5 ms·
This brings up a question I have had for a while: what is the life story of a photon shot at a black hole? From an outside observer, presumably you shoot a las
by colechristensen 6y ago
This brings up a question I have had for a while: what is the life story of a photon shot at a black hole?
From an outside observer, presumably you shoot a laser at a black hole and if your photons don't hit anything on the way to the horizon, they never hit it either but just approach asymptotically as time goes to infinity.
As, a photon though, you don't "notice" crossing the horizon and in a measurable amount of time you go from being emitted to hitting the singularity.
Black holes don't last until infinity though, they evaporate in a large but measurable time. (let's say 10^100 years, it depends on time and how the universe dies and how big the black hole is, but whatever, presuming it happens it is some extraordinarily large number of years)
So... as something falling into a black hole an outside observer will watch you infinitely slowly approaching a growing horizon until at some point the growth goes negative and you watch the horizon falling away from your friend the photon until at last the horizon disappears entirely and releases the photon to go about its merry way to hit something sometime around the heat death of the universe.
In other words, if you are a conscious very resilient little particle doomed to fall into a black hole... do you really appear from the outside to be falling in until the black hole evaporates? Do you experience going through the event horizon like it's nothing and hit the singularity in a few hours by your own watch...
Or is a black hole sort of a time machine to the end of the universe where in the short process of falling in you get to watch the whole history of existence pass you by and you come out at the end having never crossed the horizon in what was for you a very short ride.
Or is there some third option where from the outside it takes an infinite amount of time for you to fall in, but that infinity "for math reasons" actually takes place and passes in a Zeno's paradox kind of way at some distinct point in your timeline and you meanwhile pass the horizon and hit the singularity in short order and are no more?
I don't really know anything but these are questions and vague thoughts I have had. The central question is reconciling the outside apparent infinite time to watch something cross an event horizon with the finite lifespan of evaporating black holes.
- bpodgursky 6y agoWell, the other wrinkle here is that the "singularity" is a mathematical approximation. There's no such thing as hitting it -- from the outside, you just move asymptotically slower as you approach it.
- btilly 6y agoNot so fast. Black holes have a singularity in the middle, and an event horizon around them. There is no singularity at the event horizon, and that is all that we can see..
- juloo 6y agoThere might be naked singularities in case of a rapidly rotating black hole. The singularity would have a donut shape and might be outside of the event horizon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naked_singularity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naked_singularity Of course, this is very theoretical and we don't actually expect that to exist.
- btilly 6y agoHuh, I thought that naked singularities were thought to not exist. But apparently in 2018 someone found a case where they could. Thanks!
- juloo 6y agoYou move asymptotically slower from the point of view of the particle falling in the black hole. From outside the black hole, the falling particle should fall into the black hole at a speed close to the speed of light. (but we can't observe that from the outside) The image an outsider would see "printed" on the black hole has nothing to do with where the falling particle is.
- btilly 6y agoThat's officially above my pay grade. :-) Seriously my course in general relativity was about 30 years ago. And work on the information paradox work is about exactly what you're talking about. I honestly don't fully know what happens when you're approaching a growing black hole. Do you cross the horizon then?
- juloo 6y agoAs a particle, you continuously accelerate even after the event horizon (which you don't realize). Immediately after you passed the horizon, any photon you can send won't ever leave the black hole. What outside observers will see "frozen" is the instant just before you cross the horizon. A bit like if your image 1ms before you cross the horizon will be seen by the observers years after, your image 1µs before will be seen millions of years after, etc...
- colechristensen 6y agoBut... let’s watch that image or at least keep a model of our friends falling into the black hole for 10^100 years. Forever is a long time. If we keep watching that image the black hole eventually stops growing, the “image” never crosses the event horizon and when the universe cools down enough the event horizon starts getting smaller and hotter until we watch our friends getting roasted outside the evaporating black hole which eventually is gone and just normal matter. The timeline of the “image” would seem to reconnect with the real article having never crossed the event horizon. In other words it would seem if we waited long enough the image of our friends outside the event horizon would outlive the black hole and we could go say hello after it evaporated. In other, other words, how do we see the universe outside aging as we fall into a black hole? Do we not get to watch the heat death of the universe as we approach and consequently the black hole very quickly evaporating in front of us as we fall towards it?
- pdonis 6y ago> it would seem if we waited long enough the image of our friends outside the event horizon would outlive the black hole and we could go say hello after it evaporated You would see your friend's image, but your friend's image is not your friend. If you tried to go towards where the image appeared to be coming from, you would just find empty space, where the black hole that evaporated away (with your friend inside, having long before hit the singularity) used to be. Your friend would not be there any more. Note, btw, that once you see the final image of your friend (the image of him just crossing the horizon, which you see in a big flash of light when you see the hole finally evaporate), you see nothing more; your friend, and the hole, and all of the other things that fell into the hole (and whose images as they crossed the horizon you also saw in the big flash of light) all vanish after that (no more images are coming).
