6 ms·
The article is talking about Toronto. You're talking about London. Both of these cities have the distinction of making various lists with titles like "The 11 mo
by roenxi 6y ago
The article is talking about Toronto. You're talking about London. Both of these cities have the distinction of making various lists with titles like "The 11 most expensive cities to live in around the world in 2020" [0].
So while I don't disagree that that far tail of people probably do need some welfare to get a house, I do want to state that if someone is going to get welfare so that they can live in a house, it should not be a house in London. It should be a house somewhere somewhat cheaper than London.
If someone honest to goodness can't keep a roof over their heads, they deserve help but really shouldn't be trying to make it work in one of the worlds most expensive cities.
[0] https://www.insider.com/most-expensive-cities-to-live-in-2020-1 https://www.insider.com/most-expensive-cities-to-live-in-202...
- joshjdr 6y agoThe article is talking about tiny temporary shelters, not giving away houses, or expensive flats.
- roenxi 6y agoI live in one of the cities listed and if I were allowed to build my own shelter in the middle of one of it's public parks, I too would jump at the opportunity. This is some of the worlds most desirable real estate here. This isn't even a case of bad government policy, which I would usually arc up about. The article is homeless people taking over public land for private use without doing anything to justify that privilege. That isn't fair, if it is up for grabs I want it and I'd be behind a long queue of other people who want it. The right to use that land is worth a fortune. Being homeless, while sad, is not actually something that should be rewarded with free space in the centre of a metropolis. If we are going to support them, we can support them to live somewhere less desirable.
- joshjdr 6y agoConsider that often these situations are temporary. And consider that cities are where support services are. And consider that if you can’t afford a home you probably can’t afford a car. I just don’t think anybody is homeless in Toronto or London or any other city for the same reasons that rich people make them expensive cities. I’m pretty sure many homeless, if offered a home in the countryside, would happily oblige.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoWell, most of them would be foolish to accept - they'd be trading a chance at getting the services they need for better immediate shelter, but be trapped in an economic dead end with no social services, no health care, lousy education and no way out. And then someone would whine that we shouldn't give handouts to people who live in rural areas, they should eat some bootstraps and move somewhere with opportunities......
- JohnCohorn 6y ago> if you can’t afford a home you probably can’t afford a car That’s simply untrue. Owning a car is vastly less expensive than renting a dwelling in most cities. I’ve known people that went homeless, and it’s pretty common for them to...live in their car.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoThose cars and vans quickly become non functional, however, at least where I live. The tires deflate and they become a hard temporary shelter that occupies on street parking rather than space for a tent in a park.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoThe rich and homeless should be equally forbidden to build small shelters in the park? That sounds like it's been said before.
- webmaven 6y ago> The rich and homeless should be equally forbidden to build small shelters in the park? That sounds like it's been said before. You're probably thinking of this Anatole France[0] quote: “The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread.” [0] https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France
- lazyasciiart 6y agoYes.
- specialist 6y agoWhat are your thoughts about squatting? There's always fallow private lands, easements, empty parking lots, abandoned warehouses, etc.
- sopp 6y agoIn most large cities squatting cannot be a longer term solution, as it often doesnt take long to be explused from a place (in paris for example squats stay around from 2 to 6 months on average if you are lucky enough to manage to secure the place for the first week or so). Also depending on who runs and occupies the building, it might actually not always be a safe/sane housing option neither.
- specialist 6y agoAgree with all. My open question wrt to squatting is the potential to incentivize keeping real estate in active use. If "use it or lose it" is official policy, it might help mitigate hoarding. A bit like some cities are now penalizing unoccupied condos, where investors buy up condos and then don't even rent them out.
- II2II 6y agoA couple of things to consider: This is a marginal case of private use of public lands. These are shelters, rather than homes. The size (2' by 6') and construction offers little more than physical security while sleeping. There are reasons why some homeless people prefer parks. For example: parks tend to be closer to social services and other means of support. There are also homeless people who find other places to squat. > If we are going to support them, we can support them to live somewhere less desirable. Unfortunately, there are also people who believe that type of support means forced relocation. There are many reasons to oppose force relocation. In the mildest of terms, it is never intended to solve the root problem of poverty.
- roenxi 6y agoThere is a line to be drawn on what people can do in public parks. At the extremes: * It is totally reasonable that people sit in them and enjoy the sun. * It is totally unreasonable for a billionaire to wall a section off and build a mansion in it. Now we can debate where that line is drawn, but a professionally built plywood structure with door locks and smoke detectors is a lot closer to the unacceptable end than the alternative. That is starting to build up a permanent dwelling in a public space. I don't know how to solve homelessness, and I'll admit to not trying very hard. But if we can just hive off public spaces for people to live on, then there is no way the homeless are getting first pick. I know people who had to leave a major city due to housing costs and move to the country. If the topic of debate is repurposing public land for longer-term dwellings, they should get priority access to it over these homeless people.
