3 ms·
There is no such thing as UMN ethics board, although they do have an ethics office: https://integrity.umn.edu/ethics https://integrity.umn.edu/ethics. I don't
by dekhn 6y ago
There is no such thing as UMN ethics board, although they do have an ethics office: https://integrity.umn.edu/ethics https://integrity.umn.edu/ethics. I don't think they get individually involved in specific studies unless there's been some sort of compliance violation.
It's also questionable whether the IRB should have considered this human subjects research and not given them an exemption.
It's also questionable whether, if the IRB had done that, the IRB would have stopped the study or asked for revisions to the study design (they would if they were paying close enough attention).
Professors at universities are typically given large amounts of freedom to conduct studies without heavy prior approval, it's a tradeoff.
- shadowgovt 6y agoAnd it's a trade-off that the Linux maintainers have now justifiably called them to task on for making the trade-off in a way that pushed the cost onto external parties.
- hinkley 6y agoAs the top level stated, "fuck around and find out."
- floatingatoll 6y agoOkay, “UMN’s ethics review(s)” encompasses whatever the exact ethical review process(es) are. Updated.
- dekhn 6y agoethics is mostly self-regulated; when you apply for grants, the University ensures you're not proposing to do anything illegal (risk protection for the U), but subsequently doesn't actively monitor most researchers to ensure they are being ethical. Same for publications. In those cases, the response is entirely reactive, doing investigations and actions after the problem hits the press.