8 ms·
The expectation that a corporation operating in India will not obey Indian laws but American ones is appalling. EU, Canada, China, Turkey or North Korea - if y
by mrtksn 6y ago
The expectation that a corporation operating in India will not obey Indian laws but American ones is appalling.
EU, Canada, China, Turkey or North Korea - if you want to do business there you have to respect their laws.
“For profit US corporation fighting foreign government atrocities” is a deeply flawed idea.
If Indians believe that they need wider free speech rights or other protections, they need to change their political figures and laws accordingly. It’s unreasonable to expect that a foreign corporation will do that for them, it even might be the case that they(the locals) don’t want it.
Imagine the other way around, Italian company selling Kinder Surprise Eggs in US, Swiss company doing banking by the Swiss laws in US, Malta company running gambling in the US by the Maltese laws. Would they be considered fighting the unreasonable food regulations, toppling the oppressive financial laws or pushing against tyrannical gambling laws of the US? I don’t think so.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 6y agoMy expectation isn't that a US tech company would break local law. It's that it would get out of market where it would otherwise be forced to do things that doesn't agree with some fundamental values of the company.
- vmception 6y ago> some fundamental values of the company they do you just misinterpreted what the fundamental values were
- jamnik 6y agoIn US they censor right. In India they censor left. In Third Reich they would have censored Hitler critics. On which morał grounds they think they can censor exactly. Who do they think that they are?
- alkonaut 6y agoMy second expectation is that I expect companies not to have "deliver maximum value to its shareholders" as its fundamental value or guiding principle (Unsure if that's what you were alluding to here). That is: I basically expect companies to leave huge amounts of (their investors') money on the table when it goes against the ethical/moral compass of a vocal minority of its users, owners, or employees.
- vmception 6y agoI wasn’t directly alluding to that, more so something like access to a market is more important and maintaining a relationship with the governing gatekeepers of that market is the priority, until the governing body says they cant do an increasing level of business in that government’s markets, thats when the corporation will consider to exit the market entirely If you want that to be “shareholder value” then sure, but I’m saying corporations don't have strong opinions on anything except antitrust and employees telling them what to do. It is much more predictable along these lines instead of imagining any other abstract expectation of corporations and being surprised over and over again for your whole life.
- PikachuEXE 6y agoDon't be evil. Unless...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- plank_time 6y agoThen why are people shitting over Google for attempting to created a censored search engine for China? I think the project was called Dragonfly.
- elaus 6y agoI think it's fair to _criticise_ local companies that are giving up certain morals to be able to make business in foreign countries. This creates some pressure and forces companies to consider either keeping the users in your home country happy or to make profits abroad. We just can't expect the foreign country to change their laws or the company to break those laws.
- themolecularman 6y agoWasn't Project Dragonfly shut down by internal Google "activists" rather than by outside forces?
- mrtksn 6y agoI don’t know, should ask them. Maybe it’s because of the Googles PR giving the idea that they are not in the business of making money but organising world’s knowledge? Maybe they should ask Google why they don’t go non-profit. Maybe Google backed down because damage on the brand in US would be greater than the expected profits from China? Maybe they back down because employees went political and Google didn't want to lose them? Or maybe they are simply afraid that these new abilities will come back home?
- fossuser 6y agoMaybe because it's wrong to actively help suppress speech in a hostile country regardless of its legality in that country? Legal and ethical are not the same thing - something can be legal and unethical, or illegal and ethical.
- mrtksn 6y agoWho says what's wrong or unethical? Would you consider unethical or wrong to take people's guns away? UK, EU or Australia might disagree with the US on this. What about abortion? What about regulation on what goes into your body? What about blasphemy? What about ending your own life? What about pre-marital sex? What about changing your religion? What about drawing Muhammeds cartoon? What about many other things that are right or wrong depending on who you ask?
- dagenix 6y agoIt's appalling that you trivialize human rights. You should be ashamed.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines like this, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are. It damages the commons, which is fragile. Your admirable concern for human rights is possible to express in a way that doesn't contribute to destroying the community. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- MperorM 6y agoIf India requires twitter murder a child every time someone tweets, I sure hope they don't just say: "Well, I guess that's just their way of life" and continue operating. Obviously India is requiring no such thing, but what about when China wants google to build them a censored search engine?
- timeslip1523 6y agoGoogle will roll up their sleeves and get the IOT guillotine ready, happily running all their american leftie-progressive marketing back home while they do so. Why not? Apple did it!
- root_axis 6y agoI don't understand your point. Murdering children is an unequicoval act of heinous evil, deleting posts from your website is a shady business decision.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhere do you draw the line? Lots of people would say that heavily silencing government criticism is evil. Not heinous evil, but can't we be mad at boring evil?
- root_axis 6y agoI didn't say not to be mad at anything, it just seems absurd to compare murdering innocents to twitter hiding tweets in one region.
