19 ms·
QNAP ships NAS backup software with hidden credentials
- criddell 6y agoQNAP shipped Hybrid Backup Sync with hardcoded credentials of walter:walter. This was used by ransomware criminals to encrypt photos and videos and demand payment in Bitcoin for the password to decrypt the data. From that page: > The code has 27 occurrences of e-mails: waltershao@gmail.com or walterentry20140225@gmail.com in the code. More information is available here: https://www.helpnetsecurity.com/2021/04/26/qnap-nas-ransomware/ https://www.helpnetsecurity.com/2021/04/26/qnap-nas-ransomwa...
- judge2020 6y agoWas there any development on if there was an actual investigation or help from Google to identify the fraudsters, given these are @gmail email addresses?
- hedora 6y agoWalter Shao is a qnap employee, and probably not related to the fraudsters.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat really should read 'was' rather than 'is'.
- PostOnce 6y agoThat still wouldn't fix the fact that they don't have a process to prevent this from being possible. This is a multi-faceted fuck up, and several people are responsible. This includes the management who decide on processes, like QA and security. Someone should have caught this in some kind of review at a company as big as QNAP Systems shipping real hardware to all kinds of businesses and consumers. Maybe Walter should never have coded this in, but that doesn't mean that it should even be possible for that to reach an end-user. Other companies and other industries have such processes. In short, that would just be blame-shifting by the management who are also at fault.
- jacquesm 6y agoYou'll get no disagreement from me on that one, clearly the process is horribly broken. But given that fact it is better not to have 'Walters' on staff.
- hulitu 6y agoSo instead of fixing the problem just fire walter ? Why not use walter as a test case. What about john, or jane, or fred ?
- PostOnce 6y agoThere's also the fact that Walter will never, ever again in his life make this mistake since the massive fuckup is now burned into his brain (in theory, if that isn't the case, then of course he needs to be fired) -- of course, there are a lot of people who would never have made the mistake to begin with. It's not completely trivial to answer, but again should be impossible by process.
- rkagerer 6y agoThe latest HBS 3 Hybrid Backup Sync 16.0.0419 has 1215 lines of code with the word "walter". Walter's a popular guy. (Apparently he's QNAP's Technical Manager)
- bastard_op 6y agoNo wonder he was promoted, so he'd stop doing stupid things like that. Obviously they've not wiped up enough after him.
- jchw 6y agoQNAP has some enticing out of the box NAS products, but I guess I feel a bit better having chosen Synology. That’s not to say I necessarily love any of these vendors too much. They feel a bit too much like feature mills that have lower incentive to adopt better security practices and higher incentives to add features and, well, provide a decent user experience. I appreciate the latter, but it isn’t ideal. Still, as much as I’d love a NAS running open source software and maybe even open hardware, I think the amount of time and effort spent on doing so would not be well rewarded. So for now, I guess I’ll ride the useful life of my Synology NAS out and go from there. As for this incident, it is embarrassing, but it happens. Hopefully this will motivate more people to do security research on these devices.
- zf00002 6y agoI am still happily running FreeNAS 11. I haven't updated to 12 and it's name change to TrueNAS. Anyway, the amount of janitoring I have to do with it is very minimal. Over the last year, less than 1 hour of time spent total.
- coffee_is_nom 6y agoAnother very happy freenas user, been running freenas (now truenas) for 8 years. Other than hard drive upgrade and one hard drive failure it has been pretty smooth. My overhead in last year has been maybe 5 hours of upkeep.
- s800 6y agoFreeNas user for many years here, very happy in multiple environments- small home/office stuff and larger "production" environments.
- buro9 6y agoSynology on the other hand just remove file systems that you may be using https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26800062 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26800062
- berkut 6y agoNow that ReadyNAS (Netgear bought them years ago, but the hardware and software was still decent up until recently when they stopped releasing updates) seems to have given up in the (pro)consumer space (4+ drives), is Synology the only option now? Asustor and WD seem to be making more advanced and larger drives, maybe they're options...
