6 ms·
I want to see details on power source and energy usage. That's where I'm a bit skeptical. To do the 20 acres they're talking about you'd need one hell of a huge
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
I want to see details on power source and energy usage. That's where I'm a bit skeptical. To do the 20 acres they're talking about you'd need one hell of a huge battery, assuming it's electric. Even just to move the thing. Then add power draw for the laser on as well.
Also seems odd to have it be something that is self-powered and autonomous rather than just something you pull behind a tractor on the three point hitch (where you could power off the PTO of the tractor). Seems excessively novel, given most farmers are already spending time going up and down the rows cultivating, etc. anyways. Adds to the cost, and complexity.
- ransom1538 6y ago"I want to see details on power source and energy usage. That's where I'm a bit skeptical." Meh. Worse case you could even have a wire.
- wombat-man 6y agoHell, you could probably stick a fuel tank and a generator on it if you had to.
- meepmorp 6y agoWhich is basically what they did; upthread, someone links to the specs and they have an onboard Cummins diesel generator.
- toss1 6y agoCheck the Features & Specs page [1] 74-hp Cummins diesel QSF2.8 4 hydraulic drive motors 75-gallon fuel capacity I'd bet that diesel also powers a generator to run the computers and 150W lasers. [1] https://carbonrobotics.com/features https://carbonrobotics.com/features
- garrettgrimsley 6y agoYou’d be dragging that wire over your rows of crops, potentially damaging them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- osigurdson 6y ago"74-hp Cummins diesel QSF2.8" https://carbonrobotics.com/features https://carbonrobotics.com/features
- maxerickson 6y agohttps://carbonrobotics.com/features https://carbonrobotics.com/features Lasers are 150 watts, so a small fraction of the power draw. Seems like getting the automation is key, replacing herbicides would require multiple passes over the same ground.
- jfkgktjrnnr 6y ago150W of output power. Lasers are notoriously inefficient, CO2 ones are in the 5-20% range. So probably at least 1000W for the lasers, assuming 10% efficiency.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe modest engine powering it is 55 kW.
- stevespang 6y agoNo wonder they call it CARBON robotics, using CO2 lasers and yet still pumping significant amount of combustion CO2 into the atmosphere . . .
- Balgair 6y agoPeople who work in pulsed kW laser labs are all sitting here salivating at thought and also horrified at the thought. Salivating because that's a lot of power that you can use for experiments, much more than most laser technicians have ever seen. Horrified because not only are you going to go instantly blind (as usual), but now the rest of your head will smolder too.
- repiret 6y ago55kW at 240V is only 230A. A typical house gets 200A service. It’s a lot of power, but you wouldn’t have to move mountains to get it if you worked at a lab that needed it. It could be had for less than the price of many used cars.
- 6y ago
- boringg 6y agoOh it's for sure an energy hog and the 20 acres is marketing. Super interesting especially think of it as in its infancy. Also would be interested to see how the real world results are. I'm guessing it can laser all life but I would be curious to see how well the algorithm worked with protecting certain species.
- gus_massa 6y agoThe video looks like a mix of cgi graphics with unrelated real videos, so I guess they don't have a real machine yet.
- defaultname 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJigArURZWU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJigArURZWU (Video of an operating unit) There is nothing particularly unbelievable about the device, and it seems, as such innovations tend to be, quite obvious.
- gus_massa 6y agoIt's driving on asphalt in a parking lot. Do they have a video of the device following the grooves over mud? (It would be not surprising, because other automated tractors can do that.) It would be more interesting to see a video where they fire the lasers. Can it aim while moving? Can it aim while the engine is on and everything is vibrating?
- onion2k 6y agoThere's a video on YouTube of a walk around. https://youtu.be/fK3AQgt47z4 https://youtu.be/fK3AQgt47z4 The CEO of the company describes it as "an all diesel hydraulic system." Essentially there's a big generator to drive it around and provide power to the pew pew lasers.
- the_mitsuhiko 6y agoFarming equipment is typically fuel based. And this appears to be the case for this robot as well: it uses Diesel.
- jmacd 6y agoThis is in no small part because of the massive subsidization of fuel for farming in most countries. Not only is the fuel for agriculture heavily discounted, but what you do pay can be written off against your revenues. Same with most fisheries. If governments want these sectors to go green, that is going to be a very big and painful band-aid to peel off.
- fortran77 6y ago> but what you do pay can be written off against your revenue How is that different from any other business expense in any other industry.
- jmacd 6y agoOperating expense is different from a capital expenditure.
- simon1ltd 6y agoYou do realize that deducting the cost of producing a product is entirely normal and expected behavior right? It’s not some special loophole. If you use $1000 of electricity to harvest your crops, that $1000 would be equally as deductible because it’s just a cost of production?
