10 ms·
Google is saving $1 billion per year because of COVID-19, not because employees are working from home. This is literally mentioned in the article, but the headl
by paxys 6y ago
Google is saving $1 billion per year because of COVID-19, not because employees are working from home. This is literally mentioned in the article, but the headline is twisted (for clicks no doubt):
> During the first quarter, Google parent Alphabet Inc. saved $268 million in expenses from company promotions, travel and entertainment, compared with the same period a year earlier, “primarily as a result of COVID-19,” according to a company filing.
Even if they hypothetically continue the WFH setting for all employees indefinitely, other costs will still creep back up once the world starts getting back to normal. They will still hold conferences (and send employees to conferences). Team events and corporate retreats will still happen. Launches won't be digital-only. Advertising will pick back up. None of this is related to whether employees are at their desks in the office or not.
- aabhay 6y agoWhat about office perks, maintenance of space, renovation, staff, commuter credits, office events, snacks, lunches, dinner, equipment, secretaries, and security?
- lamontcg 6y agoThey've been paying rent on their offices the whole time. If they went permanent WFH they could sell/lease those spaces and probably save billions. Not to mention the cost all the employees have to endure for traveling to work, wear on vehicles, gas, repairs, collisions, insurance, medical payouts due to car accidents, etc. Plus just generally the externalities of higher carbon emissions.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis assumes the presence of enough office demand to replace a Google sized company in the markets they lease in. It’s not clear that this is true. US vacancies are projected to be 19.4% nationally. On top of that, there isn’t exactly another Google-sized employer waiting in the wings over in Mountain View.
- thorwasdfasdf 6y agoWith re-zoning this won't be a problem. Just rezone it to residential. or residential/commercial.
- astrange 6y agoThere's nothing Mountain View wants to do less than let anyone live there. Also, because of Prop 13 those people wouldn't be paying property tax in 10 years, much like how everyone living there now isn't paying any, so Google is paying for everyone's schools and sewer systems as is.
- gabrielsroka 6y ago> because of Prop 13 those people wouldn't be paying property tax in 10 years I'm not sure what you mean. Prop 13 just caps the annual increase at 2%. I've lived in California and owned property here for 30 years. I pay property taxes.
- bseidensticker 6y agoIf the annual increase is capped at 2% and inflation is >2% then the value reaped by property tax will eventually go to 0. Similar to how if you rent the same place for long enough and it's rent controlled your rent effectively gets cheaper even though it's going up.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoand if inflation is under 2% and the city always increases by the maximum of 2%, then eventually the value of the property tax paid will be infinite, right? How is that analysis useful?
- adrianN 6y agoIf you make property tax a fixed percentage of the value of the property, it automatically adjusts with inflation.
- jwogrady 6y agoOnce an employee has built a report with their team, knows their roll, is fully trained, properly equipped, and demonstrates proficiency at their job..... then I'm cool letting staff work from home. I suspect Google has the leadership, supervision, and infrastructure to do all those things at a large scale. Unfortunately for my crew I find brining everyone in is waaaaay more efficient....carbon emissions aside.
- akomtu 6y agoOf course, who cares about carbon emissions when profits are at stake.
- jwogrady 6y agoAmen.
- snovv_crash 6y agoIf you completely ignore profits you go out of business and then the only companies left are the ones who ignore carbon. Better to get this changed at a legislative level to keep the playing field equal.
- jlund-molfese 6y agoThat's a model I'd be interested in working under. It's different for everyone, but I find onboarding most efficient in person, and long-term work most enjoyable fully remote.
- LordAtlas 6y ago> Once an employee has built a report with their team, knows their roll Did you mean "rapport" and "role"? Because that sentence was a bit confusing.
- pferde 6y agoAlso, "brining everyone in"? They are all going to be very salty after that... :)
- akomtu 6y agoThis is actually the biggest proof that the big players, including the gov, don't take co2 emissions seriously. If JP Morgan's Dimon is bragging about how he'll pull employees back to offices and the WH pretends to look the other way, it's safe to assume they don't give two shits about the carbon whatever. Real estate prices is what really matters to them.
- rangoon626 6y agoYeah. It’s totally fine to ask everyone to stop eating meat, but millions of Americans running their cars to/from the office everyday? Not a peep. Our politicians and business class are wholly unserious about this as they were about COVID-19.
- waterhouse 6y agoThe claim is usually that people are more productive in the office. Assuming that's true, then what's actually more expensive: having existing employees commute, or employing, say, 10% more people? Even if you only care about carbon costs, what are the carbon costs of raising, educating, training, and giving healthcare and everything else to 10% more people?
- throwaway2037 6y agoIf you read his comments closely, he was specifically talking about investment bankers. He talked about how it was hard to train junior bankers on deal making if not face-to-face. I think he used the term "apprenticeship". Even in the era of unlimited voice calls, emails, and video calls, as I understand, most M&A and IPO deals are still done face-to-face. For the investment bank, many of the employees work in New York City and use a train (or bus) to commute. That is pretty low carbon intensity.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoThe same "apprenticeship" also applies to tech companies.
- megablast 6y ago> If they went permanent WFH they could sell/lease those spaces and probably save billions. To whom? Everybody is moving to work from home.
