2 ms·
> UBI is really the only functional alternative to a minimum wage. i dont think that's true. re-education and re-training into higher value work is a better i
by chii 6y ago
> UBI is really the only functional alternative to a minimum wage.
i dont think that's true.
re-education and re-training into higher value work is a better investment. it's just that education of adults isn't funded well by society, and thus the debt load for that re-education is too expensive for the benefit.
I would argue that society should have a funding system where if you re-trained (may be in some category of work that society determins to be useful, like nursing), the cost of that education is only going to be placed on you if you earned above a threshold wage after graduating from training.
- shkkmo 6y agoEducation and training is solving a different issue, one that is orthogonal to the one solved by minimum wage or basic income. I think making public colleges free (similar to germany) would be a massive benefit to our economy. But making all education free doesn't do anything to help remove the need for the minimum wage. If you have an alternative to the minimum wage that isn't UBI, I would love to hear it.
- chii 6y ago> one that is orthogonal to the one solved by minimum wage or basic income. no it isn't orthogonal - UBI and minimum is based on the premise that there exists people who would not be able to produce value that is enough to sustain themselves (aka, they consume more resources than they produce), and thus need the rest of society to pick up that slack (otherwise, they'd just die). I'm saying that people would always be able to sustain themselves if they are able to get trained to do something useful. As more knowledge is required in the modern day, this training becomes more expensive, and so society should make this investment, rather than place the entire risk onto the individual.
- shkkmo 6y agoThat is not the premise on which UBI is built. If I had to pick just one it would be that we have more productive capacity than we need, so threatening people with death (your words) to be productive is no longer necessary.
- chii 6y ago> we have more productive capacity than we need i'm not convinced that this is true, except with very basic necessities like food and water, and even then, those require a lot of energy to produce, and those aren't free yet since science hasn't discovered cheap or free energy yet.
- shkkmo 6y agoWe have distribution and allocation problems, but we definitely have sufficient productive capacity to provide a reasonable standard of living. Even if you pick a standard of living that makes this premise not true, this is still the primary motivating premise for UBI. This is why UBI is so closely linked with the rise of Automation to a point where there simply won't be enough jobs to retrain people to do.