4 ms·
We have very little evidence to substantiate the actual quantity of real dollars in this system. This is especially true of NFTs. With each item unique, there'
by Animats 6y ago
We have very little evidence to substantiate the actual quantity of real dollars in this system.
This is especially true of NFTs. With each item unique, there's no meaningful market price. There are just occasional stories about sales.
This is important. With a commodity that has an active market, prices have some meaning. You can usually sell your asset at roughly the current market price. This is not true of unique items. You have to find a buyer who wants your specific thing.
This works just like collectables on eBay. Here's a current collectable.[1]
"Rare Tag Error Retired Ty Beanie Baby Claude The Crab 1996 Collector - US $1,235.00 [ 0 bids ]" Note the "0 bids". Now keep scrolling down until something shows up with a bid.[2] "Princess diana beanie baby 1st edition 1997 w/o tag US $0.99 [ 1 bid ]" That's what a willing buyer is prepared to pay. You can scroll through page after page of Beanie Baby asking prices without seeing anything with a bid.
That's what an NFT market looks like when you want to sell.
The NFT market is useful only to those with a fan base they can monetize. If you're the fan, you're the sucker.
[1] https://www.ebay.com/itm/194065105880 https://www.ebay.com/itm/194065105880
[2] https://www.ebay.com/itm/254955747357 https://www.ebay.com/itm/254955747357
- aphextron 6y agoPeople are going to have to learn the hard way about bid/ask spreads.
- gruez 6y agoIronically I learned how exchanges worked (bid/ask, order book, spreads, etc.) through crypto.
- Itsdijital 6y agoI searched for most valuable beanie babies and found a site that said the Princess Di bear is worth $500k. The completed auctions on ebay reveal a market price of....$4.50
- Nasrudith 6y agoI think that may be a feature for money launderers. They love exploiting subjective valued things like art and wine. It would also help explain where the dumb money is coming from - losing money during the laundering process is the norm so a "bad deal" could still be a win.
- tim333 6y agoTrue it's kind of a great fit for that. Your clean money account offers a stupid NFT for $50m, your dirty money account buys it all via anonymised crypto. Though maybe a bit obvious.
- adventured 6y agoWhile your broad point is correct, that's not at all how you would gauge eBay / marketplace values correctly. The $0.99 one bid example doesn't reveal much about what people are willing to pay. At a minimum you also want to use completed / historical sales, not pick out an item with 0 or 1 or N bids that is an auction in progress. People often place an initial entry bid on items when the auction begins just to keep track of items of interest as an alternative to the watchlist, and typically there is a rush of activity in the last minute courtesy of robobids. That Claude the Crab or Diana - depending on condition - might go for $10, $100 or $5,000+. We wouldn't know unless we check historical sales and keep in mind how condition drastically alters the value of collectibles. Using eBay's filters you can switch to only showing sold items. Or you can use one of the numerous sites that make it easy to check historical prices.
- londons_explore 6y agoAuctions have an issue for rare items - they require at least TWO bidders to get an idea of a price. One bidder might have been happy to spend a million dollars, but the item still sells for $0.99 because nobody bid against her.
- pessimizer 6y agoThe value is going to be desire times scarcity. It doesn't matter if someone would pay a million dollars for something that is available for 99¢; I'd pay $1000 for a glass of water if they weren't available for a penny.
- Animats 6y agoHere we have eBay's listing of Beanie Babies that actually sold, sorted highest price first. There are 21 that actually sold over $5000. How many of those are wash sales is not clear. [1] https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=Beanie+Babies&_sacat=0&LH_Sold=1&LH_Complete=1&_sop=16 https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=Beanie+Babies...