13 ms·
> They’re investments, not really meant for living in. They cast these huge shadows and block views—really change the skyline—just so they can stand empty. Tha
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> They’re investments, not really meant for living in. They cast these huge shadows and block views—really change the skyline—just so they can stand empty.
That is definitely one of the saddest parts for me. These billionaires (many of whom got their wealth in shady circumstances) are just using these condos to park their money. I may think NFTs are insane but at least when people with too much money park their wealth there they don't fuck up an entire city.
- dionidium 6y agoCounterpoint: these buildings are gorgeous and only enhance the city. Whenever I’m on 57th St I crane my neck to stare at them as I walk. Often, I’ll just stop for a while to look up in awe. They haven’t ruined anything. Moreover, even if you disagree about their beauty, so what? People should be free to build things — even things you don’t personally like!
- hippira 6y agoWell you are free to do things but not at the cost of pollutions.
- dionidium 6y agoAttempts to equate 1) zoning that prevents buildings one doesn't like; and 2) zoning that prevents sources of pollution is a fairly tired false equivocation.
- HWR_14 6y agoIf you think that the buildings are ugly and damage the city, you'd be opposed to them. You like them so are not. As for "people should be free to build things", we decided over 100 years ago that wasn't the case. Not unrestrained by zoning laws and concern for the community.
- dionidium 6y ago> we decided over 100 years ago that wasn't the case. That was an enormous mistake. It's the source of our housing shortage in high-demand areas and it's probably costing us literally trillions of dollars. [0] > If you think that the buildings are ugly and damage the city, you'd be opposed to them. You like them so are not. This is what you believe, not what I believe. In fact, I think people should be free to build buildings I think are ugly. [0] https://ggwash.org/view/42946/zoning-the-hidden-trillion-dollar-tax https://ggwash.org/view/42946/zoning-the-hidden-trillion-dol...
- HWR_14 6y agoInteresting take, considering the article we are talking about discusses how billionaires are hiding assets overseas (well, from overseas relative to us) in our housing. Don't you think that's driving up pricing. Anyway, I disagree with your article's point of view. I don't think letting more people live in San Jose or NYC would unlock huge 10% improvements to GDP, and, even if it were, there's a value to being able to live in single family homes. If WFH is here to stay, then my suspicion is that NYC is going to continue suffering from its 2020 housing glut.
- dionidium 6y ago> there's a value to being able to live in single family homes Of course that's true. Again, my view is that people should be free to build whatever they want. Single-family zoning makes the alternatives illegal, not the other way around! Proponents of single-family zoning get a lot of mileage out of the implication that urbanists want to impose their way of living on everybody else, but the opposite is quite plainly the case. Only one side in this debate wants to encode their preferences in law.
- paxys 6y agoWhile I can't say about these specific buildings, I do agree that complaining about skyscrapers in New York seems weird. In general given enough time every eyesore becomes an iconic part of the city.
- busterarm 6y agoAs someone who has lived on 57th street for most of their life, it's not all roses. 57th street used to be a vibrant street full of a variety of businesses. Back in the 70s & 80s when the 40s and 50s of Manhattan were filled with street prostitution (on the west side) and brothels (on the east side, and they're still there), 57th street used to be where you started to get respectable looking buildings and shops to fill them. Now from end to end across Manhattan, most of 57th Street is becoming vacant in preparation for construction. The process is likely to take 20 or 30 years to complete, similar to what happened on 10th Avenue. There is more money to be made by letting buildings sit empty for years. 250 West 55th, at the cross street of 55th & 8th avenue, was an empty corner lot for 28 years while they waited for the rest of the buildings on the block to become vacant for teardown. Some areas are especially derelict -- between 5th and 6th Avenue in particular. It's an absolute eyesore and source of daily construction noise and will likely be so for the rest of my natural life. This has ruined my neighborhood.
- practicalpants 6y agoWealthy people minus a few eccentrics are most certainly not parking their money in NFTs. The crazy $69MM Beeple headline was actually a purchase by an NFT related company from what I understand. Not withstanding unoccupied real estate investments are a problem in every major city. It's usually wealthy foreign investors living far away in particular...e.g. Russia -> London, China -> Singapore/Vancouver, etc. really seems like non-occupied real estate purchases by foreign capital ought to be restricted a bit legally
- twelvechairs 6y agoThe simplest answer is land value tax
- skybrian 6y agoExcept that’s explicitly discouraging vacant lots and encouraging tall buildings. These owners can afford the tax better than anyone.
