11 ms·
This article seems to make fantastic jumps from the believable -- mortality from overall air pollution (e.g. in Delhi) to the frankly unbelievable -- your ultra
by crazygringo 6y ago
This article seems to make fantastic jumps from the believable -- mortality from overall air pollution (e.g. in Delhi) to the frankly unbelievable -- your ultrasonic humidifier supposedly reducing your life by nearly an hour each night, or that a daily commute between Newark and NYC takes half a year off your life.
According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening.
Similarly, it seems impossible to believe that the minerals in the air from humidifiers are equivalently dangerous to factory pollution or cigarette smoke. Different categories of particles are going to affect the body differently, no? I mean, our body requires minerals -- we're drinking them in our water all day long -- while certain factories may be belching out straight-up poison.
These statistics are just not passing the smell test. They seem to be extrapolations of extrapolations of extrapolations. This article's conclusions don't seem even remotely convincing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- erosenbe0 6y agoStatistical evidence for high BMI's effect on quality of life and morbidity is more compelling, at least in the developed world. Author's thesis does stand insofar as AQ often being overlooked as a causative agent behind cardiovascular disease.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoBMI is known as a very bad measure
- sharken 6y agoSo what is a better measure ?
- vehemenz 6y agoWaistline to height ratio measures unhealthy weight better than BMI.
- maccard 6y agoFor anyone who isn't a bodybuilder and is between 5'0 and 6'3 BMI is a pretty damn good estimate.
- Symmetry 6y agoUse height to the 2.5th power as the denominator rather than height squared.
- goodpoint 6y agoBFP is the real deal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_fat_percentage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_fat_percentage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#Limitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#Limitations (however the statistics on BMI vs mortality as still completely valid)
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoGreat now let's figure out how to measure BFP across the entire population the way we can with BMI. Every guide i've seen either uses expensive displacement equipment or trained professionals with calipers. That doesn't scale nearly as well as a height / weight calculation
- goodpoint 6y ago> Great now let's figure out how to measure BFP across the entire population the way we can with BMI I never said that. I said the opposite.
- blunte 6y agoBMI is a fairly decent measure for folks who don't work out or otherwise build excess muscle. And since that's _most_ Americans, BMI is a good starting point to use when judging health fitness.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Tenoke 6y agoBMI is known to be a bad measure for outliers (e.g. bodybuilders) and just a ballpark rather than exact but for most people there's a pretty decent correlation between BMI and body fat percentage or whatever you prefer.
- lm28469 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening. I don't think you're being honest here, it obviously isn't try to make the point that each commute = 1 year, that's why it's in the "lifestyle" category and not in the "single event" one
- KMag 6y ago> it obviously isn't try to make the point that each commute = 1 year They aren't saying one commute takes a year off the life. They're saying that people who's job is riding the public commute infrastructure spend roughly 20 times as much time breathing the air in the commuter infrastructure as people who commute to/from work, so if the effect is linear... that's roughly a 10 year reduction in lifespan. Or, are you trying to say that some underlying common factor between commuting and home/office air quality is present, and so the commute is just a proxy for that common factor? If that's the case, if that common factor is identifiable, it should be named. If that common factor isn't identifiable, how are we confident in attributing it to air quality? Or, are you claiming that the air quality in the commute infrastructure is the culprit, but the effect is dramatically sublinear?
- WillPostForFood 6y agoExtinguish candles with a lid. If you are worrying about the method by which you extinguish a candle, worrying is what's going to shorten your life, not the candle.
- drivebycomment 6y agoThank you. That is such a great one liner that I wrote this down in my quote collection.
- tda 6y agoI have a cheap pm10 meter and ran it continuously for a few weeks. Next too cooking meat the other activity that stood out was blowing out the birthday candles. The pm10 rose to 300 and only was backs to healthy levels (below 50) several hours later. I was as surprised as you are. Next time I'll definitely open a window
- coddle-hark 6y agoHow often do you blow out birthday candles?
- vinw 6y agoAt least once a year
- kenniskrag 6y agoYou're lucky not born on 29th February.
- uCantCauseUCant 6y agoEvery day when you are poor on this planet..
- HPsquared 6y agoNot all particles are equally toxic. If I had to guess, the smoke from a recently-extinguished candle is probably condensed wax vapor rather than PAHs and heavy metals.
- ac29 6y ago> or that a daily commute between Newark and NYC takes half a year off your life. As compared to an "average" US city taking off a quarter-year. I think the commuting thing is a red herring, and they just mean living/working in the NYC metro area, which as a densely populated area likely has slightly worse air than an average US location.
