4 ms·
This seems like a "running before we can walk" statement. Until we can handle day to day problems, it seems weird to worry about edge cases. I imagine as we t
by cogman10 6y ago
This seems like a "running before we can walk" statement. Until we can handle day to day problems, it seems weird to worry about edge cases. I imagine as we transition to renewables and storage we will still have fossil fuel peeker plants to handle these sorts of snaps.
It won't be until our power storage is far more beefed up that we'll shut those down, and that will take years.
- ms4720 6y agoA cold snap like that can happen every 3-5 years, think really cold February. If you don't have the capacity to handle it people will die and lots of things will break. It is not an edgcase
- martinald 6y agoIt's actually worse than that, there are many days in winter in the UK with high demand and virtually no solar/wind output. But obviously a really cold snap would be even worse (and as you said isn't an edge case - even if it is look at the damage that happened in Texas when it wasn't accounted for)
- raverbashing 6y agoAgree. See Texas for an example.
- cogman10 6y agoIt is when we aren't running 1 year on pure renewables. Let's worry about events that happen every 3 to 5 years when we've got 1 year of renewable only figured out. It will take years before this is potentially a problem and by that time we'll likely have gone through a few cold snaps.
- f6v 6y ago> This seems like a "running before we can walk" statement. Europe tries to be at a forefront of green energy. No sun/wind is a real issue there, not just an edge case.
- silon42 6y agoYup, where I live there can be 3 months of fog/clouds... meaning minimal wind / sun.
- oauea 6y agoGlobal warming will resolve that issue soon enough.
- cogman10 6y agoRight, and my point is that they aren't going to decommission all backup power until they are at the point where sun/wind/storage can actually be relied on for more than just the good days. We have a long trip to get there, so why worry about a once in 3/5 year event? We wouldn't go a year without fossil fuels and say "Ok, that was it! Demolish all the plants right now!"
- Qwertious 6y agoArguably, if a gas plant hasn't run for a year then it'll go bankrupt and shut down pretty soon.
- Dylan16807 6y agoIn a system where it's a backup, it shouldn't be both independently owned and have revenue tied only to use.
- canadianfella 6y agoPeople freezing to death isn’t an edge case.