6 ms·
Most "premium" products costs are mostly Advertising, R&D, paying employees/shareholders, etc. They're valid things to spend money on, but don't reflect the "
by londons_explore 6y ago
Most "premium" products costs are mostly Advertising, R&D, paying employees/shareholders, etc. They're valid things to spend money on, but don't reflect the "top quality ingredients" that consumers expect the money to be spent on.
I suspect many consumers wouldn't like to know that the $1500 iPhone they just bought only has $400 worth of actual parts in.
- 55555 6y agoExactly this. A lot of consumer gadgets that cost $60 involve spending $30 on ads.
- devoutsalsa 6y agoI'm willing to buy a $1500 phone w/ $400 in parts because it has a better user experience than $150 phone with $50 worth of parts.
- weird-eye-issue 6y agoWhy are you comparing a $1500 phone and a $150 phone? And how is that even relevant?
- molszanski 6y agoTotally agree. I am too, willing to buy a $300 000 car w/ $100 000 in parts because it has a better user experience than a $30 000 car with $10 000 worth of parts.
- Uehreka 6y agoI agree with the gist of this comment, but not the numbers. I don’t have sources to hand at the moment, but while Apple’s margins are notoriously high, they’re not that high. OLED screens are quite expensive.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoHere's a source that says the cost is $415. You're right that the OLED is expensive, it costs $23 more than the LCD it replaces. https://www.counterpointresearch.com/bom-analysis-iphone-12-costs-21-percent-more-than-iphone-11/ https://www.counterpointresearch.com/bom-analysis-iphone-12-...
- londons_explore 6y agoIt should be taken with a massive grain of salt, but [1] suggests $431 BOM cost for an iPhone 12 Pro. [1]: https://www.counterpointresearch.com/bom-analysis-iphone-12-costs-21-percent-more-than-iphone-11/ https://www.counterpointresearch.com/bom-analysis-iphone-12-...
- me_me_me 6y ago> only has $400 worth of actual parts in Heh. Yeah 400 ;)
- pwned1 6y agoBut that reflects an ignorance of how cost accounting works. Sure, it might include $400 of parts, but a hell of a lot of R&D, equipment, labor, and overhead are amortized into that phone. A very cursory look at Apple's latest income statements shows that the net profit margin on their revenue is about 20%, meaning that the phone's actual cost to produce is somewhere around $1200 (assuming a $1500 retail cost).
- londons_explore 6y agoYes, but will you be the one to explain that cost accounting to each buyer? "Yes Maaam, we'll spend $200 of the money you're about to give us on a fancy campus with hammocks to try to attract good engineers. Oh, and the massive billboard outside that made you walk into the shop in the first place."
- lizardmancan 6y ago$1 for labor > For the effect to work, the cost disclosure must be voluntary, not forced (e.g. by regulation). A logical conclusion from the study.</sarcasm>
- HeyLaughingBoy 6y agoTBH, I've consistently found that "average people" have a better intuitive understanding of costs/profit than the average engineer. That may sound strange, at least it does to me, but I've noticed it for as long as I've been in this profession.
- Cederfjard 6y agoHow has this manifested itself? Where do you see that engineers tend to go wrong?
- HeyLaughingBoy 6y agoThis was not an easy question to answer :-) I guess what I've noticed is that although if you pressed them, engineers (across a range of fields) understand that businesses need to generate a healthy profit to stay afloat, they still seem to be uncomfortable with the idea of "profit" at all. And they seem to be surprised when you bring up the question of "how will you make money from that?" Whereas the "general public" tends to think of it with an approach of "make as much money from it as you can because it might not last." I know that's not a very good description but it's the best I can do at the moment.
- 1123581321 6y agoThat sort of item might benefit from displaying upfront costs instead of BoM. It'd be an interesting study.
- chadash 6y agoPoint taken, but perhaps a bad example. When I buy an iPhone, I'm paying a little for materials, but mostly I'm purchasing the culmination of tens of billions of dollars of R&D that possibly surpasses any other product on Earth. A better example might be a luxury brand wallet where they sell the illusion of better quality, but that may or may not be true.
- pydry 6y agoLuxury brand wallet owners feel much the same way about their wallets that you do about your iPhone.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoPerhaps, but I think most luxury brand buyers fall into one of two categories: 1) They are paying more for quality materials, durability and perhaps a hand-made feel (that may or may not be in line with reality). 2) They are paying more so that they can get something that most others can't only because it's too expensive. I really can't believe that people who buy $2000 handbags think that the handbag company is doing any R&D into handbags. But perhaps they do...
- pydry 6y agoYou can replace R&D with trust, material quality, worksmanship or some other ethereal hard to pin down quality.
- Frost1x 6y ago>I suspect many consumers wouldn't like to know that the $1500 iPhone they just bought only has $400 worth of actual parts in. This is neglecting software development, maintenance, new features rolled out, etc. Yes, you're overpaying beyond cost, Apple would go out of business if you weren't. The question is are you overpaying for the functionality or value you get out of the product/service and are the margins too fluffy. In the case of a designer wallet or velben goods in general, you're really paying for the status and symbolism in the inflated margins. This may be true of some iPhone owners who don't use their phone or buy one every quarter but not most, they're getting utility and value out of the devices that's likely worth the cost. Velben goods get a bit complex as well because of intangible value in social situations. Sure, that designer wallet is a waste of money. My $10 leather wallet does the same thing and is probably more durable (even blocks RFID, yay). There is much theater to life, however, and velben goods can land you in situations surrounded by those will wealth that leads to opportunities you might not otherwise have. Impression and perception is difficult to assess value (advertising and marketing in business sure think its valuable), but you'll find you may get bumped in lines, have better service, land a job, or something else all because of such social impressions. This is the entire reason people don't wear flip-flops, athletic shorts, and t-shirts into the office or interviews and why some people carry thousands of dollar hand bags around. The question is: what's your ROI on these impressions? It's difficult to measure and frankly to me seems typically like a net loss. I personally think it's crazy and could care less if you waste money to flaunt wealth or play status games, but I've witnessed the effects first hand of success in this realm to not completely discard the intangible value that may exist.
- elboru 6y agoTo be honest I don’t pay for expensive parts, I don’t really care if they cost $100. Instead I pay for a final product that can last me more than 2 years without becoming crap. I bought my first iPhone 4 years ago, today it works like the first day (I only had to replace the battery a few months ago). I never experienced that from any Android, I’m not saying there aren’t good quality Android phones out there, but I never found it and I got tired of not finding it. If another brand can give me that same reliability and for less money I’ll happily and quickly switch.
- vntok 6y agoTry any Samsung Sx product. You won't even have to replace their battery after only 4 years.