7 ms·
An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku
- theknocker 6y ago>By The YouTube Team I'm tired of seeing shit like this. It's not a "team," and it's not a "blog." It's a massive corporate monopoly that doesn't even allow itself to be contacted by its customers, and this is a press release.
- JediWing 6y agoThis is all so ridiculous and anti-consumer. There are working apps. Right now! The status quo should be that existing apps stick around. As far as codecs, or anything of the sort, Roku has a device that they sell to customers. Google must write an app that works on that device. I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats.
- aranelsurion 6y agoSeems to me all these problems would simply vanish if consumers could decide what they want to install. All this craziness started with App Store 's to begin with, and hopefully one day might end with their demise. One can hope.
- falcolas 6y agoNah, this all started with normal retail channels. They introduced the concept of the middle man and the markup that entity would demand for their services. App stores just brought this into the digital space, overwhelmingly large profit margins and all. Folks here frequently laud Epic for their attack against Apple, but even their (comparatively low) margins are kinda ridiculous for the bare minimum service they provide.
- shakna 6y ago> I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats. That's the way the Roku works. If you already have the app installed, then it will continue to work and function as-is. It's only disappeared from the store. If you uninstall, you won't be able to reinstall, but the app isn't remotely removed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JediWing 6y agoBut if the app is working, why shouldn't it be on the store?
- tw04 6y agoSo google should continue to be forced to pay royalties for a codec because Roku refuses to slightly increase the cost-of-goods by utilizing a newer chipset that supports AV1? On HN of all places, I'm surprised to see that the guy throwing his weight around to GET RID of proprietary codecs is being portrayed as the bad guy. I'm sure if you dig far enough into my history you'll find I have absolutely no sympathy for google under almost any circumstances, but in this case they're doing the right thing.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y ago> supports VP1 You mean AV1
- yipeedipee 6y agoI would understand if: A) Roku were not paying to have it on their platform B) Consumers weren't paying for the service as well.
- jsnell 6y agoBut per the earlier reporting, Roku is not paying to have the app. The money is flowing in the opposite direction: they are taking a cut from both subscriptions and adds.
- totalZero 6y ago> On HN of all places, I'm surprised to see that the guy throwing his weight around to GET RID of proprietary codecs is being portrayed as the bad guy. When it comes to these gluttonous Big Tech companies, I tend to err on the side of the smaller guy. Your comment doesn't capture that dimension of the conflict.
- cmeacham98 6y agoWhy? Roku had over $1 billion in revune in 2019 (couldn't find 2020 data) - they're massive. While Google is obviously bigger comparing their relative sizes doesn't seem to make much sense.
- atomicUpdate 6y ago> Google must write an app that works on that device. Why? Saying they must support Roku devices is a pretty firm (and strange) stance to take. Where does the line get drawn on what devices they do or don't have to support? > I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats. This would certainly have unintended consequences. What do you consider "stupid corporate spats"? Why should Google be forced to support codecs on HW they don't manufacture?
- hundchenkatze 6y agoI believe they mean that if Google _wants_ YoutubeTV to run on Roku's devices then Google must write an app that supports that hardware, not that Google must support all devices in existence.
- JediWing 6y agoYes, exactly what I meant. If they want to be on the device, write within the bounds of the device and support it throughout it's lifetime. Don't hold your massive customer base as leverage after having supported multiple apps on the platform since forever.
- oofabz 6y agoYou want to legally mandate backwards compatibility? That would cause all kinds of unintended consequences. The ability to break backwards compatibility has been central to the continued development of every platform. Windows, Mac OS, Android, iOS, the web, are all unable to run certain old programs. Some of these platforms offer more compatibility than others, but none offer 100%. Most of the time, the breaking changes end up being good for consumers, especially in the long run. Change is necessary for technological progress and banning such activity would be like throwing out the baby with the bath water.
- JediWing 6y agoIt's not backwards compatibility support, it's warranty. Google is running Youtube. It's very profitable. They can afford the maintenance burden of running these apps for the supported lifetime of Roku devices. It's really no different than running Youtube to an old computer.
