10 ms·
It makes sense if you realize that everyone wants everyone else to have a minimum quality of life, but everyone is also trying to pay/sacrifice the least to ach
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
It makes sense if you realize that everyone wants everyone else to have a minimum quality of life, but everyone is also trying to pay/sacrifice the least to achieve it.
We want employers to provide benefits, as opposed to the government because that means higher taxes. Then you put a million exclusions and tax deductions and other loopholes, so no one knows what they're really getting, but we can say we did something and that benefits do exist to serve as arguments against broadly, easily accessible benefits to serve as a floor on quality of life.
- giantg2 6y ago"It makes sense if you realize that everyone wants everyone else to have a good quality of life, but everyone is also trying to pay/sacrifice the least to achieve it." And what defines a good quality of life depends on who you ask.
- treeman79 6y agoWhat about people that can not handle a normal job? I have a chronic condition and for a year the only reason family didn’t end up on street is because of gig jobs. Most days 12-16 hours a day in bed essentially blind in horrific pain. But sometimes totally fine. Disability straight up laughed at me.
- zepto 6y agoThis. so much policy is designed around the idea that people should work a 9-5 at a corporation, without any consideration for the fact that this simply doesn’t support a lot of people’s needs. We need more flexibility not less. Ironically this completely flies in the face of any motion or ‘diversity and inclusion’.
- lupire 6y agoAre you claiming that gig/piece work isn't a "job" for an "employee"?
- novok 6y agoIf you are an employee, the employer has the right to dictate your schedule and put significant more restrictions on how and when you work, which they do because it's more economically efficient for them to do so (think: time and transition costs). When your a contractor, not so much.
- wtf42 6y agoWhat you described is called "sick leave" in Europe and you are entitled to sick pay by law.
- xyzzyz 6y agoIn Europe, any time he wanted to get this sick leave, he would need to go to a doctor every single time. That means multiple visits at a doctor every week. After a few weeks or months of being only available randomly, he would get fired from most jobs anyway (which happens regularly in Europe too, there is just a few more hoops to jump through).
- robertlagrant 6y agoWhile I agree with the thrust of your statement, he'd probably only need to go once a week at most.
- treeman79 6y agoOn average I was going to three doctors a week. Mostly trying to find out what the heck was going on with me. Each outing would eat up all of my energy for a couple of days. I have nothing left for work family or generally life. At a certain point I had to stop going to the doctor so I would be able to get enough hours in keep keep the house.
- robertlagrant 6y agoApologies - I meant in order to stay on sick leave in Europe, not for diagnosis purposes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- minimuffins 6y agoThere are certain things that aren't in question about this. Enough income to afford decent housing and food, healthcare, etc. It's not so mysterious.
- citilife 6y agoI know multiple people who have never worked a day in their lives. They get food stamps, free health care and live in a $300/month apartment subsidized by the state (aka free). They basically make money buying and selling items occasionally, when they see a deal. That's enough for them to buy all the "luxuries" they want ($5k car, $2k laptop) every couple years. I think there's a big difference between peoples desires/definition of acceptable and what they put in to obtain them.
- hobs 6y agoBuying and selling items is in fact considered work!
- umvi 6y agoAgain though, define "decent". It will vary depending on who you ask.
- minimuffins 6y agoThere is enough space to move around in the dwelling. It is not falling apart. It is not infested with rats. There is clean running water. Come on. Stop pretending this is a hard question.
- Domenic_S 6y agoIt is bad faith or sheer ignorance to think this isn't a hard question. Consider that even people spending their own money on their own housing often can't define their own parameters, which is why touring houses is a thing. Now scale this out to the population of a country and creating a single bar of "decent housing" is incredibly hard. And then that's just talking about the structure. What about the location - if a person's entire support system is in one location but the available free housing is 75 miles away and they don't have a car, that isn't decent. This comes up all the time re the affordability of the Bay Area where locals get priced out, someone says "just move to stockton" and the resident feels it's not fair (or "decent") to have to leave where they were born and raised. You could link location to workplace I suppose but then that would create massive downward pressure on wages since people would be willing to sacrifice pay in order to live where they prefer. This sounds like a net negative. This question is only hard if you haven't thought about it for more than like 2 seconds.
- dhritzkiv 6y agoFor starters, there's what many developed nations have agreed the minimum is, including: 2 or more weeks of paid time off, statutory holidays, parental leave and benefits, and –most importantly– socialised healthcare. Some –certainly not all– have taken it a step further and offer pharmacare, daycare, a livable minimum wage, and free higher education. Still, worldwide, there's an uneven or inequitable provision of other basics, such as disability benefits, guaranteed housing, food, and internet access. All of which I would argue is even more necessary for a good quality of life for all.
- taurath 6y agoI’d say you have the first statement wrong - some will give but only not if they’re forced, some won’t give anything in any circumstance, and some would give a lot of not blocked by the other two. I don’t want to be chained to my employer for benefits, for retirement, for healthcare. It’s stupid to put a sociopathic entity with no accountability to you in charge of your basic needs.