- ivalm 6y agoBut I do want to discourage vacant lots and encourage tall buildings, that’s seems the feature. We have only so much land and a large amount of people who want to live on it, increased density is the solution.
- austhrow743 6y agoIf they can afford the tax that's fine. At least then the inhabitants of the city get value out of the empty apartment buildings. Hell, it can be used to build other apartment buildings that aren't empty.
- pydry 6y agoLVT turns an asset into a liability. The fact that they can afford it isn't the point. They won't want to afford it if it's a liability unless they live in it or can rent it out. Meanwhile city coffers fill up with cash that can be used to build social housing. The only downside to LVT on non primary residences is the epic political fight it would require against the super rich.
- peteretep 6y ago> many of whom got their wealth in shady circumstances Like inheriting it, which is the shadiest of shady ways to make money
- LimaBearz 6y agoI can’t tell if that’s sarcasm or not so I’ll just remind everyone of Adam Smith: "A power to dispose of estates for ever is manifestly absurd. The earth and the fulness of it belongs to every generation, and the preceding one can have no right to bind it up from posterity. Such extension of property is quite unnatural." In this country there was a time yes where inheriting it is shady and it’s something I fear our conservative brothers have forgotten. The problems of multi-generational wealth were clearly visible to our founders looking at Europe. It should be patently offensive to all Americans
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- theonething 6y agoI don't get it. What business is it of ours if a wealthy person passes their wealth to their progeny?
- alpha_squared 6y agoWealth is finite, despite how much some like to claim it's not zero-sum. Not everyone can be wealthy, so by definition there will be those who aren't. Inherited wealth allows the inheritors to start further along in wealth accumulation and widens the gap between the wealthy and those who aren't. That then locks up wealth into the hands of fewer and fewer people.
- koonsolo 6y agoI feel sad for you that you think people cannot create something from nothing. So if you gain something, does that means somebody else needs to lose? Is that how people justify stealing or scamming? Or is that how they cope with their envy that rich people must be stealing or scamming. I once knew a person that had this theory about happiness. If someone is happy, someone else needs to be sad. I feel sad for anyone who has this mindset. It's way nicer on our side, where we do win-win deals, and know to be happy, the people around us need to be happy.
- cheriot 6y agoWell, if you want to ruin their investment then issue building permits for more of them. > They cast these huge shadows and block views Talk about first world problems. Expecting a city skyline to never change is ridiculous. The only problem is that so few people use these buildings. The best kind of density regulation requires _more_ density.
- heterodoxxed 6y agoThe insane height of these building is far beyond the argument for vertical density, though.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYeah I think 10-12 floors is plenty and still "climbable"
- mc32 6y agoNot even. plenty of first-world cities expect skyline changes. This attitude toward change (anti-change) comes from SF and has migrated elsewhere. NYC was the antithesis to this attitude but apparently it's not immune to this line of thinking. It's like they think mountains do not move. Rivers always run the same course. It's comical and tragic.
- ZoomerCretin 6y ago> This attitude toward change (anti-change) comes from SF and has migrated elsewhere. NYC was the antithesis to this attitude but apparently it's not immune to this line of thinking. NYC created the world's first zoning laws in response to a building casting shadows: https://www1.nyc.gov/site/planning/zoning/background.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/planning/zoning/background.page
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis was back from an era where the main contributors to disease were thought to be lack of air and light. The zoning described was actually quite generous by modern standards; you could technically build as much as you wanted as long as it fit the prescribed cake tier shape, and you could build theoretically unlimited height on a certain portion, I believe the center quarter of the lot. There is no city in the US today where you could build something as tall as the Empire State Building as of right; and yet the older regulations allowed that.
- zadler 6y ago> NFTs are insane With any luck, NFTs and crypto in general might reduce this kind of investment in property. They might turn out to be a better place to park excess cash.
- knocte 6y agoI think NFTs are great because they move money from the hands of the stupid&rich to the hands of artists.
