4 ms·
Getting into contact with the Dutch parliament is actually quite easy, if you have a story interesting enough, you can probably get them to read your email and
by jeroenhd 6y ago
Getting into contact with the Dutch parliament is actually quite easy, if you have a story interesting enough, you can probably get them to read your email and forward the Zoom link.
A simple phishing attack should be more than enough to confuse these people. They're almost all exclusively schooled in social sciences, business, history, that kind of thing. Incredibly few of them have any sort of technical background. There are plenty of agencies working their hardest to keep the political leaders safe, but they can't fix the people themselves.
A Dutch journalist managed to get into a "secret" Zoom call with the European ministers of defence after a Dutch politician posted a picture of her screen... with the invite link and most of the password visible. I'm sure they're intelligent people, but when it comes to computers, their young children/grandchildren are probably more capable of securing themselves online than they can.
Also keep in mind that there's an aura of secrecy surrounding Navalny's chief of staff even before the Russian government tried to kill Navalny. Things like routing traffic through TOR and the use of privacy-enhancing technologies like Fastmail can be well explained in an environment where the government actively wants to kill any competition to the current leadership.
In truth, I think these people have fallen for a well-put-together spear phishing attack that worked well because of their lack of digital skills. I strongly doubt that the leaders of other countries will do much better; politicians and tech rarely mix well.
I find it much more troubling that the Dutch government is using Zoom, a product with a terrible history in security problems from a company based in the country that notoriously spied on politicians of even just allied countries. Using American software for government videoconferencing (especially about Russian politics) is a terrible risk.
- toyg 6y agoIt just baffles me how late governments seem to be at establishing secure videoconf applications for their middle-management (which is effectively what MPs are). I would assume most of NATO has better tools for military applications- what is stopping them from repurposing some of these tools for more “everyday” situations?
- ForHackernews 6y agoMPs are not "middle managers". In many countries [0] Parliament is sovereign: Collectively, MPs are the highest authority in the land. Theoretically, if they chose to do so, they could dissolve the judiciary, have anyone they didn't like executed, and declare war on their neighbours. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_sovereignty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_sovereignty
- toyg 6y agoWell, in most countries the sovereign is actually the people, and Parliaments act as intermediary interpreters of the popular will. Hence, middle-management.
- ForHackernews 6y agoNo, that that's not true. In countries with a history of royalty the monarch is sovereign but in modern times that power is vested in Parliament. The notion of popular sovereignty is largely a recent new-world fancy.
- toyg 6y agoI don’t know what your beef is, but what you say it’s not true for France, Germany, Italy, and likely tons more. All these constitutions state explicitly that sovereignty belongs to the people. Even in UK, where Parliament is now sovereign by way of forcing its primacy over the Crown, there are plenty of arguments about this (as recently rehashed), and the question is technically not settled.
- Aeolun 6y ago> the use of privacy-enhancing technologies like Fastmail Fastmail is a privacy enhancing technology now? I thought it was just an email provider?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jeroenhd 6y agoFastmail has a few privacy-enhancing features (one being "paid email that's not connected to a tech giant") and it's one a token technology that's recognisable by end users. It's no Signal or Threema in levels of privacy enhancement, but it's something.
- alfiedotwtf 6y agoFastmail is a great email service, but their service won’t keep you say from state actors