10 ms·
What really drives the poor
- nowarninglabel 15y agoGood insights, though instead of biometric (?!) based money transfers, I'd like to see a further push on phone based transfers and other branchless banking. Recent research reported through CGAP shows branchless transfers being used increasingly by the poor, http://technology.cgap.org/2011/06/17/does-branchless-banking-reach-poor-people-the-evidence-from-india/ http://technology.cgap.org/2011/06/17/does-branchless-bankin... I was hoping they might discuss Microfinance's role in helping the poor reach their goals, since at kiva.org we tend to think of microloans as one of the small steps towards solving the problems they face.
- Vitaly 15y agoim getting some weird html on this url. the body is empty and its followed by a style/css tags with flash embedded in it. wtf?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- elmindreda 15y agoPoor people are human beings, so I assume it's the same things that drive other people.
- zem 15y agoit's amazing how few policymakers realise that. mostly, the poor tend to be infantilised and patronised.
- protomyth 15y agoTo be blunt, quite a few politicians really don't want changes to the current status because it would endanger their power-base. If you ran on an issue, it is helpful not to solve the issue and blame the other guy for not solving it. One example is bilingual education. There are very effective groups and lessons that can teach students English in a short amount of time, allowing the student to be in the same classrooms as everyone else. But if that student (or anyone else) doesn't speak the language of the majority, they are easier to control because they are not independent and need "special" programs. If they were bilingual, then they would have a better chance than 1 language people to get jobs and opportunities. More language = More options. Instead we get a lot of empty political rhetoric that keeps everything the same.
- omouse 15y agoNot only that, but there's money involved. How many billions are sent in foreign aid? Some of that money disappears due to corruption and who doesn't want some corruption happening ;p
- wccrawford 15y agoThey finally hit on the real story halfway down: "“Generally, it is clear that things that make life less boring are a priority for the poor,” they write in their new book." Yes, the poor spend their money unwisely when they have extra. That's the real reason. If a rich person finds themselves down on their luck, they knuckle down and work really hard to get into a situation where they can afford to buy luxuries. It isn't about lack of opportunity. It's about wise choices. I can't find the story now, but there was a fairly wealthy man who decided to give all that up and see if poor people could pull themselves up. He stowed his credit cards and cash and went to live on the street. He started at day-labor sites until his work ethic paid off and he got a steady job from someone. He had goals like an apartment, a car, etc, with a certain amount of cash in the bank. He gave himself 1 year. At 9 months, he had completed his goal, and a family member fell ill. He quite before the 1 year, but he had already completed his goals and was on his way to a good life. In other words, he spent his money wisely and was able to vastly improve his lifestyle in less than a year. But most poor people say it's impossible. Are they not trying? Are they trying, but making too many bad decisions?
- elmindreda 15y agoFor one thing, it makes a lot of difference whether or not you have a safety net when you're on a tightrope.
- burgerbrain 15y agoI'm not sure that analogy holds. I'll accept that in the literal case it does, since I can easily see how being nervous would effect physical coordination while walking on a tightrope, but I don't see how being nervous of failure would render you unable to work hard unskilled labor jobs or save money. On the contrary, I expect it would help by providing real motivation.
- elmindreda 15y agoI think what I meant was that being nervous about falling down most likely means you'll be walking a lot slower than the person with the safety net. If you only have what you need to survive, you're far less likely to take any chances with it. Working hard, despite much propaganda to the contrary, isn't a solution. I'm not even sure what it means in this context. Being poor is very hard work in and of itself, as taking care of the basic necessities of life takes a lot more time and effort when you can't use the expensive short cuts that middle-class people take for granted. When you're poor, everything takes longer, everything associated with money causes anxiety, the social stigma can prevent you from making useful connections, healthcare becomes more difficult to access, you have to spend time fixing or working around broken items, if you have a job you likely work longer and/or more uncomfortable hours, if you don't have a job there's the added stress and stigma from that, many government programs in reality become traps due to their desire to control poor people's lives, you cannot afford and/or do not have the time or energy left to make healthy food, etc. There are many, many other factors, many of which can be trivially seen to magnify other factors.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- paganel 15y agoI barely made it half-way through the article, it sounded like an United Colors of Benetton add adapted into a Nobel-winning Economics paper. Just a couple of gems that made me skip it: """ they may well be more driven by ideas, simply because they have less information about the world outside """ So, supposedly, us, the rich people, live in the "real" world, why them , the poors, live in a world from which they cannot see "outside". Ok, I got it. """ She would also read to us books on Mother Teresa, on African children, etc """ Mother Teresa and African children in the same sentence, what's this, "feel-good bingo for well-off people"? Also notice the "etc" after "African children", that's a first. And I could go on and on. In case anyone's curious (and before you start downvotting me), I'm furious about the condescending tone of this article because some time ago, when I was 15-16, my family went from middle-class status to poverty (meaning less per US$ 1 per day per person) in a very short time. I can still remember my mum, an engineer by training, going to the market place early in the morning to sell home-grown parsley. She gave me most of that money in order to pay for private math-lessons given by my high-school math teacher (that was the only way to get into CS school). I still try to help my parents as much as I can, but 10 years later they still rely mostly on subsistence agriculture. But, nevertheless, they're happy with it, that's their life, they have their small piece of land, they garden it, they live under the sun in fresh air and not in a God-forsaken cubicle with artificial lights, and my dad would look very strangely at these "rich", paper-writing people who think he's living in a "different", lesser world.