- mikem170 6y agoMaybe we need to dedicate lots where self-policing groups of homeless people can put their temporary shelters, provide them with a porta potty, somewhere near a bus stop so they can get to work. This would be such a boon for so many struggling people.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoMost people have little choice in where they live. It doesn't matter if the city you live in is expensive: When you are poor, you can't move. Some people might like to move: Others would not. Forcing folks to move can easily mean forcing folks to leave behind what family and friends they have, and seems cruel. Some of the folks will have jobs that don't pay enough to live in the city they work in, and I don't think we should punish people by making them have hours of commuting either. "You are too poor to live here" is also "you are too poor to afford to take this basic job" as well as "you are too poor to stay around anyone you know".
- jobjob 6y agoPeople move all the time when they get a job. Why should people who have lost a job and are about to be homeless not be required to move to a lower cost area in order to get free housing? If need be transportation can be provided.
- dTal 6y agoI take it you've not been in this situation.
- jobjob 6y agoI’ve gotten jobs and moved. I’ve lost jobs and moved. What’s your point?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoSure. Poor people don't do this all the time, though. Moving requires things like deposits and first months' rent. If you change utility companies? More deposits. I've had to turn down jobs because I couldn't afford the startup costs. One was just red shirts, and I couldn't afford one. A time or two, the reason I was able to move was because I could stay with family. Transportation isn't enough. People should be able to live near work: Being poor shouldn't mean spending 4 hours a day on commutes. Being poor shouldn't mean moving away from people you know just to have shelter, a basic need. And so on.
- mlindner 6y agoHomelessness exists in cities because it's possible to be homeless in cities. It's not possible to be homeless (without a vehicle) outside cities. Ergo, cities cultivate homelessness. If you make living as a homeless person impossible in cities, homelessness would disappear.
- iovrthoughtthis 6y agothe sim city way.
- dTal 6y agoBy what mechanism would homelessness disappear? What would happen to the existing and newly homeless? Because it sounds like the answer is "starvation to death". Most people would regard that as pretty inhumane.
- burntoutfire 6y agoYou assume that none of the homeless can lift themselves up from homelessness. I've read some interviews with them, and it seems that a portion of them just prefers homelessness to hard physical work for meager pay (which is an only option available for them). With the support systems provided by cities and states, homelessness can be seen as a favorable option by people who have an extreme aversion for labor (not to mention that without having to show up for work every morning they can freely pursue their drinking habit). I don't see that angle discussed here.
- mlindner 6y agoI don't propose a mechanism. Just pointing out the reasoning.
- nulbyte 6y agoRural homeless isn't just possible; it exists.[0] [0]: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/07/04/736240349/in-rural-areas-homeless-people-are-harder-to-find-and-to-help https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/07/04/7362403...
- bregma 6y agoA lot of homeless people have jobs. Jobs are in the city. Are you suggesting all the homeless need to do is rent a parking space downtown for their Bentley and they can commute from a nice tent in a farmer's field outside of town? For goodness sakes, a shack on a lake north of Toronto goes for millions of dollars these days [0]. A few years ago a conservative government in Alberta tried to solve their homeless problem by giving free one-way tickets to Vancouver to the homeless instead of welfare cheques. Dumping your problem on someone else converts a cost into an economic externality but is sure to get you hated. [0] http://muskokacottagesforsale.net/real-estate-properties/ http://muskokacottagesforsale.net/real-estate-properties/
- slothtrop 6y agoThe other distinction with Toronto is the government hasn't "removed their welfare" as the other user suggests. Most of the homeless have a source of income.
- diogenescynic 6y agoIs it really surprising that drug addicts can’t afford housing in the most expensive cities in the world? In San Francisco we are constantly fed propaganda to tell us this is a housing crisis, but someone on meth or heroin can’t afford the rent regardless if it’s in SF or Des Moines. The drugs are the big issue but no one wants to address it.
- randomsearch 6y ago> The article is talking about Toronto. You're talking about London. Sorry, no I wasn't, my fault for not being clearer. I gave an example of London but my experience is beyond that city, that's just where I happened to talk directly with a lot of homeless people about why they were on the streets. My observations generalise to the rest of my experience, for sure, including in very poor towns with low rents in the UK.