- SamBam 6y agoAt that point, is this more environmental than applying Round-Up to the field? Each of these lumbering beasts goes 5 MPH, burning diesel the entire time. How many gallons of gas is going to be spent weeding a hundred acres of farmland?
- CameronNemo 6y ago
- tw04 6y ago>Also seems odd to have it be something that is self-powered and autonomous rather than just something you pull behind a tractor on the three point hitch That doesn't seem odd to me at all. The whole point of this thing is to let it run all day killing weeds while you do other stuff. The fact it only has a max of 5mph (and likely significantly slower when there are actual weeds to kill) means you would spend all day every day in the field trying to take care of weeds. When they spray for weeds they're going significantly faster than that and cover a massive swath in one pass, and that's generally outsourced to someone other than the farmer himself. This looks like it's good for maybe 3 rows at a time.
- hanniabu 6y ago> The whole point of this thing is to let it run all day killing weeds while you do other stuff. There's a lot of automated tractors now
- icegreentea2 6y agoYeah. But I wonder if putting it all in one was for better coupling between shooting laser control vs the whole cart moving around (for example, slowing down/stopping when the weed density goes up). I noticed this thing uses hydraulic drive motors... I assume that was so they could run the engine as 'electrical first', but I also wonder if it gives them better start/stop control of the cart.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoMany tractors these days are hydraulic as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tw04 6y agoI guess I don't follow what the advantage would be. Putting hours and wear/tear on a $250k tractor that you likely have other uses for in order to cut what? $10k off the price of this for the cummins motor and hydraulics? It would need power generation of some sort, so you'd be doing PTO off the tractor instead to drive a generator. I'd imagine the end result would be more fuel and in the long run more expense.
- MauranKilom 6y agoMaybe it's because the robot needs different amounts of time for different patches of soil? As in, it kinda needs to go its own pace to a) ensure it has enough time to detect and kill all weeds (which depends on weed density, presumably - the video shows it only killing one at a time) and b) maybe it has to stop to ensure it hits the right thing because it can't handle moving targets (not clear from the video)? No idea if this is something that modern tractors could accommodate already or whether it would need some annoying human-in-the-loop stop and go.
- throwaway09223 6y agoThe energy usage should be minimal - it doesn't take much power to burn a leaf. If you pull it behind a tractor, you need to hire someone to drive the tractor. This defeats the purpose of an autonomous weeding system.
- Minor49er 6y ago> The energy usage should be minimal - it doesn't take much power to burn a leaf. This is certainly true for dry plants. If they're weeds, they're actively growing, so they are trapping a lot of moisture that could make it hard to burn. If the weeds are a problem, then they're going to be growing. Many weeds, too, will continue to grow, even if their leaves are damaged or removed.
- throwaway09223 6y agoI think we might be using different definitions of "burn." I mean burnt by radiation so it no longer photosynthesizes -- in some plants this can happen simply from overexposure to sunlight. It's not necessary to turn it to ash. A machine continually damaging cotyledons in emerging seedlings would go a long way. That's part of the advantage of a continually running weed killer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tjoff 6y agoWhy would you assume it was electric?
- Minor49er 6y agoInstead of a laser, I wonder if it would make sense to use positioned lenses and have the robot focus the sun's rays on each weed to burn it out. Though that probably would cause fires and would only be usable during certain hours of the day.
- erikpukinskis 6y agoWhy would the fire danger be different than the laser?
- Minor49er 6y agoI could easily be wrong on this, but my understanding is that a laser is highly focused to one spot. A lens would have a wider spread and would also heat up the area surrounding the target to the point that it could ignite.
- ninju 6y ago> would only be usable during certain hours of the day Limiting usage to when the light will be strong enough to be focused would seriously limit the hours of usage Maybe adding solar panels to harness solar energy to offset ICE emissions would be a consideration
- Minor49er 6y agoThat woukd be a good idea, though wouldn't that notably increase the cost of the unit as well?
- cryptonector 6y agoI don't see why power would be an issue. Why do you even assume there's a huge battery instead of a diesel engine and generator? Having this thing be autonomous makes it more expensive to acquire, yes, but way cheaper to operate because the labor cost of pulling this thing with a non-autonomous tractor is quite large (even if the tractor were autonomous, having two autonomous robots doing different things is better than having one doing two different things that might halve its availability for each kind of task). This is a very big deal. If labor were a non-issue we'd have people weeding manually and we'd not use herbicides. Everything in farming is about labor, which is why we've gone from being agrarian societies to industrial and post-industrial ones: by bringing economies of scale to agriculture in order to greatly reduce labor costs in agriculture.