7 ms·
DPA blocks facial recognition system in Italy and MP proposes moratorium
- gcthomas 6y agoThe UK Met Police have been using facial recognition systems on London without regulation for a while, under the same law, - it'd be nice for our ICO to make a ruling on it.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoWe need to block it on a federal level in the USA. Don't allow any state to use facial recognition software for any reason, except maybe at airports, but only for terrorism---not for any other reason.
- zo1 6y agoSounds like a modern-day version of Luddism. We don't need to block it. We need to embrace it and make sure it's used properly, safely and with accountability. We're not talking about nuclear warheads here. There has to be a safe and secure way to get the benefits of large-scale and centralized facial-recognition and tracking.
- jhgb 6y ago> We're not talking about nuclear warheads here. True, we're talking about something worse. The danger is higher and the detectability and barriers to entry are lower.
- brodock 6y agoOnce systems are in place, all it takes is a change in will of who controls it.
- selfhoster11 6y agoThis is precisely my objection to anyone who suggests such things are put in place. The Stasi would have simply loved to just inherit an all-pervasive, comprehensive surveillance system from a more peaceful predecessor.
- Jiejeing 6y ago> We need to embrace it and make sure it's used properly This has never worked, period.
- mellavora 6y agoExcept if the embrace is a death-embrace in which you carry the technology with you to the netherworld, leaving none of it behind... and 'used properly' means 'utterly destroyed'
- zthrowaway 6y agoThere’s a point where things can go too far. When we have machines violating our privacy and manipulating social expression (behaviors change when people know they are being watched and tracked), that’s a problem. In the end it’s corporations and governments doing this, why all of a sudden have we forgotten how most of the time they don’t have our best interest in mind and only greed and power?
- selfhoster11 6y ago> We're not talking about nuclear warheads here. No, we're not. Those damage the physical world. Facial recognition will damage something else in the long run - the society - which is just as dangerous.
- neartheplain 6y agoYou know what else damages society? Rape, murder, kidnapping, arson. Facial recognition software, used responsibly under a strict and throughly-audited regulatory scheme, can assist law enforcement in more quickly and reliably apprehending suspects in such cases. I see absolutely no reason why it shouldn’t be used, given the proper legal and regulatory framework.
- simion314 6y agoWhat are the benefits? The only thing I can think might be that for a shot while you can catch some criminals but as they learned to use gloves they will learn to use masks, After that what benefits are there for creating a database with everyone historical location?
- anticristi 6y agoWell, there you have it. It creates jobs in the high-end mask accessories industry.
- toyg 6y ago> but only for terrorism That little loophole right there would soon be big enough to let through a freight train.
- prox 6y agoExactly, the definition of terrorist is very malleable in the hands of despots.
- mtgx 6y ago> but only for terrorism You do realize that means scanning everyone to check if they are a known terrorist, yes? They said the same when they passed the Patriot Act - "We'll pass this to read the terrorists' emails." And everyone cheered, without realizing that means reading YOUR emails to see if YOU are a terrorist. They did this through all the taps into the ISPs and carriers' cables, considering email wasn't even encrypted between servers until very recently.
- tomcooks 6y agoIsn't terrorism specifically the reason behind the Patriot Act and all limitations that American citizens are suffering?
- selfhoster11 6y agoColour me skeptical. The USA pioneered such abusive innovations as perpetual copyright, pervasive hardware-level DRM and rootkits, and surveillance capitalism. I can't see protections against something as powerful as facial recognition coming from a society that didn't oppose similarly abusive tech.
- tzs 6y ago> The USA pioneered such abusive innovations as perpetual copyright The US change from a fixed 28 year term that could be renewed once to a life of author + 50 years term was done to match the minimum term allowed under the Berne Convention, which most of the world had already done decades before. In 1998 the US lengthened the term again, to life + 70 years. That one was to match Europe, which had made that change in 1993.
- anticristi 6y agoI like the popular myth more: Copyright in the US is prolonged as required to keep Mickey mouse away from the public domain. :)
- crocodiletears 6y agoI'm pretty sure the only way to block it is at the local level. There is no compelling incentive for the federal government to not support the expansion of facial recognition technologies. Our politicians might be convinced to introduce token pieces of legislation that can conveniently be voted down by the other side, and just enough of their fellow party members. But that's about it.
- snarf21 6y agoWho will watch the watchers? It isn't like there was no crime/terrorism before 1995. Look at how ex-AG Barr wanted backdoors in everything but they "promised" to only use it responsibly and with warrants. Do you sincerely believe that?
- cblconfederate 6y agoI still nod in disbelief when i see people unlocking with faceid. Apple may be privacy conscious, but they made face recognition cheap and ubiquitous. The pervasive use of face recognition should be considered a mark of a prison state, a country where people don't trust each other and it is only held together under the watchful eye of the prison guards.
- toyg 6y agoIt also makes it trivial to unlock your phone under coercion. Same for fingerprints. Whereas nobody can (yet) get a code out of your brain.
- mids_hn 6y agoThey can, however, still coerce you to give away your text-based password. I agree, though, that slicing one's finger off is simpler for all parties.
- La1n 6y agohttps://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- toyg 6y agoThe wrench can be resisted by determined individuals; whereas fingerprints and face-recog cannot.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoThe wrench does not represent physical torture, but metaphorical, basically representing a pressure point tailored to each individual.
- pessimizer 6y agoPeople resist torture all of the time. The problem with torture is that there's often little reason to think that the torture would end if you give up the password, other than the word of the torturer.
- notimetorelax 6y agoImagine a nightmare if this thing erroneously matches you with a criminal.
- brodock 6y agoIn italy...
- tomcooks 6y agoWhat about Italy? Are there more criminals in that country as opposed to other places?
- qsort 6y agoNo, as a matter of fact it's the opposite, Italy has relatively low violent crime levels. What Italy has, though, is very violent and abusive law enforcement, to the point where it's unbecoming of a first-world country. So I can definitely see how that would be a concern.
- MaheshC 6y agoAs an Italian constantly exposed to American videos showing clear irrational US based police brutality, I am not sure what you are talking about. Have you got any sources supporting these claims?
- Smithalicious 6y agoUS police brutality would be unbecoming of a third world country let alone the first world, but that doesn't say anything about Italy.
- qsort 6y agoI'm Italian as well, btw. Just off the top of my head: - 2001 raid on Armando Diaz. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Raid_on_Armando_Diaz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Raid_on_Armando_Diaz "The detainees were given few or no blankets, kept awake by guards, given little or no food and denied their statutory right to make phone calls and see a lawyer. They could hear crying and screaming from other cells. Police doctors at the facility also participated in the torture, using ritual humiliation, threats of rape and deprivation of water, food, sleep and medical care." None of the responsible parties served any time. - Way too many to count cold blooded murders of people in custody. The Aldrovandi, Cucchi and Magherini cases are emblematic as they at least got covered by the media. - Violence against minorities, for example: https://www.statewatch.org/media/documents/news/2009/mar/EveryOne%20-%20Report%20Police%20Violence%20in%20Italy_ENG.pdf https://www.statewatch.org/media/documents/news/2009/mar/Eve... - Illegal detentions, for example: https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2019-07-28/california-teen-italy-police-officer-stabbing-death-blindfolded https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2019-07-28/califo... - General lack of accountability and transparency. - Widespread abuse of power by intimidation. - Flat out lies, helped by crap media. I'll bet you $1,000 that on Dec 25, 2021, the news will report a variant of the following story: an elderly person called the police because they were lonely and wanted a friend to share a glass of spumante with.