- throwawaysea 6y agoBut this isn't "heavily silencing government criticism". Only 50ish tweets were blocked, for containing misinformation that was intended to cause a panic. That's illegal per Indian laws. Criticizing the government is not illegal, and is allowed. If the government were really "heavily silencing government criticism", we would be seeing millions of tweets and accounts being blocked and censored. Instead, it's a narrow targeted set that did things like use images from other circumstances to make it seem like they were part of the COVID situation.
- dasKrokodil 6y ago>Imagine the other way around, German company selling Kinder Surprise Eggs in US TIL that Kinder Surprise Eggs are illegal in the US.
- oooooooooooow 6y agoYep, a result of legislation prohibiting food items containing inedible parts iirc! I always found it amusing.
- ndr 6y agoInteresting, I wonder how they kept skewers and mangos legal.
- jchallis 6y agoUnlike AR-15's that kill a great deal more children.
- dang 6y ago"Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- oooooooooooow 6y agoUnderstandable you'd think Kinder was a German brand, but they're made by Ferrero, an Italian company.
- mrtksn 6y agoAh, I keep forgetting that. "Kinder" sounds very German to me.
- oooooooooooow 6y agoIt is, German for "Child" (cfr. Kindergarten)
- majewsky 6y agoActually, it's German for "children".
- ithkuil 6y agoBecause the word is german indeed. Ferrero has an long history in using foreign words in their product names. E.g. Mon Cheri chocolate in 1956 Nutella in 1964 ("nut" also not an italian word, which would be "nocciola")
- ButtSpark69 6y ago“For profit US corporation fighting foreign government atrocities” I think that's a bit of an unfair phrasing. How about "Good people upholding their morals instead of dropping them at the door when they go to work" I really am not a fan of how far we've taken the general image that 'business is business' and a bunch of regular morals are OK to toss out. We should preserve the social stigma we hold against people equally against companies.
- mrtksn 6y agoI agree. IMHO, corporations must be hold morally accountable(whatever that is, locally). However, if the local morals say that "It's all about profits" or something permissive then they will operate in oppressive regimes. What I disagree with, is the expectation of enforcing US morals to other parts of the world. If we are going for the moral stance of "should not tolerate censorship", instead of expecting Twitter to "fight the oppressive Indian govt" , it's more reasonable to expect Twitter not doing business there. So far, as we see with Apple, Twitter, FB, Palantir, Oracle, Cisco and many others, the Americans are fine with their businesses working with those governments.
- bellyfullofbac 6y agoTwitter allows posting of naked photos. I have no problems with this, but should a country's laws against pornography be ignored because "our morals are superior"?
- fighterpilot 6y agoI don't think it's valid to compare different pornography laws with a government censoring criticism. The former has very little societal significance, the latter is correlated with rather unpleasant state authoritarianism.
- ehsankia 6y agoAt the end of the day, this goes back to a debate that's been had here many times before, such as with Google's Dragonfly, which is that is Twitter doing more good being available in India with occasional censoring, or if it do more good if it wasn't available in India all. I'm not siding one way or another, but it's not clear that taking down the platform as a whole is always a better solution than running a slightly censored one.
- pjc50 6y ago> Swiss company doing banking by the Swiss laws in US In the end, Swiss companies doing Swiss style secret banking in Switzerland were deemed unacceptable to the US and forced to change. It's realpolitik all the way down. This stuff tends to come down to whether you support the specific policy and outcomes. Hyped up nationalism is a problem in lots of countries; there's only so much blame you can apply to social media before having to look at other actors as well.
- colechristensen 6y agoI don’t know about that, the swiss banks i was aware of getting into trouble with the US were very much not doing business in switzerland.
- fossuser 6y agoThis is a warped framing. I don't buy moral relativism, it may be legal in China to put the Uyghurs in camps but any company helping to enable that is on the wrong side of history - legality is irrelevant. Stuff above that threshold (kinder eggs) sure, follow the country's policies - provided the country is a real democracy, with a free press, and rule of law.
- morbicer 6y agoso many Chinese shills downvoting you, so sad :( at some point you need to draw a line where "profit is the only thing that matters" ends and some basic humanity should prevail
- another_kel 6y ago>If Indians believe that they need wider free speech rights or other protections, they need to change their political figures and laws accordingly And then twitter in India won't ban people just like it does in the US. Oh wait...
- colechristensen 6y agoIBM more or less actively participated in the holocaust with punchcard technology enabling large scale identification and organization of the atrocity. Did IBM do wrong it were they just operating in a market with different laws? How do you decide which violations of human rights are just different laws and which are crimes against humanity?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIf you think your country's company is doing wrong in a different country by following that country's laws there, push for them to exit that market entirely.