- hagy 6y agoSimilarly, many of us don't want to be chained to a comparably sociopathic and unaccountable government entity. We'd instead prefer to independently manage our own unique needs using our own individual economic agency.
- taurath 6y agoSorry you think government is sociopathic and unaccountable, it honestly seems like a rough life if that’s what you’ve experienced.
- hagy 6y agoHow can anyone look at the atrocities committed by every major government over the centuries of its existence and not see that large governments are orders of magnitude more sociopathic than the worst corporations? Its just a general feature of large and powerful organizations; shared by governments and corporations alike. Governments simply hold the power to commit larger atrocities. Just look at how the city of Flint, MI poisoned their own citizens water while suppressing knowledge of their actions. [0] While in the grand scheme of government atrocities this actually appears relatively minor, this issue happened in very recent times. One could fill pages listing government atrocities before even getting to basic incompetence and mismanagement. While inefficiencies happen in all bureaucratic organizations, governments hold singular power over their citizens in a way that no corporation could ever dream of. This is not an argument against government. There are some services that only the government can provide. E.g., a strong military. Nor is this an argument against government playing some role in promoting general welfare. I just personally would like the option to not be further dependent upon our government and would rather use my own economic agency to provide for my own unique needs. Many other people feel similarly and therefore reject this further intrusion of government in dictating our labor relations with employers. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flint_water_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flint_water_crisis
- manigandham 6y agoA "minimum quality of life" has nothing to do with your worker qualification. People can, and should, have the freedom to choose how they work. The obvious solutions include new hybrid classifications or mandating certain benefits based on tenure. Why is this not considered? Why take away choice from those who specifically decided not to get a full-time driving job (which have always existed)?
- throwaway1777 6y agoI choose the work minimally, maybe 2 hours a month for doordash. Can I collect my benefits still?
- KMnO4 6y agoAlmost all discussion on this topic suggests a minimum amount of work to qualify.
- manigandham 6y agoThere are always basic limits. For example you don't get all of your healthcare coverage or benefits on the first day of your job, and certain things like vacation time are accrued as you work. It's not a complex problem to solve.
- d4mi3n 6y agoI see things like this that seem to me to imply that in order to deserve benefits, someone needs to work. I think a more productive line of debate would be: 1. Do we, as a society, believe we should only care for those who can be productive? 2. Do we, as a society, value things other than productivity? 3. Do we, as a society, believe it is the place of a governing body to ensure a standard quality of life (whatever that standard may be)? Putting barriers around who deserves what doesn't really serve to do much other than exclude people who don't know how to work the system, or those who are unable to work the system.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nerdponx 6y ago> We want employers to provide benefits, as opposed to the government because that means higher taxes This is a silly argument. You pay for your healthcare no matter what, it's just a question of who administers it. > Then you put a million exclusions and tax deductions and other loopholes, so no one knows what they're really getting This is precisely the current state of employer-sponsored healthcare, and also the wildly complicated medicare/medicaid system. Universal coverage combined with higher taxes (ideally on people who already have lots of money and therefore place very little value on marginal income) is arguably better and easier to reason about than a mandate for employer-provided coverage and its associated opaque and complicated effects on labor markets, including higher fixed costs of hiring people and decreased ability for people to move between regions, industries, and even jobs within the same industry/career.
- munk-a 6y ago> This is precisely the current state of employer-sponsored healthcare, and also the wildly complicated medicare/medicaid system. I'm happy to talk about manufacturer drug rebates which is an amazingly crazy portion of the healthcare market that would be illegal in almost any other market due to the perverse market incentives it creates. But yea, the short version is that the private healthcare market is incredibly inefficient.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> This is a silly argument. You pay for your healthcare no matter what, it's just a question of who administers it. But who administers it has a lot to do with how much you pay for it. For example, a high deductible plan will save you a lot of money as long as you aren't in the 99th percentile of healthcare needs, and (unless the deductible is really high) still not bankrupt you if it turns out you are. Any kind of government plan that doesn't give you that choice because it's paid from taxes rather than premiums is plausibly going to cost you more money. And that's true even on average, because high deductible plans make people more price sensitive, which exerts downward pressure on costs. (The fact that US healthcare regulations disfavor high deductible plans is one of the reasons costs remain high.) The US system is also uniquely screwed because the rest of the world piggybacks on US medical R&D while in practice regulating prices even for products under patent. The result is that the US market is paying a disproportionate share of the R&D cost. Cost comparisons to single payer systems that pretend that single payer systems are inherently less expensive are ignoring the lower contribution of those systems to worldwide medical R&D. Moreover, the recipient companies are disproportionately in the US and have lobbyists and large numbers of voter-employees, so implementing a single payer system here would be unlikely to remove those costs. Then you're left with the resulting increase in price insensitivity and the US system becomes even more unaffordable. It's actually a hard problem. The solution probably has to involve the other countries paying more of the R&D.
- Consultant32452 6y agoI don't want government or employers to provide benefits. I want people to keep their money and decide what is best for themselves. I don't believe the government or my employer has my best interest at heart, nor are they equipped to cater to my unique family needs..