- g_p 6y agoI am particularly concerned by the eWaste implications of this kind of decision. At a time of a global semiconductor shortage (likely for 6+ months), it looks like consumers will be left to deal with the fallout of these kinds of deals. If we normalise "deprecate that hardware as it lacks some logical software feature", that's bad for the environment, and bad for society in general. That's currently normalised though, so we have a long way to go to get this put right. It's a shame we're nearly full circle - we had fully programmable computers, now we need to add hardware codecs to them, in order to prevent those general purpose programmable computers from lasting too long (!)
- CraftThatBlock 6y agoIf the app was there before, and they are saying the terms didn't change, they how could Roku want "lower requirements"? I don't think they can downgrade the hardware in existing devices that are shipped. Maybe I'm misunderstand this, but this smells fishy.
- barbazoo 6y ago> Our initial conversations started with Roku simply to renew the current terms of their ongoing deal with YouTube TV > However, Roku chose to use this as an opportunity to renegotiate a separate deal encompassing the YouTube main app Those seem to be 2 different apps they're talking about
- striking 6y agoFrom the article: > Roku requested exceptions that would break the YouTube experience and limit our ability to update YouTube in order to fix issues or add new features. For example, by not supporting open-source video codecs, you wouldn’t be able to watch YouTube in 4K HDR or 8K even if you bought a Roku device that supports that resolution.
- dmitriid 6y agoWhich is clearly bull crap. Youtube happily provides 4k video in H.* formats elsewhere. What Google says is: use our VP9 codec, or else.
- Hamuko 6y ago>Youtube happily provides 4k video in H.* formats elsewhere. Do they? Because if I put a 4K video through youtube-dl -F, I get this: 248 webm 1920x1080 1080p 1392k , webm_dash container, vp9@1392k, 24fps, video only, 193.77MiB 137 mp4 1920x1080 1080p 2650k , mp4_dash container, avc1.640028@2650k, 24fps, video only, 368.92MiB 271 webm 2560x1440 1440p 3453k , webm_dash container, vp9@3453k, 24fps, video only, 480.62MiB 313 webm 3840x2160 2160p 10434k , webm_dash container, vp9@10434k, 24fps, video only, 1.42GiB
- BoysenberryPi 6y agoNone of this passes the smell test to me but this in particular > ...To be clear, we have never, as they have alleged, made any requests to access user data or interfere with search results. This claim is baseless and false. If Google is telling the truth here I feel like this is worth launching a lawsuit against Roku.
- otterley 6y ago> I feel like this is worth launching a lawsuit against Roku. On what grounds?
- BoysenberryPi 6y agoDefamation. What Roku is alleging is a direct attack on Google's reputation and if Google is telling the truth then it should be easy to verify in communications between Roku and Google.
- coliveira 6y agoThere is a simple way for Google to disprove Roku: just support the device. If they don't do that, everything else is just a smoke screen operation.
- true_religion 6y agoThey don't want to pay Roku money. It wouldn't be natural to demand someone clear their good name by paying money (i.e. 'support' the device) to the person who insulted them. That's akin to blackmail.
- teawrecks 6y agoRoku has a platform. If google wants to be on it, they have to be OK with giving them a cut. Why is that so difficult?
- Jabbles 6y ago
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoSounds like this is exactly what happened to me with the Spectrum TV roku app. They didn't delete the app from my Roku, but said that I can't install it again from the Roku Store. So now that means I can never upgrade my 2 year old roku streaming stick. This basically means that Roku is useless to me.
- kbenson 6y agoThere are ways to install apps not through the store. I'm not sure about Spectrum TV specifically, or if old versions of the apps are available from Roku by app code even if they don't show, but side-loading it directly is also an option. Here's what I just found WRT Spectrum specifically: https://www.techowns.com/spectrum-tv-on-roku/ https://www.techowns.com/spectrum-tv-on-roku/
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoThanks for the link. I may decide to go that route if they don't resolve their issues and if I still care at that point.
