4 ms·
You might not be aware, but the core of this mentality is “you’re either with us or against us”; and is one of the most toxic mantras that those who seek to en
by dijit 6y ago
You might not be aware, but the core of this mentality is “you’re either with us or against us”; and is one of the most toxic mantras that those who seek to enact change engage in.
I conduct many actions a day which do not make me complicit in the status quo. The mere act of throwing an item away is not political unto itself, the item in question may be. But we really must find better ways not to ascribe malice when some unknown group of people does something ordinary without consideration of politics.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoIt could just be that actively choosing to be ignorant is in itself a form of malice if that ignorance harms others. I say this as someone who you feel lacks awareness, after all. Maybe I'm just too dumb to pretend that the obvious is actually nuanced.
- orwin 6y agoFirst: no its not "core", it is sometime a byproduct. In my opinion you have that reversed. The "everything is political" mean "every action or non-action any human take is political". Gravity is not political. How you describe gravitation to an audience is. The issue of this saying is that it make false equivalence. Everything might be political, but the degree differs, and not everything have to do with a "side". The way math is usually taught (poorly imho) have nothing to do with right or left, but with the culture and how we treat children, how we grade them and what we expect from them.[0] The "everything is equally political" that some people seems to be saying can and will become "you’re either with us or against us" [0] writing this i understand this is a poor example since in my country this criticism is politically charger when extrapolated.
- goodpoint 6y ago"you either are part of the solution of [X] or you are part of the problem" is an oversimplification and it's probably not meant to be taken literally. First, nobody can have the knowledge, time and resources to work on each and every problem in the world. Second, people can be overwhelmed by problems in their own lives and focused on getting to the end of the month. And there's no shame in that. > we really must find better ways not to ascribe malice when some unknown group of people does something ordinary without consideration of politics Yet we have to realize that there are hundreds of millions of people in developed countries that have access to information (e.g. Internet, documentaries...) and have enough spare time to learn and take a position. And yet they choose not to. Without ascribing malice, it can be uncomfortable and even painful to look at many problems in the world and admit that our lives could have been 100x times worse if we were to be born in the wrong place.
- claudiawerner 6y ago>I conduct many actions a day which do not make me complicit in the status quo. This is very true, but there's also an argument to be made that our everyday life and almost all the actions we take count as 'reproduction' of the system - whether that's reproduction of religion, the economy, the state, or whatever else. Althusser picked up on this a while back. Not only does the economy need to reproduce itself using inputs from other production processes, but everyday life and society needs to reproduce itself too. This happens at the most basic level with the accumulation of thousands of small decisions, combined with particular ideologies (e.g. the religious person sees a particular action as rational or irrational in accordance with their ideology; the economic actor sees an action as rational or irrational on the ideology of the market; the state sees a certain action as rational or irrational on the ideology of control and parameters set by budget). That's not to say reproduction is bad, or individually morally blameworthy in most circumstances - but it is there. When you work, you reproduce the economy. When you sing in church, you reproduce religion. When you pay taxes or vote, you reproduce the state. When you send your kids to school you reproduce the education system. There is very little room to be 'revolutionary' about these things, and that's a shame.