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoI expect Twitter to do exactly the same thing they would do if the US authorities were issuing a legally questionable censorship order. Fight it in the courts. Fight it in the public arena. Indian Twitter users and Indian civil society should have just the same expectation of receiving support from Twitter's lawyers as U.S users and U.S citizens get. That's what it means to be a global corporation. >If Indians believe that they need wider free speech rights or other protections, they need to change their political figures and laws accordingly. Yes, but that is a process. And part of that process is making a fuss about cases like this. You act as if an order issued by some bureaucrat was itself the law and the will of the poeple. That's completely ridiculous. We would never accept that in a rich western country before it has gone through the courts of law and the court of public opinion. In my view it is outright racist to expect corporations to put up a public legal fight against questionable decisions by authorities in rich countries but consider the same thing a cultural inevitability in poor countries.
- dTal 6y agoI wish I could upvote this twice. The double standard is appalling.
- hansvm 6y ago> You act as if an order issued by some bureaucrat was itself the law and the will of the poeple. I mean, we kind of do act that way. If a given thing has regulations then there almost certainly exists a small office whose sole purpose is to be the button pushers for those regulations, and their word is effectively law unless you're wealthy enough to fight it. As a comparatively minor example, there's just some guy behind a desk in the MN department of public safety who can unilaterally revoke drivers' licenses without any court's approval or any available appeal's process. The police and the rest of the system are more than happy to enforce that guy's decisions. *In case there's any ambiguity, the "wealth" mentioned above doesn't just refer to your legal fees, but also to things like being able to afford to repeatedly take a day off work to wait on hold or in a line for yet another round of red tape. It adds up, especially with more than half of people living paycheck to paycheck.
- onion2k 6y agoImagine the other way around, Italian company selling Kinder Surprise Eggs in US, Swiss company doing banking by the Swiss laws in US, Malta company running gambling in the US by the Maltese laws. Would they be considered fighting the unreasonable food regulations, toppling the oppressive financial laws or pushing against tyrannical gambling laws of the US? I don’t think so. It's obvious with physical goods. If the goods aren't inline with the country's laws then you can't sell them there. Simple. It's a lot less obvious with digital services. If I run an online service that's a legal entity in the US, with servers in the US, and someone accesses from a different country, whose laws count more? Should I have to write my code to obey every country's specific legal frameworks? What if two countries conflict? Does it make a difference if there are edge servers in the foreign state that do caching? This is not a simple problem. “For profit US corporation fighting foreign government atrocities” is a deeply flawed idea. "For profit US corporation doing what the shareholders want" isn't though, and if the shareholders think that being complicit in covering up atrocities reduces their stock value then the corporation has to fight the foreign government instead. That's how capitalism works.
- jb775 6y agoIt's nothing about laws, Twitter did the same exact thing in the US (actually even worse since they did it attempting to sway election results). Twitter is a communist organization and communists love censorship. There's no way this was a difficult decision for Twitter, considering their actions here align with their actions and decisions conducted voluntarily on a daily basis.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoIn what way is Twitter a communist organization? What do you mean by “communist” here?
- jb775 6y agoCarve out their decisions and behaviors/actions related to any social impact they have on non-internal matters and it's essentially the exact ideology detailed in the Communist Manifesto. It's not hard to see, it's just currently under the guise of supporting the Democratic political party.
- fakedang 6y agoUh, hello? By law India is a democracy, where it has always been OK to criticize the government - at least up until 2014, when the current government began abusing the British Era sedition laws. I think every Indian on this site is old enough to remember who the protests against the Delhi Rape Crisis and the government response were effectively coordinated on Twitter and Facebook. Twitter wouldn't have been breaking any laws if precedent weren't being set by this government.
- mrtksn 6y agoOkay, what's the expectation here? Twitter fixing the "wrong choice" the Indians made in 2014? That doesn't sound like a democracy to me either. IMHO, if that's the case Indians need to get a new government and fight their own wars. Why would Twitter be liberating the Indian people? If anything, that "liberation" would come at a cost just as with the USSR liberating Germany from the Nazis, US liberating Iraqi people from Saddam, Turkey liberating Turkish Cypriots from the Greek dictatorship.
- fakedang 6y agoBecause Twitter wasn't breaking any laws. Twitter should not be policing content because none of the people posting on it were breaking any laws either. The only laws Twitter was breaking was a skewed interpretation of a British Era law for which the Indian government is twisting the definition of treason.
- mrtksn 6y ago>skewed interpretation of a British Era law for which the Indian government is twisting the definition of treason. There you have it. It’s not up to the companies to police, enforce or interpret laws. That’s the states job and if that’s how they interpret it then that’s how the law is. There are other tools to change laws or interpretations.
- fakedang 6y agoLast time I checked, it's the court's job to interpret laws, not the legislature's. And from recent past precedent, we know that the courts haven't interpreted the sedition law the way the government has, yet the Modi government does not give a rats ass and continues to trample over them.
- dTal 6y ago>If Indians believe that they need wider free speech rights or other protections, they need to change their political figures and laws accordingly. That's a wonderful idea. Pity it's censored in India.