- globular-toast 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening. Why is this obvious?
- kgwgk 6y agoBecause you would see all the time commercials on tv letting you know that if you, or a late loved one, worked in the subway you may be entitled to financial compensation.
- airhead969 6y agoNo. Just no. That's not how science works.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoNot unless data has first been collected and analyzed. There was a long period of time between people suspecting cigarettes were unhealthy and actual data showing it
- dheera 6y agoI put together a monster air quality monitor with just about every sensor I could cram into it. Dust sensors, geiger counters, the whole works. One of the biggest problems I found was indoor CO2 levels. High CO2 levels (much less than dangerous CO2 levels) make you groggy, sleepy, and can induce headaches. I now get notifications to open my windows when CO2 levels pass a certain threshold. https://dheera.net/projects/airmonitor/ https://dheera.net/projects/airmonitor/
- sharken 6y agoHaving good data is the first step towards making a change. I like that the air quality monitor enables you to figure out how much the window has to be opened and also when. That's far more useful than the blanket advice of opening windows daily.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoIs it possible to buy one of these from you?
- tim333 6y ago>or that a daily commute between Newark and NYC takes half a year off your life. >According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? I don't think that's what they mean. I think it's a lifetime NYC commuter on average should live half a year less than someone out in the country.
- O_H_E 6y agoI agree with what you are saying, but there is just a small technicality I'd like to correct. > ...I mean, our body requires minerals -- we're drinking them in our water all day long Regardless of the minerals in question here, route-of-delivery is a big deal in toxicology, so the line of thinking here is a bit flawed.
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoI think the particular bit about the subway may be informed by very recent news that the air pollution in the New York subway stations is far in excess of what anyone had inspected. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/feb/10/subway-air-pollution-new-york-washington-dc https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/feb/10/subway-a... As for actual subway workers… I mean it’s not exactly a coal mine, but I would be pretty surprised if their mortality wasn’t at least somewhat measurably lower than, say, that of shepherds.
- ehnto 6y agoJust to point out how why this is a fairly nuanced topic, a shepherd may be breathing clean air but they're also exposed to UV radiation all day. They may have a higher morbidity due to increased skin cancer rates.
- darkwater 6y agoI'm no way an expert on the matter but by pure logic it's still amazes me how we survived (and evolved!) as a species for thousand of years without almost no shelter from direct sunlight and yet now (too much) sunlight exposure is seen as a cause of death. I know we lost almost all the body hair we used to have but still, we usually wear clothes when under the sun.
- saiya-jin 6y agoShepherds (like all folks) wear and wore clothes, long sleeves and often hats also in the summer. Also if skin is exposed to sun regularly, often, its much less sensitive compared to usual office worker seeing almost no sunlight and then having 2 weeks of mega exposure and sunburns on vacation.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThe last time I looked in to this, enough sun exposure to tan is also enough sun exposure for folk of northern European discent to badly increase skin cancer risks. This is why tanning studios have been banned in Australia.
- staticelf 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening. Are you sure this isn't happening? I could easily imagine people working in dusty places for example dying earlier due to health related issues that could be traced back to the lifestyle.
- modeless 6y agoYeah, it is not at all obvious to me that this isn't happening. Is anyone even collecting the data you would need to tell whether or not it's happening? I'm sure the transit authorities would rather not know.
- guerrilla 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening. We know this?
- raverbashing 6y agoOh I read their allegedly "humidifiers kill" snippet, so tl;dr: > but ultrasonic humidifiers produce huge numbers of particles. They turn any minerals in the water become airborne particles. got the following steady-state increases over background levels. > Mineral water: ~265 > Tap water (Seoul): ~260 > Purified water: ~50 > Distilled water: ~0 So what you mean is that if I follow the instructions on the manual and use distilled (or at least purified water) for mineral and biological reasons, the issue is smaller to non-existent?
- xaduha 6y agoGet a TDS meter and measure PPM in your water. Reverse osmosis filtered water will do, just activated carbon filtered water will not.
- airhead969 6y agoYou can't readily buy DI water, but you can buy distilled water. The two are entirely different purity levels.
- xaduha 6y agoReverse osmosis filtered water is mainly what I have in mind, companies sell that. 6-14 PPM is what I measured personally and I think it falls into this category.
- airhead969 6y agoThat's some crappy RO water. My home system takes 45 ppm water and reduces it to <2 ppm (~500 kΩ). For all intents and purposes, it's not conductive on its own. Distilled water is made by steam condensation, and nearly ultra-pure but still contains dissolved gases. DI water should be made from some distilled water to be the highest possible purity, but it's usually made from RO or simply filtered tap water. There are some things DI can do that steam distillation can't, and vice-versa. The two processes are entirely different and NOT interchangeable.
