9 ms·
I know, "Not your keys, not your coins". However, most people have no idea about the technicalities of the crypto and because transfer fees range from not-zero
by mrtksn 6y ago
I know, "Not your keys, not your coins". However, most people have no idea about the technicalities of the crypto and because transfer fees range from not-zero to ridiculous, as long as the arbitrage between exchanges stays minimal there's no motivation to ever move crypto anywhere so for most people crypto currency is simply the number in their account on a website.
- knocte 6y ago> and because transfer fees range from not-zero to ridiculous This problem has been solved already: just stick to using exchanges that support Lightning (e.g. Bitaroo, Bitfinex, Bitnovo, etc)
- grey-area 6y agoBitfinex No danger of fraud there!
- joosters 6y agoCatch-22: To open a lightning channel, you need to make a transaction (and so pay the high fees), but to pay that fee, you'll need to already have coins in a wallet that you control - which you can only achieve by withdrawing some coins from the exchange. So your 'solution' is for people to withdraw some coins, paying a high fee, then open a lightning channel (again, paying another high fee), make a lightning transaction (beta software, coins at risk, barely functional, better hope you're running the lightning software 24/7 to ensure you don't get ripped off!) and finally you have your coins in your own wallet. What a bargain! Currency of the future!
- gruez 6y ago>Catch-22: To open a lightning channel, you need to make a transaction (and so pay the high fees), but to pay that fee, you'll need to already have coins in a wallet that you control - which you can only achieve by withdrawing some coins from the exchange. I'm not sure whether any exchanges implement this, but theoretically they can withdraw and open a channel at the same time. ie. instead of withdrawing 0.1 BTC, they deposit 0.1BTC to a channel and send all the funds to you. >beta software It's used in production by various merchants so I'm not sure how relevant this is. Speaking of which, isn't bitcoin itself "beta" as well? ie. the version number is still 0.x.x >barely functional ??? >better hope you're running the lightning software 24/7 to ensure you don't get ripped off AFAIK the period is somewhere between 1 week or 2 weeks (don't remember which), and you can have third parties do the monitoring for you.
- joosters 6y agoBeta software: http://lightning.network/docs/ http://lightning.network/docs/ reports that the design of the network is still only in draft form, never mind the software! (those pesky details like routing, which are a difficult problem, are mostly elided in the documents so far) The main lightning daemon, https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd is still beta, with plenty of warnings in the docs about shortcomings and potential loss of funds. I'm sure people use it, but the developers are very clear that it it is not to be trusted: https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/blob/master/docs/safety.md https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/blob/master/docs/saf... says that it is 'considered reckless to put any life altering amounts of BTC into the network' - how can anyone consider this to be production quality? you can have third parties do the monitoring for you Not your keys/monitor, not your coins! We're back to square one, aren't we? With just some dodgy software and additional complexity papering over the critical flaws.
- gruez 6y ago>reports that the design of the network is still only in draft form last updated 2016 >(those pesky details like routing, which are a difficult problem, are mostly elided in the documents so far) Can you elaborate on why routing is a difficult problem? Pathfinding and flowgraphs are solved problems in computer science. >I'm sure people use it, but the developers are very clear that it it is not to be trusted: https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/blob/master/docs/saf https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/blob/master/docs/saf... says that it is 'considered reckless to put any life altering amounts of BTC into the network' - it's considered reckless to put any life altering amounts of money into a volatile cryptocurrency (or for that matter, even a single stock) >how can anyone consider this to be production quality? it's considered production quality because merchants are willing to put hundreds of thousands of dollars into it. >Not your keys/monitor, not your coins! watchtowers don't require your keys.
- hanniabu 6y agoYou mean the centralized off chain network that's riddled with bugs and horrible UX?
- atoav 6y agoI get all that, but it is a bit like having a perfectly good safe at home and still carrying your gold to the bank because opening it is a bit cumbersome and fidgety. Kinda defeats the purpose of having a decentralized cryptocurrency.
- mustafa_pasi 6y agoStoring all your gold at home is your super secure safe is also not very smart though. I am actually surprised we do not see more robberies of this kind targeting Bitcoin billionaires.
- Viker 6y agoHere is the irony of crypto vs gold... You can secure ur gold physically very well, fires and natural disasters short of volcano, yet it is easy to steal it at gunpoint. Crypto is hard and cumbersome to secure ( paper keys, hw Wallets), yet very hard to steal at gunpoint.
- leereeves 6y agoHard to steal at gunpoint? Who is going to refuse to hand over their keys when the choice is "Your Bitcoin keys or your life"?
- Viker 6y agoSure. I can hand you a handful of USB sticks about 20 paper wallets maybe a hard disk or two...and tell you, here are my keys. Now what you do? Do you put down your gun and start verifying which one is with actual funds or, do you know what is a usb drive and what is a hw wallet? Are you gonna ask me for my password too. How do you know you actually stole something worthwhile? How do you know I am not going to be faster transferring the coins to different wallets? All that is vs. "show me gold, shiny ohh heavy". You see the levels of complications....
- 6y ago
- mustafa_pasi 6y agoI reckon 95% of people are also in it for speculation, and then you must have your coins always at the exchange, cause you never know when Elon Musk decides to pump, or when the FED or China or the EU decide to make a move. To move coins takes hours last I tried it and as you say the fees are also ridiculous now.
- mrjin 6y agoThat defeats the claimed purpose: decentralization, isn't it?
- Filligree 6y agoSure, absolutely. Most Bitcoiners don't care; they're in it for the speculation.