- felipemnoa 15y ago"that was the only way to get into CS school" Couldn't you just have gone into a community college and move on from there. It is a lot cheaper and lot of the professors are actually pretty good. If your grades are good you should be able to transfer into a decent 4 year college.
- lsc 15y agoIf his family is living on USD$1 per day, most likely he's not from a country that provides such services.
- Duff 15y ago
- chrismealy 15y agoMike Konczal: Here’s the normal story. Picture you are in a room with 10 people. Each of them has a slice of cake. How much you are willing to pay for a slice of the cake is the ‘marginal utility’ of having it, and the more cake you have the less any more cake is worth to you. You’d be willing to pay a $1 for the first slice of cake, but you’d only be will to pay 90 cents for the second slice. You’d only be willing to pay 10 cents for the 9th slice, and a penny for the 10th slice. Eating the 10th slice of cake in that room would probably make you sick, hence you want it a lot less than the first slice, which is delicious. That’s declining marginal utility. Now picture you are in a room with 10 people screaming. You hate it when people scream, and you can pay a person to get them to stop screaming. Would you pay in a similar way to the cake example? Would you pay a $1 to get the first person to stop screaming, and a penny for the 10th person to stop screaming? No. Getting one person to stop screaming would make very little difference in how much you dislike being in the room. Modern psychology tells us you might not even notice it. You’d probably only pay a penny to get that first guy to stop screaming. However getting the second guy to stop screaming might be worth 10 cents. And the last guy, the difference between some screaming and no screaming, might be worth the full dollar to you. The more quiet it got, the more a marginal difference in how quiet it is would be worth to you. There’s increasing returns to this good; the 10th guy not screaming is worth more than the first guy not screaming, which is the exact opposite dynamic of the 10th cake being less delicious than the first. -- http://rortybomb.wordpress.com/2009/12/03/persistence-of-poverty-and-increasing-marginal-utility/ http://rortybomb.wordpress.com/2009/12/03/persistence-of-pov...
- chrismealy 15y agoThe point is that solving one problem feels attainable, but having dozens of problems just makes you feel hopeless and resigned.
- Unseelie 15y agoThis is a brilliant example, but even after reading the article, I feel like it needs a stronger connection to the problems of poverty. So, anyway, Guys, the situation where you're in a room where people are screaming is poverty, but its only one moment of poverty. In poverty, you go into that room over and over and over again. You can't afford to keep your whole reality quiet, but you can buy a moment or two of peace, by paying more money than you can rightly afford to spend, if you've a longterm goal to support. You may go into debt for a TV to relieve the oppresive boredome, or spend change you shooldn't on a sweet, to eat something nice. Those breif respites are massively appealing, even though they don't last, and very possibly set you back, because remember, you're living in a situation where everyone is always screaming. A moment's peace is worth not making it out.
- known 15y agoAre Untouchables allowed to own/operate a restaurant in India? https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Untouchability https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Untouchabilit...
- omouse 15y ago“Generally, it is clear that things that make life less boring are a priority for the poor,” they write in their new book. “They don’t just need nutrition that will keep them alive longer—they also need a reason to want to live longer. Being healthier by denying yourself the little pleasures you can afford, a cup of tea or a bowl of steaming rice, makes little sense if you have nothing else to look forward to,” says Banerjee. “I think they make exactly the choices I would make in their place as regards food.” ...isn't that fucking obvious? You can extrapolate from our own rich society where people would rather spends thousands on electronics than on non-fast-food. Paying double for healthier food? Fuck no. Paying hundreds for an iPhone? Fuck yes.
- ttran08 15y agoI read the whole article, however, I didn't think it did a good job of getting to the bottom of everything that does matter. The article needed to give people a better sense of the situation of the poor, by providing more insights. Otherwise, people who've never experienced poverty would not understand why it's so important to help these people out. The best reporter on an issue like this is someone who actually made it out of poverty and is actively trying to help their own people.