3 ms·
> That ends up being regressive taxation. “Regressive taxation” is a term for people paying what something costs. Carbon taxes are also a “regressive taxation”
by kortilla 6y ago
> That ends up being regressive taxation.
“Regressive taxation” is a term for people paying what something costs. Carbon taxes are also a “regressive taxation” as well as sales tax, alcohol tax, etc.
Public resources are public goods, but they are rivalrous. If you don’t make people pay in a fair manner, you’ve just implemented government rations which incentivize all kinds of stupid shit (illegal taxi services for one).
> and what happens if there is a lot of traffic in their own neighborhood?
If they can’t afford it then they don’t drive. It’s that simple.
The complexity only comes from trying to solve poverty (“oh, but that’s regressive”) at the same time as trying to solve a specific issue. Just give poor people cash stipends for transportation if transporting the poor is the problem you want to tackle. Then they can choose if they want to spend it on bus fares or use it towards ride shares, biking, whatever.
Prescriptive “there shall be 10 taxis for the people and they will enjoy them and no more” laws have basically never had good outcomes. Hedge funds paying millions of dollars to analysts with mountains of data have difficulty predicting market demand trends, there isn’t a chance in hell some bureaucrat is going to correctly balance a market.
- imtringued 6y agoThis is a common pattern, poorest member M of society Y is not well off enough to do X, the cost of X is lowered for everyone until M can afford X. Except the members of Society Y that do X primarily consists of rich people, it looks fair because everyone is treated equally, in practice the support didn't solve the problem at all, and in the process a bunch of people got a free gift so they don't mind the damage. The reason why politics doesn't work is that people aren't interested in solving the problem, they just want some kickbacks. The end result is a "fair" but dysfunctional society.