- hnews_account_1 6y agoThe second option is accurate. As you fall from the event horizon to the singularity, you see the entire future of the universe unfold since all arrows of time now point toward the singularity so as you move along it, you are moving in time. This is one of the things shown in interstellar before he hits the tesseract and they go into pure speculative scifi. He gets bombarded with extremely energetic blue shifted particles as he moves through time while falling. Regarding what happens at the event horizon, your question is slightly inaccurate in that the photon is what you observe so it doesn't emit anything. If you assume, say, a torch falling in facing toward you, the reason that it feels delayed is ofc that it has to move out of the gravity well of the black hole. I haven't thought about the question myself, but basically think about the entire set of photons your torch emits and assume it is a magically resilient thing that never tears apart. Then it emits a fair few trillion packets of energy before it crosses the event horizon. Most of this is caught in the photon sphere and never makes it out (depends on incident angle and some other calculations I forget).But we will assume photons are ejected in one line out on some radius vector of the black hole. Then all photos ejected before the event horizon will eventually escape and you will see them. The last one is supposed to escape asymptotically as you approach the horizon but it is only constrained by how much energy it loses traversing that piece of space time from the event horizon to infinity (i.e. where the observer is located). So we can deduce that it gets emitted at some point in time. We assume infinity to make the math easier but real life is quantized so it'll likely be sooner than that. I can't do any better than that unfortunately.
- colechristensen 6y ago>As you fall from the event horizon to the singularity, you see the entire future of the universe unfold since all arrows of time now point toward the singularity so as you move along it, you are moving in time. This would suggest that as I see the entire future of the universe as I fall towards the event horizon I also see the entire future of the horizon itself... which means that I will never cross the horizon because it will at some point far in the future no longer exist. i.e. there is no spacetime path which ever crosses the event horizon I'm near the point where I'm going to have to learn some black hole math to convince myself otherwise. (I think I'm wrong but can't see why)
- samatman 6y agoThe wrinkle in your question which sibling comments miss is this: it's difficult to reason about how a photon 'experiences' things under any circumstances. No, not because they don't have sensory organs or the like, we can wave that aside, but because time doesn't pass for objects moving at the speed of light. It's so compressed that everything is instantaneous: a photon from another galaxy arrives in our eyeballs at the same moment it is emitted. So you're asking a question about the duration experience around a black hole, of a particle which can't have duration experience.
- colechristensen 6y agoYes I was a bit imprecise and wandered about with my various examples... a photon doesn't experience time but an observers in a reference frame inertial-ish to the microwave background and generally far away from a gravity well will have a consistent agreement of when a photon is emitted, when it crosses an event horizon, and perhaps what happens to that photon as the black hole evolves. From the photon's experience it is emitted and absorbed at the same instance, my questions about duration are about how an external observer would assign times and locations to events for that photon.
- pdonis 6y ago> Black holes don't last until infinity though, they evaporate in a large but measurable time. Yes, but things can still fall in and hit the singularity inside during that time. You can't see the inside from outside, but you can still calculate that it is there based on observations you can make outside. > if you are a conscious very resilient little particle doomed to fall into a black hole... do you really appear from the outside to be falling in until the black hole evaporates? Sort of. If you are watching from outside, when the hole finally evaporates, you will see a big flash of light that includes images of everything that fell into the hole before it evaporated away, at the instant those things crossed the hole's horizon. Up until that point, yes, you will see infalling objects appear to gradually slow down as they approach the horizon. But that is only a sort of optical illusion; the objects actually fell in and hit the singularity inside the hole long before you see the final image of them crossing the horizon. > is a black hole sort of a time machine to the end of the universe where in the short process of falling in you get to watch the whole history of existence pass you by No, it's not. If you fall into a black hole, you will only see a short portion of the future of the rest of the universe from the time you started falling. The rest of the future of the universe will never become visible to you. > is there some third option No.
- platz 6y ago> the objects actually fell in and hit the singularity inside the hole long before you see the final image of them crossing the horizon. It's not an illusion at all, and neither observers reference frame is more privileged than the other. There is no global reference frame that allows you to say that the objects actually fell in and hit the singularity inside the hole long before you see the final image
- pdonis 6y ago> neither observers reference frame is more privileged than the other. I am not talking about any particular observers. I am talking about invariant properties of the spacetime geometry and invariant curves within that geometry. Nothing I have said depends on any particular choice of observers. I only phrased it in terms of what a particular observer sees because the post I was responding to was asking about what can be seen from outside the horizon. I could just as easily have phrased it in terms of what null curves intersect with a particular timelike curve; the underlying geometric facts, and the fact that they are invariant, are the same either way. > There is no global reference frame that allows you to say that the objects actually fell in and hit the singularity inside the hole long before you see the final image Yes, there is. There are a number of frames that cover both the exterior and interior regions; for example, Painleve coordinates, Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates, and Kruskal coordinates.