- dorkwood 6y agoMost artists do not sell their NFTs, and are instead stuck with the fees they paid to mint them. "These numbers do not show the democratization of wealth thanks to a technological revolution. They show an acutely minuscule number of artists making a vast amount of wealth off a small number of sales while the majority of artists are being sold a dream of immense profit that is horrifically exaggerated." [0] [0]: https://thatkimparker.medium.com/most-artists-are-not-making-money-off-nfts-and-here-are-some-graphs-to-prove-it-c65718d4a1b8 https://thatkimparker.medium.com/most-artists-are-not-making...
- astoor 6y ago> I think NFTs are great because they move money from the hands of the stupid&rich to the hands of artists. There are 15 million items offered for sale on OpenSea, for example, and each one of those will have cost the artist $50-100 in fees to list. Almost all of those will either fail to sell, or will sell at a loss to the artist. So, although the crypto-rich want you to believe you're democratising finance or sticking up for the little people against "the elite" or however they phrase it, the reality is the exact opposite of what you describe, i.e. NFTs are moving money from the hands of the artists to the crypto-rich.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoNo, not really. Most artists aren't going to sell, in no small part because there are a LOT of artists out there in the world and because selling art is Hard. I've met plenty of folks that spend more time selling art and being social enough to sell art than they spend actually making that art. And this is just the average seller: Few can actually make it a career. Money, connections, luck, and a lot of social labor are pretty well required to get your art selling at higher prices, and might get rich folks to buy your stuff.
- 3finmunchousen 6y agoVacancy tax
- jcampbell1 6y agoI’d be fine with $50 million dollar apartments if the owners paid 1% per year in real estate taxes, but in NYC the law is ridiculous and based on equivalent rent and there are no equivalent rentals. Taxes on a $50 million dollar condo are about $50k per year rather than $500k.
- dmurray 6y agoI don't get the "billionaires buy property and leave it vacant, because it's more valuable as an investment" trope. Billionaires like to make money with their money. Sure, property prices increase, but rents are significant. If you can make 5% a year from your real estate appreciating, you can make 10% by renting it out. That's the difference between a mediocre yearly return and a fantastic one. Maybe at the absolute top end, there isn't enough rental demand, eg the $90m apartment mentioned may not fetch $400k/month in rent. But I hear the same argument for middle-class apartments in moderately expensive cities: rich people buy $600k apartments in Dublin, Vancouver, Sydney, but turn down $2500/month in rental income even in red hot rental markets. I don't buy it, though I don't have a clear alternative explanation.
- MathYouF 6y agoWhy don't you rent out your car on Turo when you're not using it, or resell your items when you're done with them rather than throw them away? I suspect, for the car example at least, it's for similar reasons. The liability of damage and hassle of managing a tenant is greater than the potential upside of rent for them.
- wcfields 6y agoIf the property is to park money and with US real estate you can liquidate it very quickly for a cash sale, a tenant will throw a huge wrench in that. A tenant in a single unit/house will easily drop the price by 10% or more from my experience trying to buy a single family home in SoCal in 2016. As well, who can afford to rent these units? The mortgage/break-even point for for a $8mil value would be $37,825 a month.
- tekkk 6y agoWhen you have billions of money, do you have really have that much drive to optimize your properties which might be nice to keep as occasional holiday homes? Sure you'd think that "ooh, 5% more income on my properties" would motivate them to rent their properties out but they might be perfectly happy just living off their other investments and not giving a damn about such tedious optimizations.
- knolax 6y ago> they don't fuck up an entire city Skyscrapers fuck up a city how???? Do you expect Manhattan to consist entirely of 2 story suburban homes? It's attitudes like yours that are the reason the streets are full of so many homeless.
- blamazon 6y agoEmpty skyscrapers fuck up the city. I expect manhattan to be full of skyscrapers, I don’t expect it to be soulless and lifeless.
- cblconfederate 6y agoTBH they are not very big, in fact rather tiny for luxury homes, so let them have it at the highest price possible. If your idea of high life is a 3 meters greenhouse without even a garden, fine.
- carpedimebagjoe 6y agoPost, physical NFTs that could keep homeless people from freezing to death.
- richardfey 6y agoIf you like this topic I recommend this talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Em7nqDqQ8oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Em7nqDqQ8oM It has a great explanation of the difference between complex and complicated, and the fragility of our systems compared to nature's ones.