certainly did a terrible job of showing it, where's the part where odds moved last minute and massive losses ensued, or where both rivals took the same large position causing massive losses to one another). Anyway, the deeper point still stands, the house takes an ENORMOUS margin, could be in the order of 25% (even nowadays). This changes everything.
- topicseed 6y agoFrom my understanding[1][2], the Honk Kong Jockey Club does indeed follows a strict parimutuel pool betting system, like the PMU in France (at least years ago). Though you are right, the house have historically taken massive cuts per pool. Eapecially as for years they were the only allowed gambling arenas. [1] https://betandbeat.com/betting/parimutuel/ https://betandbeat.com/betting/parimutuel/ [2] http://special.hkjc.com/racing/info/en/betting/guide_qualifications_pari.asp http://special.hkjc.com/racing/info/en/betting/guide_qualifi...
- joosters 6y agoIt's not just a 'wisdom of the crowds' thing where you are using people's betting in aggregate. The odds also reflect private information that other in-the-know people may also have. The problem with pool betting (like in HK) is that the odds only become significant right before the start, when everyone has placed their bets. This means that there is a strong motivation for everyone to wait until the last possible moment to bet - meaning that the odds then only become useful even later!
- vgeek 6y agohttps://www.hpb.com/products/the-wisdom-of-crowds-9780385721707 https://www.hpb.com/products/the-wisdom-of-crowds-9780385721... This is a good book that discusses how an individual may be wildly wrong, but in aggregate, groups are remarkably good at estimating many common things. Although with horse racing, the betting favorite only typically wins ~30% of the time or places (1st or 2nd) ~50% of the time. Given that this is with average field sizes of probably 6-8 horses, it is materially better than blindly betting.