- saiya-jin 6y agoAs for humidifiers, specifically ultrasonic ones - we bought one for our baby, but immediately with it also the best water purifier we could find (Zero water) that produces demineralized water practically absent from other molecules than H2O. There is no dust the next morning on the floor (or anywhere), there is no buildup of calc in the machine. I do believe that breathing that fine dust isn't very healthy long term, but that article outright lies about using it = taking 50 minutes out of every 1440 minutes of everybody's lives. We would see this effect in dusty (ie Saharan) regions already, there are hundreds of millions of people living in those conditions. What is dust if not small particles of stones and organic compounds flying around.
- goodpoint 6y ago> produces demineralized water practically absent from other molecules This is plain false.
- arisAlexis 6y agodo you know of mortality statistics specifically for subway workers? Because it may very well surprise you and it can't be grounds for dismissing the hypothesis.
- londons_explore 6y ago> anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? From my ad-hoc survey of subway driver friends, this seems about true... Most die in their late 60's in a country where most people make it to 70/80. Obviously the fact their job involves sitting in a chair all day doesn't help things...
- Gravityloss 6y agoIs there a fundamental reason why the subway must be like that? I assume it's not as bad in say Hong Kong? Copenhagen metro for example is automated and there's a wall and automatic doors separating the tracks from the platform. I assume it's quite clean.
- londons_explore 6y agoSubways are dusty because they use mechanical brakes that produce metal dust particles. For $50 per carriage, dust collecting sponges, fans or filters could be fitted, but train companies don't care. By doing anything about the dust they might be opening themselves up to lawsuits claiming they didn't do enough about a risk they knew about... There are also political issues - often the train company bought the trains 50 years ago and will pay extortionate prices to the original manufacturer for any modifications, and if they make modifications themselves the manufacturer will drop all support. Many modern trains are starting to have electric braking, and that produces far less dust.
- krrrh 6y agoYou say “train companies” as if every major subway/metro outside of Japan wasn’t nationalized in the early 20th century.
- londons_explore 6y agoSame applies even moreso when it's government run...
- 6y ago
- stared 6y agoWhen it comes to ultrasonic humidifiers, they do generate a lot of PM 2.5, see: https://blog.getawair.com/awair-investigates-how-your-humidifiers-water-affects-your-health https://blog.getawair.com/awair-investigates-how-your-humidi... It is NOT certain that these particles are as bad as ones from dust or combustion. All in all, when small droplets evaporate, what remains is water-soluble salts, rather than anything more reactive or harder to remove, see https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3922954/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3922954/ as mentioned in https://learn.kaiterra.com/en/air-academy/humidifiers-cause-poor-air-quality https://learn.kaiterra.com/en/air-academy/humidifiers-cause-...: "In a study on mice, researchers discovered that inhaling the dust from ultrasonic purifiers produces a cellular response, but this response lacks the inflammation and damage associated with other forms of particulate matter." Myself, I got shocked when my air purifier suddenly started showing a huge amount of pollution (and yes, my eyes turned red). Only afterwards, I checked it was exactly because of my freshly-bought ultrasonic air purifier. Now I have an evaporative one - not as fast, not as spectacular, but better.
- xaduha 6y agoThat's why you gotta use them with reverse osmosis filtered water. And not one that remineralizes, you can do that later on your own. I have a ultrasonic humidifier, reverse osmosis water filter and air quality sensor, it's all good.
- homero 6y agoI use distilled water
- shlant 6y agois there a downside to just using an evaporative humidifier?
- scythe 6y agoThe power draw at the humidifier will be larger, but the net power cost is about the same assuming a constant indoor air temperature. I always use filtered water for the US humidifier, but I'm reconsidering it now.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoAnd in NYC and the US in general having better health care especially for poorer workers will have much more of an effect.
- airhead969 6y agoCompletely untrue. The US spends the most per capita and gets worse outcomes than other countries. This fact was even highlighted in Michael Moore's Where To Invade Next?
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoI said "Better" not throw more $ at the current omnishambles
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoWorse than many countries, but certainly not worse than India or Indonesia that the US was being compared to in this article.
