6 ms·
> Even in circumstances where the distances are not too great, and the political and bureaucratic hurdles are. NIMBY-ism as well? Because I can't fathom how a
by masklinn 6y ago
> Even in circumstances where the distances are not too great, and the political and bureaucratic hurdles are.
NIMBY-ism as well? Because I can't fathom how a 400 miles high-speed rail route can cost $100bn unless you're spending years re-drafting your route because every asshole on the way has to be heard.
25 years is not completely nonsensical though, if you want to do this right it does take time.
For a fairly recent example, the french LGV Est is 252 miles (406km), it cost 4bn (including 800 millions worth of rolling stock), and took 16 years before the construction and financing protocol of the first phase was signed and the opening of the second phase. First phase opened a year late, and second phase 3 months late because of the Eckwersheim testing accident (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eckwersheim_derailment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eckwersheim_derailment).
Obviously building in California would require additional studies and expenses for earthquake safety and the like, but 12x… seems a bit much.
The cost only makes sense if it's basically all tunnels and briges, like Chūō Shinkansen: that's estimated to cost north of $90 billion for 177 miles, but it's going straight through mountains, 90% of the way is through tunnels.
- bushbaba 6y agoHave to wonder if Elon’s boring company is the solution. The state can say you don’t own the ground underneath and just tunnel straight from sf to la
- masklinn 6y agoThe cost would actually make sense if it were all tunnels. Japan's newest Shinkansen route will be 90% tunnels, and it's estimated at $90bn for 180 miles. Tunneling is expensive as hell.
- Pxtl 6y agoI wonder if you could lower cost by switching to narrower tunnel gauge. Also, if it's all tunnel you could evacuate some of the air to lower resistance... Oh crud Hyperloop finally makes sense to me.
- bobthepanda 6y agonarrower tunnel gauge either means less capacity or comfort, or sometimes both. part of why Concorde was retired was because the seats themselves were not actually comfortable, and it could not compete with more spacious business class on traditional airliners with innovations like lie flat beds.
- ghaff 6y agoI'm not sure the timeframes quite line up. Lie-flat seating was coming in when the Concorde was retired (after an accident and in the wake of 9/11) but I'm not sure how widespread it was. But, yes, I've been in a Concorde (not flown in one) and the seating is, at best, modern domestic--non lie-flat--business class. I actually think this is something that a lot of modern supersonic travel fans miss. If you're willing to spend the money that supersonic travel will cost you can travel very comfortably. And 12-24 hours of time spent relaxing comfortably is not actually a problem for most people.
- bobthepanda 6y agoBA, one of the two Concorde operators, started using lie flat beds in 1999. Six hours vs three in a Concorde for JFK-LHR is totally a worthwhile trade for a cheaper fare if the six hours are mostly during sleeping hours anyways. There were definitely other problems (the aircraft was a dinosaur, with parts no longer made and a three-person crew; there was no reasonable replacement program on the horizon; the fuel costs of supersonic were hard to justify with the oil prices of the 2000s) but yeah, at some point Concorde's proposition became less and less appealing. FWIW the biggest supersonic contender these days, Boom, is specifically targeting room and per-mile costs for a modern business-class cabin of 50 people, which is a lot more workable from a business perspective. That being said, the money is not really in transatlantic (where you can sleep for 6-8 hours anyways) but in transpacific, because 12+ hours in a plane is a slog no matter how comfy the seat is.
- Pxtl 6y agoThe narrow tunnel-gage of Boring Company is designed for cars... presumably it'd be possible to have a train vehicle with a form-factor more like stretch minivan than a bus. Lots of moving parts because many many more doors to open-close than a traditional bus or subway. But still, if stop-to-stop times are under half an hour, is it okay to seal someone in stretch-minivan-like train car without a bathroom for half an hour? I dunno. It does mean that non-stop from LA to San Jose would be right out though. Being conservative and assuming a 300km/h vehicle, you'd want at least 3 stops along the way if people are completely trapped in the vehicle without even being able to stand up, much less relieve themselves.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis is not how Western property rights work. And most of the cost of tunnels is the requirement for emergency access and ventilation; the small demonstration tunnel in Vegas lacks these features, and so was cheaper. To compare, the Gotthard Base Tunnel in Switzerland requires emergency cross connections every 325m and access shafts to the surface. The cross connections are perpendicular to the main tunnel and short in length so they have to be dug out more or less with workers anyways. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gotthard_Base_Tunnel#/media/File:Nrla_scheme.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gotthard_Base_Tunnel#/media/Fi...