- throwawayboise 6y agoDoes it matter? Even if they have to sell or sublease at a loss, it's better than paying rent on empty buildings.
- EvilEy3 6y agoHow much cost they will endure when their employees start getting insane from all the zoom meetings and working with a monitor instead of a real person?
- jjav 6y ago> working with a monitor instead of a real person Pre and post pandemic I'm still communicating with coworkers via email and slack, on the monitor. No difference at all. Well, one difference is I used be able to hear them munch on their snacks a couple cubicles over, but I can do without that part. Also, erasing the two hour commute, total win.
- LightG 6y agoWe both win with WFH. I have a co-worker (generally a lovely person) who is about ready to explode when she hears someone crunching on an apple. WFH, I can now eat an apple without self-consciously slow-crunching.
- derekdahmer 6y agoI used to work in event tech and can confirm the annual event marketing budgets just for one product at Google is in the $XX millions. Multiply that by all their departments and it could easily be 100s of millions that google spends on conferences every year.
- seoaeu 6y agoLike one expense they saved on is sending out recruiters and engineers to likely thousands of career fairs, recruiting sessions, etc. Nobody would reasonably argue that skipping all of them is a sustainable strategy long term even if it hasn't hurt them much so far.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fukmbas 6y agoRecruiting is a total waste
- Guest42 6y agoWith the amount of resumes they get, I'd question how important it is for tier 1 companies. I have gone to career fairs and learned a great deal about companies I had never heard of, but it seems as though Google would just receive thousands of applications per opening and approach it algorithmically anyways. Although I've had contacts get poached via LinkedIn or given challenges from Googling certain tech topics.
- paxys 6y agoIt helps because they can also do the initial screening round with basically the entire graduating CS class in-person at the university.
- Guest42 6y agoThat is practical. Wouldn’t have thought of that.
- quantumsequoia 6y agoGoogle is one of the most sought after companies, but this is due to them actively advertising Google as a great place to work. Actually talking to someone who works at Google makes it more real and attainable in candidates minds and reinforces Google as a desirable place to work If Google were to stop attending, they risk newer generations of engineers shifting their perspective on Google, especially these days when most portrayals of Google in the media are negative. The point of Google attending these events isn't for recruiting. It's to advertise their brand to job seekers. Seeing a bunch of candidates flocking to the Google recruiters triggers FOMO is candidates who might not have been as enthusiastic
- mandeepj 6y agoIt means all the consulting companies are also going to report better than expected results; no travels, food etc expenses. Clients don’t always reimburse that.
- ghaff 6y agoIn general, the pandemic has not been great for services businesses.
- yalogin 6y agoI guess it will go up a little, but I am willing to bet that a bunch of the cases you mentioned where they had to send people around are now done online. I will be really shocked if the google IO is not an online conference going forward.
- ghaff 6y ago>I will be really shocked if the google IO is not an online conference going forward. I would be very surprised. I'm connected to the tech events space and the widespread assumption is that events will go back to physical while maintaining a strong online component going forward to continue to reach more people.
- squaredisk 6y agoIf Google saved that much money and the business didn't see a considerable negative impact (34% increase? Quite the opposite in fact.), then that news should be telling not just for Google, but for every company that previously catered to spoiled employees who jump on an airplane just to have lunch with the customer. Two lies COVID has forcibly flushed out and helped dispel: Lie #1: Remote work, cannot work. Lie #2: Business travel, is a necessity. It will be interesting to see how the corporate travel whores, spin this post-COVID in order to keep their Triple Diamond Medallion Platinum status.
- noja 6y agoYour "lies" are missing the "outside of a pandemic" qualifier.
- etripe 6y agoWhat are your reasons for assuming business travel is a necessity outside a pandemic? Why do you think remote work is only feasible during a pandemic?
- jsjohnst 6y ago> Why do you think remote work is only feasible during a pandemic? Remote work was feasible in part during a pandemic because it had to be. When everyone is 100% remote, things aren’t bad. If companies don’t do anything to preserve that culture from during pandemic times, when folks start returning to the office again, remote work will very likely go back to sucking. Being remote you’ll very likely be the odd person out on meetings desperately trying to hear what was said and/or struggle to get a word in with everyone else jammed in a conference room.
- ghaff 6y agoA number of teams in my group have long had a rule that if anyone on a call is remote, everyone needs to do the call from their own computer. I agree that the odd person out being remote is often a problem but distributed teams generally can adopt effective practices. If your company doesn't? Well, there are other companies that are going to be more effective.
- amelius 6y agoAlso, people might work differently, as there will be different distractions in a post covid world.
- greggman3 6y agoIt's also not counting any repercussions, short or long term. I don't know Google but several other friends have told me productivity is down at their companies significantly with WFH. Also, if it's just about the perks mentioned, those perks might be part of what retains employees.
- Trollmann 6y agoInteresting, what position are the people in that told you this? I‘ve only heard this from middle management at my company. Software project‘s actually have less delay than usual. Don‘t get me started on why every project is ‚late‘. We‘re not even allowed to work overtime while we‘re at home. We do see problem‘s with new hires though. They have a harder time integrating into their team.