- G3rn0ti 6y ago> These statistics are just not passing the smell test. These numbers are derived from estimations, for sure. But they are sophisticated estimations and serve to rank other health risks in life. In rich countries we usually obsesses about things like pesticides in food or „small particulate matter“ to an extent that it is absurd. Air quality is a real threat in many countries but not anymore in the US or most of Europe for sure. As the article shows obesity is the killer number 1 in the US. A healthy diet is something which is totally under our control. And for sure smoke generated at a BBQ for example is not very healthy and can be avoided by using a gas grill. These are things usually ignored and thus underestimated in our health obsession.
- splithalf 6y ago“Air quality is a real threat in many countries but not anymore in the US” Couldn’t be more wrong. As the author casually admits, we know nothing without experiments. End of story. What makes your statement so wrong is that it takes decades for the consequences to show up, if they are measurable at all, in non experimental studies. That is exactly the same reason that cigarettes were considered safe for so long. Health consequences take decades to show up and without experiments all we get are loose correlations. Air quality in many places in America is getting worse, the size of the population in these areas is massive. To declare to potential health consequences 60 years in the future without any solid experimental evidence is the same as the doctors of the 50’s telling patients to smoke up, there’s no evidence cigarettes are bad. Exactly the same.
- G3rn0ti 6y ago> What makes your statement so wrong is that it takes decades for the consequences to show up, if they are measurable at all, in non experimental studies. So, you're telling me the air quality is getting worse despite this trend not being observed, yet? There is a logical fallacy somewhere. Furthermore, the link between lung cancer and cigarette smoking was well observed already in the 50s but the tobacco industry naturally downplayed the risks. BTW: It is an established fact that air quality in the cities of 19th century was way worse -- mainly due to the fact that people cooked and heated their places with open fires and coal. For some insight on the UK: https://theconversation.com/air-pollution-in-victorian-era-britain-its-effects-on-health-now-revealed-87208 https://theconversation.com/air-pollution-in-victorian-era-b...
- FridayoLeary 6y agoa bit off topic, but i can logically guarantee you that smoking takes at least 5 minutes off your life. It takes that long to smoke a cigarette... You have to put things into perspective, why should you care less about living now then in 40 years in the future? Chances are your quality of life will only get worse etc.
- airhead969 6y agoNot if smokers multitask, like making your contact cleaner solution in the factory or making your delivery food. IMO, all cigarettes should have cyanide added to them to reduce the costs to society by speeding-up the slow suicide and excess harm to others.
- FridayoLeary 6y agoshould all diesel cars have lead fumes pumped into the cockpit? Should all alcoholic drinks contain methanol?
- airhead969 6y agoFrivolous response. Diesel vehicles are extremely hazardous causing great harm to millions but go under regulated because of money. ICEs should die. Alcoholic drinks don't directly harm anyone else in their consumption and the QALY/micromorts involved are small. Do you have any other rude, unscientific arguments?
- beckingz 6y agono need to label other people's comments as rude. Also, the suggestion to make products more deadly so that they are used less seems like bad policy. Reduction of harms usually does not mean killing the patient.
- learnstats2 6y ago> Chances are your quality of life will only get worse etc. The quality of your end of life gets (on average) much worse if you smoke. Not only do you die 5 minutes earlier, but you also spend more additional time with disease impacting your quality of life, such as COPD.
- HPsquared 6y agoI wonder what the PM2.5 meter would say about fog or mist.
- learnstats2 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening. On the contrary, that sounds extremely credible. If you divide life expectancy stats just by gender and race, you already see more than 10 years difference.
- JW_00000 6y ago> According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Just two more nuances: 1) The article is measuring loss in "DALYs" = disability-adjusted life years. 10 DALYs lost may not mean dying 10 years earlier, but could also mean suffering from Alzheimer's for 16 years (Alzheimer's has a weight of 0.66 [1]), or any combination thereof (e.g. 10 years of Alzheimer's + dying 3.3 years earlier). 2) The cited number is for the "worst offender" on the NYC metro. The pollution levels on the London underground are less than a 10th of that. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disability-adjusted_life_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disability-adjusted_life_year
- MomoXenosaga 6y agoPeople are dying from air pollution it's just that we like to ignore it because what are you realistically going to do about it... Move to your villa in the countryside? Thankfully as a human being I'm perfectly able to ignore and suppress inconvenient information.
- jairofloress 6y ago"According to this logic, anyone who works in the subway should be dying, what, 10 years earlier? Which is obviously not happening." And you know this how?, Where YOUR numbers and conclusions come from?
- periheli0n 6y agoI find it hugely suspicious that huge claims are made but the methodology behind the numbers presented in the first figure is not explained at all. Further down, correlation plots are shown but no analysis of potential confounders that could affect life expectancy as well, like access to medical care, education, wealth.