5 ms·
Ingenuity: NASA's Mars helicopter makes it three from three
- whiddershins 6y agoThree for three?
- davidjgraph 6y agoThat's US English, this is British English.
- iab 6y ago“From” in this context I associate more with British English, and “for” with American English
- ridgeguy 6y agoAfter the planned flight program concludes, would it be possible to have Ingenuity follow Perseverance on the rover's travels? Perseverance moves pretty slowly - it would seem straightforward to have Ingenuity do a daily catch-up flight to stay within comm range of the rover. Having demo'ed flight successfully, it would seem useful to keep using the helicopter to gather more engineering data.
- MontagFTB 6y agoWhile I agree the idea would be novel and intriguing, it’s trying to keep alive an 84M experiment that was a footnote on a multi-billion-dollar expedition. I don’t think anyone would want to jeopardize the latter for the former, no matter how enticing.
- systemvoltage 6y agoHow would it jeopardize the rover?
- dogma1138 6y agoPotentially crash into the rover. The more flights it takes the more likely it would eventually fail and it will not crash gracefully. Considering that other than would it actually fly and the coolness factor there isn’t much scientific value stemming from repeat flights as it carries little to no scientific instruments the risk even if it’s relatively low isn’t really worth it.
- systemvoltage 6y agoThis seems extreme and overly cautious, I think logically not sound. If there was a risk of the helicopter colliding, they wouldn't have done this project in the first place! Rover can be far away from the area of operation of the Helicopter. Even if it crashes, it weighs next to nothing and despite of its blades spinning at 2900 RPM, it has very little kinetic energy if impacted compared to the amount of abuse the rover had to endure when landing.
- dogma1138 6y agoIt has a mass of 2kg, and as you said two sets of carbon fiber rotors that are operating at nearly 3000 RPMs that’s more than enough to do some damage to Percy it can easily break an antenna, arm or the mast camera as well as damage other experiments. There is a very big difference between the landing shock when the rover was locked down and sensitive equipment protected and a flying lawnmower blades impacting sensitive equipment it wouldn’t surprise me it much of the rover skin is paper thin so you are potentially even at a higher risk here.
- stevenhuang 6y agoThis sounds like someone who has never flown an RC plane before. Nevermind the fact you think it won't damage the rover, which is beyond strange. The forces when landing have been modelled and taken into account, the helicopter crashing into the rover is not. If any one of the instruments is hit at the wrong angle, it's not hard to see it will be permanently knocked out.
- nitrogen 6y ago
- jvanderbot 6y agoI think I remember that Percy will, at speed, outrun the copter on a day-over-day basis. It's quite a bit faster on daily average mostly due to much longer drives that are possible with the new version.
- _rpd 6y agoMy understanding is that Ingenuity will act as a scout for the rover, to make the rover’s investigations even more productive.
- Keysh 6y agoNo; that’s a potential use of upgraded, more capable rotorcraft in future missions.
- carlosdp 6y agoThe copter won't last very long on the Martian surface. It's using non-radiation protected hardware (which allows the software to be much more advanced that what we'd typically send to the planet).
- zarzavat 6y agoI'm curious what kind of permanent damage radiation causes to hardware? We hear about cosmic rays flipping bits in non-ECC RAM but that would generally be fixed by a reboot.
- throwawayboise 6y agoI guess maybe bits will get flipped in the saved program code and operating systems also? Thus rendering the device inoperable since there's no way to perform a reformat/reinstall
- shantara 6y agoI wonder if the team has anything planned for Ingenuity after completion of the mandatory mission program. Something that could obtain as much data as possible in the shortest possible time while not particularly caring about the survival of the helicopter itself. Like, a flight to a 100 meter altitude, or something similar.
- exporectomy 6y agoYes, they did say they want to find its limits even if that means crashing it. I don't think they'll just turn it off still in working order and abandon it. They didn't do that with any of the rovers, after-all.
- ilkkao 6y agoI hope too it can keep following the rover for some time. Hardest part might be to alter Perseverance's schedule accordingly I guess. Additional data transfers need to be planned. Preferably Perseverance needs to take some images during every flight and so on.