- kjjjjjjjjjjjjjj 6y agoI do not believe google for one second. This makes no sense.
- raldi 6y agoAs always, when Google uses the headline, "An update on X", it means, "We're turning off X."
- Sebb767 6y agoIn this case, it's technically "They're turning off X"
- lousken 6y agowhy roku doesn't want to allow av1 is beyond me
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agothey're already selling those streaming sticks at a loss. I imagine adding another hardware decoder chip (is there one for av1?) will increase their costs, without being able to pass it on to youtube, which sounds like part of the problem.
- otterley 6y ago> they're already selling those streaming sticks at a loss How do you know?
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoSince they're a public company we get to see exactly what they spend their money on [0]. Look at Platform Gross Profit vs. Player Gross Profit. It looks like previously they were selling at a loss, and in 2020 they managed to start selling basically at-cost. [0] https://ir.roku.com/static-files/0e84462d-74ac-459d-9aff-be335c09a4f3 https://ir.roku.com/static-files/0e84462d-74ac-459d-9aff-be3...
- bluthru 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1#Hardware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1#Hardware
- datapolitical 6y agoCan someone explain what the actual issue is here? Roku is claiming it’s not about the money and they both seem to be talking past each other to a degree.
- pgrote 6y agoIf you're going to reference the contract, release the specific sections of the contract. If you're going to reference Roku demands, release the emails. It is tiring when 2 corporations sling it at each other without any backup. Maybe after the HBO fiasco and now this it's time to reassess choosing Roku devices as the default.
- StreamBright 6y ago>> Our agreements with partners have technical requirements to ensure a high quality experience on YouTube This high quality experience caused my device to randomly reboot while watching youtube. Also because of this the last android update bricked the device that is rendered useless. Because of this great experience I am switching to Apple TV just like I did with my phone long time ago. Google does not give two shits about customer experience for a long time. Unlimited data collection is the only thing they care and everything else is secondary.
- andybak 6y ago"to bring you the content you love" Who writes stuff like this and thinks it sounds authentic?
- Someone1234 6y agoThis comes across extremely disingenuous. If you read Roku's version of what is being negotiated and then read Google's, then note that Google only discusses the popular one (codecs) and seemingly forgets all the ones that make them look bad. I don't consider Roku a "good guy" with all of these disputes, but on this one based on the information we have it seems like Google tried to flex and got rebuffed. They then thought the recent other disputes w/Roku would give them cover, but it hasn't worked too well so far. PS - I do feel like Roku's position on the codec though is a little weak/vague. But Google's lack of statement about the other 90% of the dispute is worse.
- CA0DA 6y agowhere can i find "roku's version"?
- Someone1234 6y agoHere's an earlier thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26992358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26992358
- g_p 6y agohttps://www.axios.com/roku-google-youtube-tv-dispute-525316c1-4d66-44e3-a96a-40db7b10e05b.html https://www.axios.com/roku-google-youtube-tv-dispute-525316c... seems to have a copy of their version of events, at least that they communicated to customers.
- evil-olive 6y agoThis [0] Axios article has a summary. It also includes a screenshot of the actual email Roku sent. Imgur copy of the screenshot at [1]. 0: https://www.axios.com/roku-google-youtube-tv-dispute-525316c1-4d66-44e3-a96a-40db7b10e05b.html https://www.axios.com/roku-google-youtube-tv-dispute-525316c... 1: https://i.imgur.com/4VtDUxI.png https://i.imgur.com/4VtDUxI.png
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoIf Google did indeed offer to continue under the current terms, then I would say that Roku seemingly is the one that is at fault. If Roku is trying to renegotiate other items under different terms, it seems reasonable for Google to be able to ask for things they want as well. For example, if Roku wants a bigger cut of ad revenue, it seems reasonable for Google to come back and ask for silicon supporting AV1 to be installed on future Roku devices. (I have no idea if that is the source of contention, but I'm just saying it seems like reasonable, good faith negotiation.)
