7 ms·
So my sister does professional photography, and went from a 16GB MacBook Pro(2016) to an 8GB Air, and reports no decrease of productivity - quite the opposite,
by gambiting 6y ago
So my sister does professional photography, and went from a 16GB MacBook Pro(2016) to an 8GB Air, and reports no decrease of productivity - quite the opposite, in her experience all Adobe programs run much faster, and the machine is quieter and lighter to boot. So yeah, I'm not sure - maybe the ram amount isn't as a big deal as people make it out to be. On the other hand I'm a C++ programer and my workstation has 128GB of ram and I wouldn't accept any less.....so obviously it varies.
- cigaser 6y agoThat machine is using swap file a lot, in couple of years SSD will die.
- nisegami 6y agoPretty sure that Apple considers this a feature.
- Toutouxc 6y agoFunny. Except there are fully supported MacBooks from 2013 running the latest version of macOS, still on their first battery, still bringing people joy and productivity.
- asoneth 6y agoOr in my case, a 2012 MacBook Air. I hope they'll support Catalina for another three or four years or at which point it's more than a decade old and can finally mature into a laptop's final stage of life as a Linux machine.
- officeplant 6y agoThey tend to support OS releases for three years. Catalina EOL is likely to be sometime in 2022.
- asoneth 6y agoI stand corrected. I'd attribute my false confidence to the fact that even the previous version (macOS 10.4 Mojave) is still supported. But now that I think about it that'll likely change at the Apple WWDC in June. Still, decently satisfied with ~10 years of software support for a laptop.
- officeplant 6y agoMojave Support ends this year right on time for 3 years. I finally left Mojave behind myself as I really wasn't using the older apps catalina lost support for anyway.
- leoc 6y agoLate-2013 MBPs still came with replaceable storage unlike the M1 Macs, no?
- codydh 6y agoYup. My personal machine is a base Late 2013 15” MacBook Pro (8GB RAM). Original battery, original storage, it saw very heavy usage up until a a couple of years ago. Still fast, decent battery.
- arvinsim 6y agoWeb Developer here. Wouldn't accept anything less than 32GB for a work machine.
- jimbokun 6y agoBut have you benchmarked your workflow on x86+32GB vs M1+8GB?
- scoopertrooper 6y agoI'm typing this response on a 8GB M1. It's great, but its no magic. Its limitations do start to show in memory intensive and heavily multi-threaded workloads. Getting some down votes, which I attribute to reasonable skepticism, so hopefully this will allay your concerns. https://ibb.co/VM4Z1DY https://ibb.co/VM4Z1DY
- hiq 6y ago> memory intensive and heavily multi-threaded workloads Such as?
- scoopertrooper 6y agoOne example, I was trying download all the dependencies for the Kafka project via Gradle with IntelliJ while watching a video on YouTube and working on another project in Visual Studio Code. The video started to stutter then stopped and Visual Studo Code became responsive. I basically had to shut a bunch of stuff down and go to lunch. I haven't seen a modern computer struggle with that kind of workload before.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoEnd of the day the Intel Macbooks of the last few years have been terrible low performance processors that get thermal constrained and have abysmal inconsistent battery life. So if all you use is Macs the M1 is going to feel amazing.
- cj 6y ago
- Spooky23 6y agoThe sweet spot is 8GB for most people. I’d guess 80% 8GB/15% 16GB and 5% more. Even many types of developers are fine with 8. Apple collects a lot of metrics and I’m sure they know this well.
- cainxinth 6y agoThe M1 also means that Apple regains full stack control of its desktops and laptops. Their phones and tablets prove that when they develop both the main chips and operating systems themselves, they are able to eke out greater performance from lesser specs. Flagship iPhones always have less ram than flagship androids, but match or exceed their performance.
- fortran77 6y agoIt's the Gigabyte Myth! Less is more! Up is down! In is out!
- Spooky23 6y agoThat may help a bit but unless they adopt that draconian policies that govern iOS runtime that impact is limited. Safari is an example of improved battery life when Apple owns the stack. It’s a great feature, but not a game changer. Most business users were fine with 4GB 5-6 years ago. Electron apps like Teams and Slack pushed it up to 8. The next tier are folks with IDEs, docker, etc that are usually 16-32GB.
- guidoism 6y agoI agree. Honestly electron used the main thing pushing up ram usage these days for most people.
- jopsen 6y agoRunning a few Google Docs tabs and I can easily bring my 16GB Linux laptop down..
- dmos62 6y ago> I'm a C++ programer and my workstation has 128GB of ram and I wouldn't accept any less What on earth are you programming?
- choeger 6y agoHe won't know until all the templates are instantiated...
- dundercoder 6y ago>What on earth are you programming? Earth. He is programming the earth.
- gambiting 6y agoAAA video games do that for you :P Well, it isn't the programming part that uses the ram(although yes, building our codebase takes about 40 minutes and uses gigabytes of ram without using distributed build), but just starting up local server + client + editor easily uses 80-100GB of ram since ALL of the assets are loaded in.
- darknavi 6y agoWhen VS decides to disk bomb you or uses literally 120GB of ram because its auto scaling trips up.
- 6y ago
- presentation 6y agoWeb developer, I had an 8GB M1 MacBook Air and if I ran vscode with my 50kish typescript codebase and dev server for api and frontend + native postgres and redis at the same time I’d be right at the limit of my machine slowing to unusable levels. Switched it for a 16GB one and I’ve never had any noticeable performance issues since.
- _fat_santa 6y agoI think the efficiency of the new M1 is what blows everyone away. When the M1 first came out I was super super skeptical, seemed like an under powered chip compared to what's in the x86 world. Now I'm convinced that it's got some magic inside it. Everyone I've talked to said it chews throw whatever they throw at it. I'm consistently floored by Apple's ability to innovate.
- Solstinox 6y agoIt’s funny you say “innovate.” They certainly innovated with the M1, but with one key difference. They did so in public, step-by-step over the course of a decade. Perhaps more than any other Apple innovation, we have the greatest visibility into the process with the M1.
- bredren 6y agoI consider ability to perform open development of future products a key differentiator for Apple. Like Jobs said in his Stanford speech, “You can't connect the dots looking forward; you can only connect them looking backwards. So you have to trust that the dots will somehow connect in your future.” It seems like Apple uniquely combines open development of technology in known products with secrecy around new product development. This allows people to be so surprised by the M1, when the late AX processors were obviously pointing toward massive capability. I believe there are other examples of this happening--specifically with the Apple Watch. On that product, the size limitations combined with increasing expectations of performance and functionality have allowed Apple learn and improve production-capability in many areas that will be in any forthcoming AR/VR products.
- havernator 6y agoIn ~2018 I briefly used an old 4GB MacBook Pro for work. It was only untenable longer-term because I needed to run two electron apps or many-hundreds-of-MB-memory tabs at a time, sometimes.
- Aperocky 6y agoBut why not 16G? It's a small price increase compared to base and it would basically make it much more usable in any extended amount of time, especially given the SSD write 'bug' that were exposed.