- xtiansimon 6y agoWatching the first press conference there was obvious disagreement about how the mission will evolve after these initial flights. I gathered the overall mission is to maximize the understanding of the copter’s flight characteristics and other issues, as they develop, regarding flight on Mars—to the point of the copters destruction.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoI hope we start sending larger and larger aircraft on Mars. From the current toy copter to Cessna sized planes and eventually fighter jets and C-130 Hercules-like cargo aircraft we will need to efficiently network distant Martian outposts with one another, we will need paved runways, air traffic control, radars, hardened communications suites, and living quarters to lay the foundation for a truly permanent human colony on Mars. The goal should be to grow a colony to thousands of people, living and working on Mars for years at a time, or for the rest of their lives even, if they wish so.
- fidesomnes 6y agoImagine having no idea what the plans are for Mars from 2025-2040.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 6y agoIt’s shame that the Martian atmosphere is so thin, a drone airship would’ve been an interesting idea since it could operate nearly indefinitely. Achieving buoyancy would require a gigantic lifting body, far larger than any folding body we can send up there. An evacuated space airship might also be possible but it would require a large ridged body (tho smaller than any gas filled balloon) which would also be impractical if not impossible to currently land on Mars.
- magicalhippo 6y ago> Achieving buoyancy would require a gigantic lifting body That's why the first manned mission should include a politician, so they could fill the thing with election promises... Seriously though, it got me thinking about Mytbuster's lead balloon experiment. Though I guess part of the problem is having to survive the dust storms, and possibly small meteorites?
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- FridayoLeary 6y agoi remember there was supposed to be an Easter egg hidden on the helicopter, like on the parachute. Anyone knows what it is?
- imglorp 6y agoMaybe you're thinking about the small sample of Wright Flyer fabric? [1] The helicopter doesn't have a parachute. The rover's parachute did have a coded message.[2] 1. https://nationalpost.com/news/world/with-ingenuity-test-wright-brothers-plane-flies-again-on-mars https://nationalpost.com/news/world/with-ingenuity-test-wrig... 2. https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/24/world/mars-perseverance-parachute-code-scn-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/24/world/mars-perseverance-parac...
- plasma 6y agoThe parachute colors was also morse code, https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/23/22297094/hidden-message-parachute-nasa-mars-perseverance-rover https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/23/22297094/hidden-message-p...
- ggm 6y agoIf it has a preplanned last flight, sending it one way along the path the rover plans taking maximises value from terrain mapping and imaging input to route optimisation. I say if, since the protocol may be to simply stop before it is predicted to drain. The last flight may only be known in arrears.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoIt has solar panels and a battery. The only reason it should ever stop is if it is damaged. (Or falls over? I wonder if the rover could pick it up again.)
- ggm 6y agoIt depends on the battery to survive overnight cold. If it gets unable to stay warm, it might not come back from an overnighter. The battery will have been chosen for flight. It may have sacrificed aH duration for peak intensity and weight
- 1970-01-01 6y agoThe helicopter was designed as a short engineering proof of concept. The only scientific instrument onboard is a high resolution camera. Having stated the obvious, I too wonder what else can be accomplished once the flights are complete. There would be significant scientific value in high resolution stratigraphy of Jezereo crater.
- Stevvo 6y agoIn earlier versions of X-Plane flight simulator you could design aircraft to fly on Mars. Lots of fun. Anything from helicopters like Ingenuity to fixed wing rocket planes. The physics/math behind it is accurate enough that NASA has used it in the design of terrestrial aircraft.
- alphachloride 6y agoThe video captured by Perseverance's camera of the flight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNx9hcrUpww https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNx9hcrUpww Taking a step back - it is just mind blowing that I am looking at color footage of activity on a different planet.
- iamcreasy 6y agoIs there any plan for the drone to take picture of Perseverance?
- tenacious_tuna 6y agoas cool as that would be, I bet the dust from the downdraft would be problematic for the rover.
- Hemingway6235 6y agoI must say you have written a great article. The way you have described everything is phenomenal. https://www.navyarmyccu.ltd/ https://www.navyarmyccu.ltd/