- karmicthreat 6y agoSynology has always had better software. But they have been more expensive and they have been threatening to lock out some features unless you use their drives. There is no real competitor on the market right now except QNAP. And who wants to deal with FreeNAS, I have better and more important things to do with my time at work.
- cosmotic 6y agoHow is Synology software better? I've had the pleasure of setting up rsync between Synology and QNAP and I would say the Synology software appears to be better but actually isn't as good. Synology appears to use older versions of a lot of tools like rsync. Although it doesn't say so, it doesn't rsync the data files, it rsync's the files that make up the backing of the software-raid. It's like rsync of the blocks of a sparse disk image instead of the files within the disk image. This makes it impossible to resume or adopt a previous backup. If any of the configuration for the rsync-send changes, it appears to download the entire remote so that it can compare the contents of the files to the local instead of hashing remotely, which nearly completely defeats the point of using rsync. It took my backup task WEEKS to adopt an existing backup that had very few changes.
- karmicthreat 6y agoI guess within the features I use its been a better experience. i use it as a NAS and DVR. The snapshotting and change reversion features have saved me a few times where engineering employees have messed up their files. Thanks for the point about NFS though.
- sodality2 6y ago> Thank you Walter Shao, best engineer ever! This is really good for your CV! Oh, and you owe a few people 0.01 BTC... Best line of the thread
- bigmattystyles 6y agoI feel bad for Walter and people blaming him as the sole responsible party are just part of a mob reaction - is this backdoor bad; yes, QNAP should suffer a financial setback*, but who among us hasn't done something like which then combined with pressure to release from management and (obviously) poor corporate code review and audit practices gone on to 'almost'** release something that shouldn't be. My point, this isn't on Walter alone, in fact, most of it isn't, it's the software development processes (or lack thereof) that allowed this happen. My guess, Walter will be shown the door, QNAP will be able to say we took action and got rid of Walter but the true issue, the bad process that led to this, is probably still there. Worst, Walter's knowledge of the code base will also be gone. And no, I'm not Walter if anyone is wondering. * they won't **'almost' is in quotes for plausible deniability reasons on my end..
- rsj_hn 6y agoAgreed, the new password should be feelbadforwalter --> decrypt + base64 zbQOp+Pa0RxqLuTjuNnJ3A==
- bbernhard90 6y agoAm I the only one that thinks that connecting the NAS directly to the internet is a stupid idea to begin with? Don't get me wrong, I can totally understand why people (without much technical background) are tempted to do this. But with all the complexity these NAS systems nowadays have it was only a matter of time for something like this to happen.
- ziml77 6y agoI think it's insane to do. I wouldn't want to open my NAS up to the internet. I can VPN into my home network if I need to access it remotely.
- abfan1127 6y agoI can't imagine attaching anything directly to the internet outside my router.
- criddell 6y agoAnd you likely have UPnP disabled.
- criddell 6y agoI think it's a bad idea as well but I don't blame people for doing so because of how QNAP markets them. Competing products are marketed in the same way.
- karmicthreat 6y agoOther than your router you should not have ANYTHING directly on the internet these days. There is just too much surface area for device software now and cost pressure doesn't allow for security to be much of a priority.
- comboy 6y agoI'd like to hear what HN folks would most comfortably put as that router (device/software).
- rhexs 6y agoI really wish there was a small NAS case that didn't look like a massive box. The QNAP/Synology 4 bay low power form factor is just killer for fitting into small spaces, but if I could put a core i5 in one of those with some flash to get some more VMs going and run linux or some BSD distro, that'd be incredible. Smallest one I've found is https://www.u-nas.com/xcart/cart.php?target=product&product_id=17636 https://www.u-nas.com/xcart/cart.php?target=product&product_..., but not quite as compact as I'd hope. As I can't find DIY hardware like that, Synology looks to have a slightly more mature vulnerability response program than QNAP -- apparently they have a bounty? I've heard about less Synology flaws, so hopefully they're a slightly better choice on the software side.