- slugiscool99 6y agoEach company has said conflicting things. Is one of them straight up lying?
- Zelizz 6y ago> For example, by not supporting open-source video codecs, you wouldn’t be able to watch YouTube in 4K HDR or 8K even if you bought a Roku device that supports that resolution. There are two sides to this, the encoding side and the decoding side. Google can frame it charitably towards themselves by saying "the Roku won't be able play 4K HDR", but we could just as easily frame it as "Google doesn't want to encode non-AV1 4K HDR". Both companies are trying to save costs, but Google's trying to frame it as Roku failing its users (users which are Google's as well, if they're trying to watch YouTube TV). To be clear, I think open-source codecs are great, and it makes sense for devices (especially plugged-in / home internet devices) to support as many as is reasonable.
- tomComb 6y agoBut it's quite possible that the Roku devices won't be capable of supporting those higher resolutions using the older codecs. Not saying that is the case - I don't know, but I don't think you do either.
- cpeterso 6y agoGoogle already encodes 4K VP9 streams for youtube.com desktop browsers. Roku supports VP9 playback, though perhaps YouTube TV has unique requirements for DRM video playback? Or perhaps Roku's VP9 decoder doesn't support 4K?
- darig 6y agoAwwwwww.... Is it annoying when a company cuts you off from a service you took for granted? Look in the mirror, Google.
- auiya 6y agoWhat's the deal with horizontal scroll bars on the top of web pages indicating the vertical position of the page? Do browser scroll bars not work anymore?
- btgeekboy 6y agoSome platforms (at least MacOS) hide the scrollbars by default if you’re using a trackpad.
- asaddhamani 6y agoThey are hidden by default on certain platforms, and you need to scroll to see your position.
- squarefoot 6y agoIt's the modern web, whose motto seems to be: "making the easy difficult through the useless".
- judge2020 6y agoI didn't experience that before turning off ublock origin. It seems the YT-specific google tag manager[0] script is loading it, blocked by easylist for `/gtm.js`[1]. 0: https://blog.youtube/static/blogv2/js/csp/gtm.js https://blog.youtube/static/blogv2/js/csp/gtm.js 1: https://github.com/easylist/easylist/blob/3d27d8f9f4752fda718a5464f9b503745401b025/easyprivacy/easyprivacy_general.txt#L2256 https://github.com/easylist/easylist/blob/3d27d8f9f4752fda71...
- yk 6y ago> Roku requested exceptions that would break the YouTube experience and limit our ability to update YouTube in order to fix issues or add new features. I assume that is pr speak for, it would limit youtube in experiencing the app users?
- Const-me 6y ago> From day one, we’ve worked to .. make the app available on as many devices as possible They have not made the app available on Windows Phone, and banned Microsoft's app a few times: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/08/google-blocks-windows-phone-youtube-app-again-for-manufactured-reasons/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/08/google-blocks-window...
- knodi 6y agoIf you ask me for proof I don't provide you any. Less than 3% of Roku users launch YouTube TV channel on Roku.
- csdreamer7 6y agoI specifically bought a new Roku Ultra 2020 for 4k AV1 decode support as I knew AV1 would be big, especially if I move to an area with poor broadband. As far as I know that is the first device that supports that. I love it-plugging in my headphones for private listening works very well. https://www.engadget.com/roku-ultra-dolby-vision-streaming-player-130015662.html https://www.engadget.com/roku-ultra-dolby-vision-streaming-p... From what I am reading between the lines: Youtube wants to dump H.265 because of patent royalties. Roku has a lot of 4K streaming sticks with H.265 support but no AV1 support. Roku picked a fight over it because maybe those customers would leave for Google devices? I no longer will get YT updates for my AV1 device. Is this correct?
- judge2020 6y ago'YouTube' and 'YouTube TV' are separate apps - as far as I know, YouTube TV is no longer on the store (as the contract expired) but the YouTube app contract is still in place and thus still available on the store. The regular YouTube app's fate is unknown at this time but you should be able to use it at least until December (ctrl f this blog post for the source on that).