8 ms·
The problem is that only a tiny percentage of harassers and rapists are ever convicted. The court -- rightly -- sets a very high bar to conviction, and police a
by jfengel 6y ago
The problem is that only a tiny percentage of harassers and rapists are ever convicted. The court -- rightly -- sets a very high bar to conviction, and police and prosecutors often won't even attempt it unless the evidence is overwhelming.
You're concerned that this is stacked against you, but the courts are stacked against the victims. So it doesn't really suffice to decry the one problem without addressing the other.
So perhaps you can see what it looks like to many women when you say, "Hey, I'm sorry this happened to you, but this bad thing happened to my brother, so _shrug_". Did your brother go to the courts and police to address these issues? It may been unlawful termination.
There is a large domain of behavior that is either nebulously legal or difficult to prosecute but which makes our communities much, much worse. It's counterproductive to tell the people victimized by that to stop talking about it. The solution is to go forward and find ways to set up our communities to protect people. And that can't mean just asking victims to accept that.
- chmod600 6y ago"The problem is that only a tiny percentage of harassers and rapists are ever convicted." How can that be known? Why do you presume that someone is a harasser or rapist if they weren't convicted?
- joshuamorton 6y agoBecause I know people who have been harassed and raped and whose harassers and rapists weren't punished. I know literally dozens of stories like that, and maybe a handful where the harasser or rapist was punished at all. Of those, even fewer where they were convicted of a crime. The majority of these cases the victim isn't public in their accusation, there's no argument that they're trying to gain something or hurt someone else. So by comparing the data that is presumably more honest, that people make in private, to that in public, we can assume that most instances of harassment go unpunished.
- throwaway0427 6y agoI'm one. I'm also male. It was brutal. No, I did not go to the police. I was far too afraid.
- lukasb 6y agoLess than 1% of rapes lead to felony convictions: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2018/10/06/less-than-percent-rapes-lead-felony-convictions-least-percent-victims-face-emotional-physical-consequences/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2018/10/06/less-than... Same article notes that between 2-8% of rape complaints are false. Worries about false rape claims are wildly overblown.
- ALittleLight 6y agoDoesn't your set of statistics show that rape accusations are 2-8 times as likely to be proven false as they are to be proven true?
- toast0 6y agoRape is hard to prove. If one party claims consent was obtained and the other that it wasn't, and there is no recording, it's going to be difficult to make a finding of fact based on the testimony of the two parties. In the absence of clear evidence of lack of consent, with no further evidence, I would expect most cases to result in a finding of not-guilty or not to ever result in a charge. Think about what evidence would it take for you to be convinced consent was absent, beyond a reasonable doubt; and how would you provide that evidence if you were a victim in the situation in the article. On the other hand, many false rape accusations are fabricated with completely made up details. Depending on the details, it can be easy to prove the accused (or the accuser) wasn't in the place claimed, or other details don't fit.
- ALittleLight 6y agoSure but the statistics, 1% of reported rapes lead to conviction and 2-8% are shown to be false, do not support the conclusion that false report of rape is not a big issue.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agoAnd yet you wouldn’t like to fall within those 2-8%.
- void_mint 6y agoDo you think that OJ was innocent? And if not, doesn't that imply you also agree (to an extent) that trials/law enforcement on heavily politicized cases have the potential to be totally mismanaged and end in injustice?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoOJ probably did it but the prosecution failed to prove him guilty so he walked free as he should. He's lucky he was a wealthy celebrity or he wouldn't have gotten the full protection that the courts supposedly afford to the accused.
- epicureanideal 6y ago> the courts are stacked against the victims Ah, that pesky presumption of innocence getting in the way of our 100% conviction rate. /s
- supercheetah 6y agoThat wasn't being disputed. It does mean that, in the real world, a lot of victims will never see justice until there's overwhelming evidence, if ever.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- orwin 6y agoThe first sentence is literally: "The problem is that only a tiny percentage of harassers and rapists are ever convicted. The court -- rightly -- sets a very high bar to conviction, and police and prosecutors often won't even attempt it unless the evidence is overwhelming.". First, its a poor place and topic for sarcasm (it just an observation, i'm not against it, i do have good friends like that) but more than that, GP actually adressed the point you're trying to highlight in his first sentence.
- DaveExeter 6y ago> The court -- rightly -- sets a very high bar to conviction, and police and prosecutors often won't even attempt it unless the evidence is overwhelming. Huh? Have you ever heard of the Central Park Five? Google "Central Park Five" and you'll have a more enlightened view!
- ummonk 6y agoThe Central Park five voluntarily confessed and were almost certainly guilty. The only issue was that there was a sixth perpetrator who had raped the victim after and wasn’t caught at the time.
- DaveExeter 6y agoIf you did a little research you will find they got paid $41,000,000 by the City of New York! You think the City just handed over tens of millions of dollars because settling would be cheaper then going to trial?
- ummonk 6y agoThe criteria for such a civil suit is whether the defendants' civil rights were violated, not whether the defendants are guilty. And cities often settle lawsuits regardless of guilt to avoid the costs of going to trial as well as the risks of public backlash. Notably in this specific case, the decision to settle was a political decision after DeBlasio was elected mayor.
- DaveExeter 6y agoThe City of New York is very wealthy, but you don't get almost $10 million for having your civil rights violated! I assure you, if that was the case, there would be a lot more multi-millionaires in NYC because the local police play it pretty fast 'n loose with the civil rights of citizens. And again, the City didn't hand over forty-million to get rid of a nuisance lawsuit. They have lawyers on staff -- it would probably cost under a million dollars for the city to go to trial.
- bitwize 6y ago> The court -- rightly -- sets a very high bar to conviction Rape convictions are so abysmally low that there's been a lot of rethinking in feminist circles as to whether the "beyond reasonable doubt" standard -- or even the presumption of innocence -- is fair or just. Some countries have been looking for ways to ameliorate this. For example, in thr USA, college date rape is such a problem that universities are required to investigate accusations of sexual harassment or assault and discipline offenders based on the looser preponderance standard, or be found in violation of Title IX by the federal Department of Education.
- prepend 6y agoIt seems like 68% [0] of rape prosecutions result in a conviction. And that’s higher than the 61% rate for violent crimes. So it seems we’re pretty good at convicting rapists, it’s the arresting that we’re bad at. And since RAINN [1] estimates that only 230/1000 are reported to police and of those only 43 lead to arrest and 9 to prosecution. If the ratios stay the same, then if we reported every rape then convictions would increase 4x. [0] Table 21, as of 2009 https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fdluc09.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fdluc09.pdf [1] https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fdluc09.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fdluc09.pdf
- secondcoming 6y agoThis problem can only be solved with trial by coin toss