- aDfbrtVt 6y agoI use one of these chassis [1], the form factor is great. Be mindful that some of the bracing blocks the pcie slot on some motherboards. [1] https://m.aliexpress.com/item/33038670915.html?spm=a2g0n.productlist.0.0.2f5d2239ttdnxK&browser_id=ac490f3a93854f28b901656d3c9a6790&aff_trace_key=&aff_platform=msite&m_page_id=1791fbd09fd5760c988818c25cc100a0b56712db9d&gclid=&_imgsrc_=ae01.alicdn.com%2Fkf%2FHTB1fBjjcwKG3KVjSZFLq6yMvXXaW.jpg_640x640Q90.jpg https://m.aliexpress.com/item/33038670915.html?spm=a2g0n.pro...
- tremon 6y agoI have this one at home: https://www.mini-itx.com/~NAS6 https://www.mini-itx.com/~NAS6 . It measures roughly 20x20x30 cm and can fit a standard mini-itx motherboard. Not as small as a dedicated ARM box, but the smallest I could find. Fitting the PSU is very fiddly though, there is hardly any space between the PSU and the HDD backplane.
- paol 6y agoWould you mind giving a quick review of the acoustic characteristics of the case? I'm looking to move away from a QNAP box, and one of the driving reasons is the horrible "hard-plastic hard-mount everything" design that couldn't amplify hard drive noise any more if they'd done it on purpose.
- trengrj 6y agoIf you want a small NAS in a similar form factor I'd recommend Helios64 5-bay NAS https://kobol.io/ https://kobol.io/. It is an Arm64 board runs mainline Armbian. Also comes with 2.5Gbit networking and a built in UPS battery. I don't understand why people who care about security and have linux knowledge would use Synology/QNAP. They are both proprietary, often exposed to the internet, and packed full of so many features that they are consistently full of vulnerabilities (SynoLocker/QLocker etc).
- thinkmassive 6y agoHelios64 looks amazing but they've been sold out for a while. You had my hopes up for a moment there, haha
- patentatt 6y agoSeems to be so common with these niche SBCs and accessories. They look so cool, but are unobtainable. People sometimes complain about the over-use of RasPis, but one thing they have going for them is that you can always find them available from many different sources.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThe built-in UPS feature is very cool.
- icedchai 6y agoIt's very cool, until something goes wrong with it. IMHO you are better off getting an external UPS and putting some other stuff on it.
- kalleboo 6y agoIt seems much more efficient with a small, DC, li-ion UPS than an external UPS which will use an AC inverter (and now you gotta decide, spring more for pure sine wave?) and heavy lead-acid batteries.
- knrdjngr 6y agoIs there an official statement regarding the exploit? What should/can you do at this point to ensure access to your data?
- gumby 6y agoWhat drives are people buying these days for moderate-load / high reliability RAID?
- tremon 6y agoI usually use the surveillance-line of disk drives. That's WD Purple, Seagate Skyhawk, or Toshiba S300. Theoretically, their firmware is supposed to be tuned to a higher queue depth and lower latency, which should be beneficial to RAID performance. Haven't run any performance numbers on them, though.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoNAS-oriented drives from manufacturers that don't lie about which disks are SMR and which are CMR. Right now, that means I buy Seagate Ironwolf drives and avoid WD like the plague. You never want an SMR drive. Just say no.
- OldTimeCoffee 6y agoSeagate Exos (x14, x16 or x18) and Ironwolf or WD HC520. Consumer drives, like the Ironwolf drives, are usually more expensive than enterprise. If you have a SAS backplane get SAS because they're cheaper as Chia caused the price of SATA drives to skyrocket.
- aborsy 6y agoIt’s worth mentioning that, people found that Synology also has a default encryption password (same password for all devices): https://blog.elcomsoft.com/2019/11/synology-nas-encryption-forensic-analysis-of-synology-nas-devices/ https://blog.elcomsoft.com/2019/11/synology-nas-encryption-f... The OpenVPN also had a hidden password: https://www.cvedetails.com/cve/CVE-2014-2264/ https://www.cvedetails.com/cve/CVE-2014-2264/ The funny thing is that, they didn’t even bother to choose a longer password (the password is synopass). Even if people haven’t found them, an attacker brute forcing these passwords would easily find them.