- spookthesunset 6y agoNot just emergency access and ventilation but the stations aren’t cheap or quick to build either. The tunnel itself is almost always the “easy” part.
- bushbaba 6y agoFrom sf to la wouldn’t need stops in between. At most you’d need 1-2 stops in between. I could totally see this as cheaper than dealing with every land owner in between the train’s path
- bobthepanda 6y agoYou still need to deal with every land owner in the path. Property rights don't stop at the surface of the earth.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- underwater 6y agoEmergency access isn't necessary for Boring Company tunnels. They're so narrow that no one is getting out of a vehicle in an emergency in the first place.
- conception 6y agoAs long as all you want is just a tunnel... https://www.indy100.com/science-tech/elon-musk-boring-company-tunnel-b1832455 https://www.indy100.com/science-tech/elon-musk-boring-compan...
- nradov 6y agoThe Boring Company will at best only achieve a small reduction in tunneling costs. This wouldn't fix the economics of passenger rail in California.
- Fern_Blossom 6y agoYou fail to understand construction reality. The LGV route is a far more open and "flatter" (relatively speaking) than LA to SF. There's way less for them to tunnel or grade, which gets expensive quickly. HSR requires more gentle changes in direction than traditional rail. Building on flat, open terrain that no one is using is great... but that kind of terrain is already in use or owned by someone. Thus, easements or having to outright purchase the land. If not and you go for cheap land, it's going to come with downsides, like being mountainous. At that, France sees less than 10 earthquake events over 2 magnitude a year on average. In the past week, there were already 6 events over 2 magnitude between LA and SF alone: https://www.cisn.org/map/index.html https://www.cisn.org/map/index.html An LA to SF line is practically on a fault line. Devastating earthquakes are a real reality for a Cali line, not so much for France. The Cali standards for building rail are going to be higher than France, and for EXTREMELY good reason. Thus, price goes up for construction. There's a lot more at play to building these things. What I mentioned barely scratches the surface to the complications. Claiming NIMBY is pretty naive if you don't take into consideration the real world problems and needs to achieving something compared to the lofty, idealistic wants of a project.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe portion of the CAHSR system being built right now is flatter and more open than most of France, and isn't on or near any of the major fault lines in California. Its outrageous expense has nothing to do with the geographical challenges of California (which are real, but not for this segment) and everything to do with the incompetence of the construction companies and their governmental overseers, as well as NIMBYs exacerbating these problems to epic degrees.
- Fern_Blossom 6y agoSunshine bear, check out the menu on that link. Hit load all from the past week. Next, search the LA to SF proposed HSR route. There were 2 dozen earthquakes along the route between 1-2.5mag and 1 at 2.5mag in the last week. The route was hit by more seismic events in one week than France experiences in a year. Yes, they are planning for earthquakes, as they should. It will be hit one day, in the next decade or so by a large event, and should be well prepared for it. The same way how many states are enacting building codes to reflect 100 year flood statistics instead of treating them as rare events. Long term projects need long term expectations of problems and methods to overcome them. You can't just replace rail like you replace your iPhone. This will inevitably cost them more per mile compared to France. That's actually an very intelligent move to make regarding long term infrastructure. It's funny how the same complaints tech folks make of the construction industry are in parallel with what construction folks say of the tech industry. Both are based off ignorance. I have the pleasant curse of having a foot in both fields. Real world construction is far more complex and difficult than what you imagine. Wide sweeping statements like, "incompetence of the construction companies and their governmental overseers" stinks of you having an cartoonish armchair understanding of what it actual takes from visualized computer renders to a real standing structure. Because civil engineering in the modern age has been a total failure, har har har. Honestly, it's people like you that are easily persuaded to vote for abolishing OSHA on the grounds to hasten construction times and lower costs. Because guess what, Cali construction costs are pretty high due to safety regulations. This is where... oh God forgive me for saying this... I agree with a lot of Cali construction code even though it can be excessive at times, it's warranted a lot of time. Especially because some of it is set for their specific region's character of obstacles... almost like local authorities know best and should enact laws how to construct depending on their local area's nuances! They shouldn't base their construction methods on regions from the other side of the planet!