- ddingus 6y agoSadly, you do not live in a vacuum. The system needs to serve everyone and make sense. Everyone choosing what is exactly right for them implies those choices are all possible and the complexity, risk and cost profile also makes sense. Those things are not true, and the outcome is rapidly escalating cost and risk exposure. This has been addressed in many ways, and one of the easier ways is to have government fund those bennies to provide a respectable floor. People who need more can choose to do that and the market for such things would make much more sense and be lower cost and risk for everyone. An example seen worldwide is supplemental plans that operate in addition to primary plans, which are actually illegal in many parts of the world due to the inherent conflict between profit motive and health care. You wanting to keep your money and make choices is very different from wanting other people to keep their money, which is an overreach frankly. Further, in the current scenario, you really can't be sure medical people have your best interests in mind because the priority is making money not making sure we have healthy people. When medical people are free to actually make healthy people a priority, the discussion about best interests becomes a much easier one.
- Consultant32452 6y agoI don’t want to argue with you or change your mind. I just don’t want to live in the same country with you.
- ddingus 6y agoAgain, sadly, unless you find new land to settle, ideally with some very committed peers to help against risk, you will be living with people, many who will express the same sentiments, pretty much anywhere you go in this world. Rough state of affairs, I would imagine.
- ddingus 6y agoAnd that really is a priority discussion. Universal healthcare, say Medicare for All style, does not have to mean higher taxes. And it would make a big difference to gig workers and the ones working for the likes of Walmart. A very high percentage of Walmart employees need government assistance due to their income not actually being enough to pay the laborer what their labor costs them to deliver. At a minimum, labor needs to exist reasonably and show up for work. Healthcare is a part of that, right along with the basics. All of us are subsidizing labor for a few of us to put profit, or more peak profit in the bank. The priority discussion boils down to what makes the most sense for the nation. Do we cut back on the military industrial complex? Maybe we decide subsidizing labor makes sense. That would also mean not shaming and blaming people who seek and obtain help from the government. Doing that is baked in right now, in that no matter what those people do, a large percentage of them will need help. Or, we simply change nothing and yes, taxes are higher, but the national spend is lower overall. Many of us will benefit. We could prioritize it so employers are more on the hook in various ways. Some of them will not be viable. Even if they all are, we may not have enough jobs. Government could be an employer to make sure everyone has a work opportunity that pays enough to exist and show up for work. There are many options. Not all mean higher taxes, but all that discussion means a national priority talk also has to happen. If we do nothing, our priority is not having people make it, exist reasonably and show up for work. Predictably, lots of people are not making it, may do crime, are homeless, may not have health care, maybe will show up for work, if they can get it. If our priority becomes about people existing reasonably and showing up for work, we will see that, but will have higher taxes, or back off some other things we currently make a priority.
- sokoloff 6y ago> Universal healthcare, say Medicare for All style, does not have to mean higher taxes. How would that be? It seems like it certainly would to me. Maybe by less than employees plus employers currently pay in aggregate healthcare costs, but I can't imagine a way where the government pays for Medicare-for-all and taxes don't go up. Do you have a specific idea in mind that I'm missing?
- deleted 6y ago
- mikestew 6y agoWe want employers to provide benefits "We" don't necessarily think benefits should be provided by the whims of private businesses. as opposed to the government because that means higher taxes. The assumption here being that benefits from the government are paid with higher taxes, and benefits from employers being paid from the kindness of the CEO's heart and not from wages that would have otherwise been paid you.
- reedjosh 6y ago>We want >"We" don't I want the money that my employer pays into health insurance to be paid to me into an HSA like tax sheltering of healthcare funds, and then I want no health insurance middleman. Poof---there goes all the corrupt incentives and ridiculous administrative overhead.
- warkdarrior 6y ago> I want no health insurance middleman That is literally impossible. Even if insurance companies are made illegal tomorrow, that role of market maker between providers (doctors and hospitals, drug companies) and customers (patients, employers) will always exist. This is because such a role is needed. Patients do not have the capacity nor the knowledge to find the best doctor, the best hospital, or the best drug maker for them.
- jessaustin 6y ago...do not have the capacity nor the knowledge... Health insurance was invented in the late 1930s as a political ploy to forestall government health programs. Did patients all get stupid at that time, or was it the case that they were all going to the wrong doctors and hospitals before then? Please give human beings a little credit. We make decisions every day, some of which are a lot more substantial than which state-licensed physician to hire. ps. you don't know what "market maker" means...
- reedjosh 6y ago> That is literally impossible. Okay, but I didn't mean literally outlaw insurance middlemen. I mean fix the incentive structure such that I have the option to forego insurance middlemen. > Patients do not have the capacity nor the knowledge I completely disagree, and what business of yours or anyone's is it to say I'm `lacking in capacity and knowledge` to such a degree I shouldn't be allowed to make my own healthcare decisions!? Worse still, right now the US government puts a cap on the percentage of profit an insurance company can take from premiums which coupled with the current near monopolistic healthcare insurance system incentivizes paying as much as possible for treatment to justify higher premiums.