- encryptluks2 6y agoCrazy when things like this happen people even rarely get fired and the company just says "oops, we'll do better." US retailers should stop selling QNAP after something like this. Who knows if this was accidental or intentional.
- flyinghamster 6y agoI was on the fence about getting some type of off-the-shelf ARM-based NAS, but once again my wariness of "consumer" hardware turned out to be a good call. I wish it could be otherwise. My current NAS is an old PC that I built for the purpose many years ago with ECC RAM and an unlocked Phenom II, and currently runs Ubuntu Server after I experimented with OpenSolaris just in time for the Oracle takeover, and then took a detour through CentOS. It's getting kind of long in the tooth now, and I could get a lot more oomph for the same power consumption, or the same for less power. It's clear that my next server is going to have to be one I build up myself, just as before. I'm leaning toward an AM4 server board (such things do exist), as it offers lots of CPU options from cheap/low-power to Ryzen 9 5950X. The latter is extreme overkill, but it's an option nonetheless. ;) I'd be most likely to go midrange on the CPU. ECC RAM is a no-exceptions must. I'm on the fence whether or not I should spring for 10G Ethernet. I have absolutely nothing else that uses it right now, and I have perfectly good gigabit gear that has served me well and would rather not throw out or try to sell. It might be worthwhile anyway as a direct single-client SAN.
- jploh 6y agoI was close to getting a QNAP as they are cheaper than a Synology. My use case is storing home security camera footage. Currently, I have an old PC running Linux with software RAID. My motivation to switching to an appliance was power consumption and heat/noise. I live in a tropical country so I can't get away with passive cooling. Due to dust build up, the Intel Celeron CPU and motherboard broke down. It's been replaced with an AMD Athlon. My plan was to replace the entire setup with an appliance NAS the next time it breaks down. I'm now hoping it will last long enough that an ARM-based CPU solution will work out. My top candidate is the ROCKPro64.
- dsego 6y agoI wish I'd built my own instead of buying synology. The added value software is just a gimmick to pad the marketing material, most of it has only the most basic functionality and isn't particularly well made.
- bombcar 6y ago10G Ethernet is cheap enough that I made a "mini backbone" using a CRS305-1G-4S+IN and threw my NAS and main desktop on it. It's nice.
- __jem 6y agoOne of my roommates reset the router and accidentally enabled upnp, which I didn't notice for weeks. Just fixed it a few weeks ago, and seems like I avoided this, phew. I think I'm going to decom the QNAP and just roll my own...
- kwdc 6y agoStopped buying storage appliances when my old drobo went out of support. Now I get a suitable case, fill it with drives and go from there. Even a usb tower with ten drives is far more preferable than some proprietary linux derivative with a downward ticking support window. I genuinely believe you're better off with a combination of: A. an integrated solution like freenas/truenas, unraid or even ceph if you want even more steps. Install and configure. Done. B. a base linux install with just the particular file servers you need. Install and tinker. Auto-update. Remove unnecessary packages.
- theogravity 6y agoI sold my QNAP NAS a year ago as QNAP does not have a strong security track record. If anyone is looking for an open source NAS solution, I recommend OpenMediaVault - it runs on Debian Linux and provides a management GUI for managing ZFS pools. I'm currently using a 3 disk setup with WD Red (CMR) drives + SSD cache on ZFS with it and have had a good experience in the past year using it so far. I've had to replace one of the disks due to age and ZFS makes it super simple to replace and resliver disks.
- strictfp 6y agoHow can you tell if you've been hit?
- strictfp 6y agoFound out that QNAP have an official response with instructions, sounds like their malware remover should detect it: https://www.qnap.com/en/security-news/2021/response-to-qlocker-ransomware-attacks-take-actions-to-secure-qnap-nas https://www.qnap.com/en/security-news/2021/response-to-qlock...
- lmilcin 6y agoHey, at least they did not remove the posts from the forum and ban the author, like Apple does regularly.