- treis 6y ago>Because I can't fathom how a 400 miles high-speed rail route can cost $100bn unless you're spending years re-drafting your route because every asshole on the way has to be heard. That's exactly what happens. Not because of NIMBYism but because it's run by consultants on cost plus, T&M, or percentage contracts. They have no incentive to finish the project. And in fact are financially rewarded for making the project more expensive.
- drawkbox 6y agoThe longer we wait to do rail right the more expensive it gets because of NIMBY-ism and property ownership. We need to do it now. Trains are slower in some cases, but the views you simply cannot get from a plane or car. You can work on a train. You can get a private cab. You can get up and move around. You can go to the viewing car and see the beauty of America. You can't do any of that in a plane or car. It is traveling in a much better way, even if longer. Take the Southwest Chief from Flagstaff to Colorado routes and you'd be amazed at how pretty New Mexico is, the deserts of Arizona and the mountains in Colorado. Take any of the coastal lines. You will simply be blown away. The great thing about trains or infrastructure like fiber across America maybe, people will see govt/business in action. It will build platforms of market value that people can see, people in small towns, people all around. People need visuals just like clients need visuals to see progress, even though lots of the work is not visible maybe in code or other areas. The time to train is now. In a way it is the last chance to really get it going before everything is full. We have been robbed of amazing train rides and views. Take any of these routes/lines and tell me you don't enjoy the views. [1] Before you vote on anything related to trains, go take one on our underfunded Amtrak routes. It will change your mind if you are not for it. Imagine if we did this right. Trains use much less fuel, help make pricing for cars/planes competitive and more. Having a third major transportation option besides a bus is needed as we get more packed in. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Amtrak_routes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Amtrak_routes
- fho 6y agoSecond this ... I've been commuting for about 84 km each way each day for five years ... in Germany with the regional trains that took me about 1.5h (and only 40 minutes of that were actual train ride). In that time I would start to work (on the clock), just "sleep in" or work on hobby projects. In the same time a friend of mine in the bay area manages to travel 20 km to the office. As much as I hated commuting ... I'd take commuting by train over commuting by car every day.
- brudgers 6y agoA bus route can do all that and more. A car is even more flexible because you can stop, get out, and become part of the landscape.
- brudgers 6y agoUS rail is private. French rail is national. The French system can use existing right of way without having to acquire right of way.
- gwbrooks 6y agoAmtrak receives well more than $1 billion a year in federal subsidies and still loses millions of dollars per year. It is private only in the broadest sense of the word.
- hakfoo 6y agoAmtrak doesn't own most of its rails. They have to negotiate with, e. g. BNSF and Union Pacific to use their tracks in most of the country. This often has led to limits on services and schedules, because they don't want to repackage their profitable freight offerings, or upgrade trackage sufficient for 100kph freight trains but not 200kph+ modern passenger ones.
- brudgers 6y agoAmtrak doesn't own much right of way.[1] Only about 700 miles. There are about 140,000 miles of track in the US. Nearly all of it in private hands. In France, the railroads are nationalized. A new high speed line doesn't incur the similar costs for right of way acquisitions. [1]: http://blog.amtrak.com/2019/05/why-are-amtrak-trains-delayed-by-freight-trains/ http://blog.amtrak.com/2019/05/why-are-amtrak-trains-delayed...
- mbreese 6y agoBut the point above is that it doesn’t get any of the “benefits” of being public, even if it is a de-facto public entity.
- thatfrenchguy 6y agoThe new TGV are all new right of ways for which they had to buy the lands, except in the suburbs where they go through upgraded original tracks that are shared with suburban trains.
- sbierwagen 6y ago>I can't fathom how a 400 miles high-speed rail route can cost $100bn In the Seattle metro area, about 100 miles of low-speed light rail has cost $75.5 billion so far. Building infrastructure in the US is just inherently more expensive than in other countries. It is a political problem, and unfortunately, only has political solutions.
- aylmao 6y agoA detail worth mentioning: Chūō Shinkansen is maglev line, which are more expensive than high-speed rail too.