3 ms·
> Let’s say you just wanted to perform just one task. Say, recognise a face. Or know whether a number is prime or not. And you didn’t care about flexibility at
by pjc50 6y ago
> Let’s say you just wanted to perform just one task. Say, recognise a face. Or know whether a number is prime or not. And you didn’t care about flexibility at all.
> Could that task be performed by simply the right set of transistors, at the hardware level, no matter how insanely arranged?
For quite a lot of things .. sort of yes. You can do functional reduction. Then you get a chip that does exactly one thing. Which works great until you want to change it. Since change flexibility is incredibly important, that's why we've gone the opposite direction and use microcontrollers for things that could be done with ASICs.
He misinterprets Thompson though; the strange physical effects of the evolved circuits aren't "hidden", they're just outside the model. We rely on simplified models to make behavior predictable, and we design circuits to be as modellable as possible and not use the properties that are hard to model.
- patcon 6y ago> the strange physical effects of the evolved circuits aren't "hidden", they're just outside the model But isn't that all the same -- feels small difference to say it's not "hidden", it's just "outside the model". Go far enough outside the model, and it's as good as hidden. (as opposed to simply going a little outside the model, which is avoided as a mild preference) For example, we don't understand many aspects of the biokinetics of neurotransmitters binding to the active sites of receptors, but the assumption is that in aggregate, things like this are important to our neurochemistry. And this, a million times over for all protein interactions. Things like this are literally still not modellable in a way that's useful to predicting emergent behavior, but despite that, they play a part in how we experience stimuli. For all intents and purposes, this is still "hidden" to us in its complexity. But the environment has nonetheless "selected" (in the evolutionary sense) on the cumulative results for a million years. Sorry, studied biochemistry, so apologies if this seems non-sequitur. It feels quite related to me :)